Tardis:Canon policy: Difference between revisions

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
(clearing up language a little bit, shifting some info to Tardis:Resources and making non-DW universe canon sources a little clearer)
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
''(Important: This is currently only a draft policy. Please feel free to expand upon this article, and also to discuss the issue on [[Tardis talk:Canon policy]].)''
''(Important: This is currently only a draft policy. Please feel free to expand upon this article, and also to discuss the issue on [[Tardis talk:Canon policy]].)''


The goal of the TARDIS Index File is to be a reliable, concise guide to all readers. Towards this end, it is necessary for us to restrict to some extent the type of information we accept.
The goal of the TARDIS Index File is to be a reliable, concise guide to all readers. Towards this end, it is necessary for us to restrict to some extent the type of information we accept.


==Types of article==
==Types of article==
Line 7: Line 7:
* [[Doctor Who Universe]] articles
* [[Doctor Who Universe]] articles
:* Any subject mentioned in or derived from a television story, prose story, comic story, radio or audio drama. This type is further divided into two sub-types:
:* Any subject mentioned in or derived from a television story, prose story, comic story, radio or audio drama. This type is further divided into two sub-types:
::* ''[[Doctor Who]]'', ''[[Torchwood]]'', ''[[The Sarah Jane Adventures]]'' and ''[[K-9 and Company]]'' - Subjects seen or mentioned in these series.  
::* ''[[Doctor Who]]'', ''[[Torchwood]]'', ''[[The Sarah Jane Adventures]]'' and ''[[K-9 and Company]]'' - Subjects seen or mentioned in these series.
::* Spin-offs - Any subject seen or mentioned in prose (novels, novellas and short stories), audio and comic stories, officially sanctioned by the [[BBC]] and/or license holders.  
::* Spin-offs - Any subject seen or mentioned in prose (novels, novellas and short stories), audio and comic stories, officially sanctioned by the [[BBC]] and/or license holders.


*Other Universes - Stories which are not necessarily part of 'canon' but derived from the [[Doctor Who Universe]], i.e. ''[[Dr. Who and the Daleks]]'' and parodies such as ''[[The Curse of Fatal Death]]'', authorized, though not part of 'canon'.
*Other Universes - Stories which are not necessarily part of 'canon' but derived from the [[Doctor Who Universe]], i.e. ''[[Dr. Who and the Daleks]]'' and parodies such as ''[[The Curse of Fatal Death]]'', authorised, though not part of 'canon'.


* Real World/Out of universe
* Real World/Out of universe
:* Information on stories set in the [[Doctor Who Universe]].
:* Information on stories set in the [[Doctor Who Universe]].
:* Information on the creators and actors who have taken part in the making of the stories.
:* Information on the creators and actors who have taken part in the making of the stories.
:* Related topics.  
:* Related topics.
:::''For additional resources of information for Real World articles see [[Tardis:Resources]].''  
:::''For additional resources of information for Real World articles see [[Tardis:Resources]].''


