Talk:The Beast Below (TV story): Difference between revisions
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 32: | Line 32: | ||
== Third in a row with an unknown amount of time passing? What? == | == Third in a row with an unknown amount of time passing? What? == | ||
This sentence formerly in the lead is completely incoherent, baffling, and arguably false. (How is the gap before ''Planet of the Dead'' or ''The Next Doctor'' clear? | This sentence formerly in the lead is completely incoherent, baffling, and arguably false. (How is the gap before ''Planet of the Dead'' or ''The Next Doctor'' clear? Don't the majority of RTD stories have an ambiguous gap in them and even be possibly placed anywhere between the premiere and the finale?) -- [[User:Tybort|Tybort]] ([[User talk:Tybort|talk page]]) 21:29, May 31, 2013 (UTC) | ||
: It also the third consecutive story in a row which has an unknown amount of time pass since the episode prior to it. This began with ''[[The End of Time (TV story)|The End of Time]]''; this would continue until ''[[Amy's Choice]]''. The first ''[[Meanwhile in the TARDIS]]'' short occurs right before this episode. | : It also the third consecutive story in a row which has an unknown amount of time pass since the episode prior to it. This began with ''[[The End of Time (TV story)|The End of Time]]''; this would continue until ''[[Amy's Choice]]''. The first ''[[Meanwhile in the TARDIS]]'' short occurs right before this episode. | ||
Revision as of 21:31, 31 May 2013
Solutions
I think I have the answers to most of these questions/suggestions/comments.
- A "simple fly-by" may not have actually revealed the star whale, as I think the hull was actually built around it, shutting it in.
- The water didn't vibrate on the floor or on the table, and that was why the Doctor was confused. Also, the area where everybody lived and worked may have been blocked off from the engine zone, but the Doctor probably just didn't care. It never shows or says that it isn't buffered away. Finally, the humans were trying to find a new planet, so they were going somewhere. They just didn't know where that somewhere was. Also, they needed to find that somewhere so that they could re-stock. Ever read The City of Ember? The situation would have kind have been like that, so they needed to find the new planet fast, before they all starved to death.
- Ah, here's a tricky one. You see, they were humans. Sadly, we humans seem to have very little regard for things that are not like us (not unlike the Daleks. Good luck sleeping!), and I think the thought never really occured to them that it could have come out of pity for the human race to save them. However, this brings us to another question (the tricky part), one that I would like somebody to answer: Why were Britain, Wales and Ireland the only countries in the whole wide world who couldn't just build a ship with a proper engine?!?!? So, yeah. If any philosophers out there have the answer to that question, please answer it. Now the rest. The ship, in all probability, wouldn't have disintegrated, but it would have been fragmented. As I said earlier, I'm rather sure the ship was built around the star whale, and it was also anchored together by the star whale. However, when the star whale stays, it keeps all the stuff on its back from falling to bits. I also think the reason Hawthorn didn't need a memory wipe was that he seemed like a rather emotionless person anyway and was unlikely to have emotional trauma. Also, I think he worked in the Tower of London, and so he would have seen the exposed brain and everything all the time, so unless they wanted to give him a memory wipe every five seconds, (which would prevent him from doing his job) he simply had to know.
- The Doctor probably didn't know about the star whale because: a) The facts were never made public and so he could not have found that out, or b) he did not think to research how it moved because he simply assumed it had an engine.
There you go! Hope I've been a help.
70.68.62.31 23:46, August 13, 2011 (UTC)
Post Regeneration Hours
This adventure toke place immediately after the Doctor scared off the Atraxi and toke the TARDIS for a test drive to break in the new engines. I'm guessing that it's still the first fifteen hours of his post-regenration, where he can heal severed limbs and minor injures easily like the Tenth Doctor did. (173.167.179.77talk to me 01:54, January 25, 2013 (UTC))
- I personally don't really see the relevance. He didn't suffer any injuries in this episode. Unlike River and the Tenth Doctor, the Eleventh Doctor didn't used this to his advantage. SmallerOnTheOutside ☎ 02:26, January 25, 2013 (UTC)
Reference to The End of Time?
Near the end of the episode, before receiving the call from Churchill, Amy has the following dialogue with the Doctor:
Amy: "Have you ever run away from something because you were scared or not ready, or just because you could?"
Doctor: "Once, a long time ago."
Amy: "What happened?"
Doctor: "Hello."
Would this be a reference to the Tenth Doctor running away from his prophesied death (and regeneration) prior to meeting with Ood Sigma?
Third in a row with an unknown amount of time passing? What?
This sentence formerly in the lead is completely incoherent, baffling, and arguably false. (How is the gap before Planet of the Dead or The Next Doctor clear? Don't the majority of RTD stories have an ambiguous gap in them and even be possibly placed anywhere between the premiere and the finale?) -- Tybort (talk page) 21:29, May 31, 2013 (UTC)
- It also the third consecutive story in a row which has an unknown amount of time pass since the episode prior to it. This began with The End of Time; this would continue until Amy's Choice. The first Meanwhile in the TARDIS short occurs right before this episode.