The policy of the TARDIS Index File with regards to acceptable sources for use in articles is as follows:
The policy of the TARDIS Index File with regards to acceptable sources for use in articles is as follows:
Line 25: Line 25:
*Spin-offs such as ''[[Torchwood]]'', ''[[The Sarah Jane Adventures]]'', ''[[K-9 and Company]]'' and ''[[K-9 (TV series)]]''.
*Spin-offs such as ''[[Torchwood]]'', ''[[The Sarah Jane Adventures]]'', ''[[K-9 and Company]]'' and ''[[K-9 (TV series)]]''.
*All other [[Doctor Who spin-offs]] such as those produced by [[BBV Productions]] and [[Reeltime Pictures]] (i.e ''[[P.R.O.B.E.]]'', ''[[Auton Trilogy]]'' and ''[[Shakedown: Return of the Sontarans]]'', ''[[Downtime]]'')
*All other [[Doctor Who spin-offs]] such as those produced by [[BBV Productions]] and [[Reeltime Pictures]] (i.e ''[[P.R.O.B.E.]]'', ''[[Auton Trilogy]]'' and ''[[Shakedown: Return of the Sontarans]]'', ''[[Downtime]]'')
*All [[Target Books]] novels ''not'' based on a broadcast television story (i.e., ''[[The Nightmare Fair]]'', ''[[Turlough and the Earthlink Dilemma]]'')  
*All [[Target Books]] novels ''not'' based on a broadcast television story (i.e., ''[[The Nightmare Fair]]'', ''[[Turlough and the Earthlink Dilemma]]'')
*All [[Virgin Missing Adventures]], [[Virgin New Adventures]] and [[Virgin Bernice Summerfield New Adventures]] stories (i.e., ''[[Timewyrm: Genesys]]'', ''[[The Sorcerer's Apprentice]]'', ''[[Beige Planet Mars]]'')  
*All [[Virgin Missing Adventures]], [[Virgin New Adventures]] and [[Virgin Bernice Summerfield New Adventures]] stories (i.e., ''[[Timewyrm: Genesys]]'', ''[[The Sorcerer's Apprentice]]'', ''[[Beige Planet Mars]]'')
*All [[BBC Books]] [[BBC Eighth Doctor Adventures|Eighth Doctor]], [[BBC New Series Adventures#Ninth Doctor|Ninth Doctor]], [[BBC New Series Adventures#Tenth Doctor|Tenth Doctor]], [[BBC New Series Adventures#Eleventh Doctor|Eleventh Doctor]] and [[BBC Past Doctor Adventures|Past Doctor]] novels (i.e., ''[[The Eight Doctors]]'', ''[[The Clockwise Man]]'', ''[[The Stone Rose]]'', ''[[The Witch Hunters]]'').
*All [[BBC Books]] [[BBC Eighth Doctor Adventures|Eighth Doctor]], [[BBC New Series Adventures#Ninth Doctor|Ninth Doctor]], [[BBC New Series Adventures#Tenth Doctor|Tenth Doctor]], [[BBC New Series Adventures#Eleventh Doctor|Eleventh Doctor]] and [[BBC Past Doctor Adventures|Past Doctor]] novels (i.e., ''[[The Eight Doctors]]'', ''[[The Clockwise Man]]'', ''[[The Stone Rose]]'', ''[[The Witch Hunters]]'').
*All [[Telos Publishing]] novellas (i.e, ''[[Frayed]]'', ''[[Rip Tide]]'', ''[[Fallen Gods]]'')
*All [[Telos Publishing]] novellas (i.e, ''[[Frayed]]'', ''[[Rip Tide]]'', ''[[Fallen Gods]]'')
Line 52: Line 52:
:''This section is still in flux, as the policy is still under debate.''
:''This section is still in flux, as the policy is still under debate.''
*Material from [[FASA]]'s ''[[The Doctor Who Role Playing Game]]'' and other Role Playing games, as these sometimes contain histories and other information which conflicts with the television and prose stories.
*Material from [[FASA]]'s ''[[The Doctor Who Role Playing Game]]'' and other Role Playing games, as these sometimes contain histories and other information which conflicts with the television and prose stories.
:''Some material from the FASA game was incorporated into [[Virgin Publishing]]'s [[Virgin Missing Adventures|Missing]] and [[Virgin New Adventures|New Adventures]] series. Such info should be cited to the NAs/MAs in which they appear, rather than the FASA materials.''
:''Some material from the FASA game was incorporated into [[Virgin Publishing]]'s [[Virgin Missing Adventures|Missing]] and [[Virgin New Adventures|New Adventures]] series. Such info should be cited to the NAs/MAs in which they appear, rather than the FASA materials.''
*Merchandise - Several items of merchandise are often given names that never appear in dialogue or are never seen on screen and have often been produced for marketing purposes.  
*Merchandise - Several items of merchandise are often given names that never appear in dialogue or are never seen on screen and have often been produced for marketing purposes.
*Fan-made blueprints and specifications  
*Fan-made blueprints and specifications
*Fan fiction of any kind (this includes [[Wikipedia:Fanon_(fiction)#Nature_of_fictional_canons|fanon]]).
*Fan fiction of any kind (this includes [[Wikipedia:Fanon_(fiction)#Nature_of_fictional_canons|fanon]]).
*Websites, unless information is clearly stated as sourced listed on the [[Tardis:Resources]] page.
*Websites, unless information is clearly stated as sourced listed on the [[Tardis:Resources]] page.


==Items on which policy is unclear==
==Items on which policy is unclear==
*The relevance of ''[[The Doctor Who Technical Manual]]'', the in-universe history presented in part of ''[[The Terrestrial Index]]'', ''[[The Doctor Who Monster Book]]'' and similar items and their suitability for use in creating and contributing to articles in the TARDIS Index File is unclear at this time, and up for discussion.  
*The relevance of ''[[The Doctor Who Technical Manual]]'', the in-universe history presented in part of ''[[The Terrestrial Index]]'', ''[[The Doctor Who Monster Book]]'' and similar items and their suitability for use in creating and contributing to articles in the TARDIS Index File is unclear at this time, and up for discussion.
*Background information from the production staff ([[Sydney Newman]], [[Verity Lambert]], [[John Nathan-Turner]], [[Russell T Davies]], etc) should either be included under the relevant background section (where available), or added to the article's Talk page where its validity can be assessed for inclusion.
*Background information from the production staff ([[Sydney Newman]], [[Verity Lambert]], [[John Nathan-Turner]], [[Russell T Davies]], etc) should either be included under the relevant background section (where available), or added to the article's Talk page where its validity can be assessed for inclusion.



Revision as of 18:53, 18 January 2011

(Important: This is currently only a draft policy. Please feel free to expand upon this article, and also to discuss the issue on Tardis talk:Canon policy.)

The goal of the TARDIS Index File is to be a reliable, concise guide to all readers. Towards this end, it is necessary for us to restrict to some extent the type of information we accept.

Types of article

There are three types of articles:

  • Any subject mentioned in or derived from a television story, prose story, comic story, radio or audio drama. This type is further divided into two sub-types:
  • Real World/Out of universe
  • Information on stories set in the Doctor Who Universe.
  • Information on the creators and actors who have taken part in the making of the stories.
  • Related topics.
For additional resources of information for Real World articles see Tardis:Resources.

The policy of the TARDIS Index File with regards to acceptable sources for use in articles is as follows:

What is considered a valid source?

This section is still in flux, as the policy is still under debate.

Secondary sources

See also Tardis:Resources for more resources for writing articles

These sources are valid sources, however should not be the only source for an article.

  • Novelisations of broadcast television stories by Target Books and other publishers may be used, however any information that contradicts that novelisation's TV story's information is to be considered apocryphal and should not be included within the main body of the article.

Other universe sources

The following sources are valid but are a deliberate break from Doctor Who Universe canon and therefore should only be used for articles relating to the worlds, individuals and objects etc created in the sources.

What is not considered a valid source, and why?

This section is still in flux, as the policy is still under debate.
  • Material from FASA's The Doctor Who Role Playing Game and other Role Playing games, as these sometimes contain histories and other information which conflicts with the television and prose stories.
Some material from the FASA game was incorporated into Virgin Publishing's Missing and New Adventures series. Such info should be cited to the NAs/MAs in which they appear, rather than the FASA materials.
  • Merchandise - Several items of merchandise are often given names that never appear in dialogue or are never seen on screen and have often been produced for marketing purposes.
  • Fan-made blueprints and specifications
  • Fan fiction of any kind (this includes fanon).
  • Websites, unless information is clearly stated as sourced listed on the Tardis:Resources page.

Items on which policy is unclear

Deleting invalid articles

If you believe an article contains nothing but non-canon information, or is sourced solely from non-valid resources, then the article should be noted with a {{proposed deletion}} template/banner, which will alert others to the article's invalidity and allow others to defend it.

If an article is concerning a canon subject but contains information from a non-valid resource, the issue should be debated on the article's individual talk page, and the article should be edited as appropriate. (See also Templates - Cleanup Tags for more information)

Except in cases of obscenity and other offensive text, you should not edit the article and delete the text.

See also