Doctor-lite: Difference between revisions

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
No edit summary
(a bit of a wide-ranging rewrite, adding sources. removing list as that only obligates us to keep the list. the lodger is sorta retrospectively not companion lite, since craig is considered a companion.)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{real world}}
{{real world}}
'''Doctor-lite''' or '''companion-lite''' is a classification of stories in which [[the Doctor]] and/or his [[companion]]s are deliberately de-emphasised in the narrative. Though most commonly associated with the production necessities of the [[BBC Wales]] version of the programme, there have been non-televised stories which have elected to tell Doctor-lite stories purely for dramatic purposes.
'''Doctor-lite''' is a term originated by the [[BBC Wales]] production team to describe televised episodes which, in order to be able to film all commissioned episodes in time and on budget, didn't have an extensive appearance by [[the Doctor]].


== TV stories ==
One of the earliest known uses of the term was in [[2007]], when [[Steven Moffat]] called ''[[Blink (TV story)|Blink]]'' "the cheap, no CGI, Doctor-lite episode" of [[series 3 (Doctor Who)|series 3]] in [[DWM 393|''Doctor Who Magazine'' #393]].  ''[[DWM]]'' staff writer [[David Darlington]], who was conducting an interview with Moffat in that issue, picked up on this "behind-the-scenes" meaning of the word, and called ''Blink'' the "[[double-banking]] episode", which Moffat confirmed was "the one that doesn't have the Doctor in". ''DWM'' subsequently reprinted Moffat in [[DWMSE 17|''DWMSE'' #17]]'s exploration of the making of ''Blink''. Thus, from a behind-the-scenes viewpoint, a "Doctor-lite" episode of ''[[Doctor Who]]'' is one that, for budgetary reasons, features less of the Doctor than is typical for an episode. 
=== Doctor-lite television stories ===
* ''[[Love & Monsters (TV story)|Love & Monsters]]''
* ''[[Blink (TV story)|Blink]]''
* ''[[Turn Left (TV story)|Turn Left]]''
* ''[[The Crimson Horror (TV story)|The Crimson Horror]]''
<!--Though mostly filmed separate from Amy and Rory, the Doctor appears throughout the runtime of The Girl Who Waited.-->


=== Companion-lite television stories ===
2008's ''[[Midnight (TV story)|Midnight]]'' brought an innovation. It was ''only'' '''companion-lite''', since [[David Tennant]] was fully engaged in that story.  During [[Steven Moffat]]'s [[executive producer]]ship, the definition of the term "companion-lite" has become blurred, largely through the innovative use of the recurring characters like [[Craig Owens]] and [[Madame Vastra]].  While it's clear that ''[[The Lodger (TV story)|The Lodger]]'' was filmed to allow [[Karen Gillan]] to work elsewhere during that [[production block]], the fact that Craig returns in an equally prominent role in ''[[Closing Time (TV story)|Closing Time]]'' makes him a ''de facto'' companion.  Thus, there is room for fans to debate whether his two adventures are "companion-lite" or just, as it were, "companion-different". 
* ''[[Love & Monsters (TV story)|Love & Monsters]]''
* ''[[Blink (TV story)|Blink]]''
* ''[[Midnight (TV story)|Midnight]]''
* ''[[The Lodger (TV story)|The Lodger]]''
<!--Amy and Rory are not companions in Closing Time. Craig is.-->
* ''[[The Crimson Horror (TV story)|The Crimson Horror]]''


Another meaning of the term — though it may just be a fan co-option of the [[BBC Wales]] production term — is simply any story where the role of the Doctor and/or recurring companion is significantly reduced.  This is the sense that is applied to stories from any media, and indeed there are several examples of this sort of ''narratively'' Doctor-lite story going back as far as the old [[World Distributors]] [[Doctor Who annual|annuals]].
== Usage in ''Doctor Who'' ==
== Usage in ''Doctor Who'' ==
Doctor-lite episodes are not usually considered to be parts of [[serial]]s of the 1963 version in which the Doctor or his companions do not appear. This often happened in the [[1960s]] as a way to give an actor a week off. Nor are they stories in which are set in the [[Whoniverse]], but not released as a ''[[Doctor Who]]'' story, such as ''[[Torchwood (TV series)|Torchwood]]'', the [[DWM backup comic stories|''Doctor Who Magazine'' backup comics]], or any of a number of [[Big Finish Productions]] ranges. Rather, they are entire ''stories'' in which the Doctor makes only a brief or incidental appearance. Companion-lite stories are likewise not those in which the Doctor is travelling entirely without a companion. Rather, they are ones in which a companion is established as being an ongoing resident of [[the Doctor's TARDIS]], but sidelined from the main action of a story.
Doctor-lite episodes are not usually considered to be parts of [[serial]]s of the 1963 version in which the Doctor or his companions do not appear. This often happened in the [[1960s]] as a way to give an actor a week off. Nor are they stories in which are set in the [[DWU]], but not released as a ''[[Doctor Who]]'' story, such as ''[[Torchwood (TV series)|Torchwood]]'', the [[DWM backup comic stories|''Doctor Who Magazine'' backup comics]], or any of a number of [[Big Finish Productions]] ranges. Rather, they are entire ''stories'' in which the Doctor makes only a brief or incidental appearance. Companion-lite stories are likewise not those in which the Doctor is travelling entirely without a companion. Rather, they are ones in which a companion is established as being an ongoing resident of [[the Doctor's TARDIS]], but sidelined from the main action of a story.


The term came into vogue with the broadcast of ''[[Love & Monsters (TV story)|Love & Monsters]]'', the first intentionally Doctor-lite episode of the televised programme. ''Monsters'' was followed by ''[[Blink (TV story)|Blink]]'', ''[[Turn Left (TV story)|Turn Left]]'', ''[[The Crimson Horror (TV story)|The Crimson Horror]]'' and the companion-lite episodes, ''[[Midnight (TV story)|Midnight]]'' and ''[[The Lodger (TV story)|The Lodger]]''. All of these were deliberately written to allow for [[double banking]], a process which enables two separate stories to be recorded simultaneously because of the reduced need for the main cast.  
The term came into vogue with the broadcast of ''[[Love & Monsters (TV story)|Love & Monsters]]'', the first intentionally Doctor-lite episode of the televised programme. ''Monsters'' was followed by ''[[Blink (TV story)|Blink]]'', ''[[Turn Left (TV story)|Turn Left]]'', and the companion-lite episode, ''[[Midnight (TV story)|Midnight]]''. All of these were deliberately written to allow for [[double-banking]], a process which enables two separate stories to be recorded simultaneously because of the reduced need for the main cast.
=== In other media ===
Though the term may have been a product of the BBC Wales version of the television programme, the concept certainly pre-dates the 2005 series. Three prose examples of Doctor-lite stories are the novels ''[[Who Killed Kennedy]]'', ''[[Birthright (novel)|Birthright]]'' and ''[[The Face of the Enemy]]''. In comics, ''[[Happy Deathday (comic story)|Happy Deathday]]'' is ultimately revealed to be a Doctor-lite story, in which the [[Eighth Doctor]] is never actually seen, but the entirety of the story is revealed to be something that happened on a video game [[Izzy Sinclair|Izzy]] was playing on the TARDIS' [[Time-Space Visualiser]].


Though the term may have been a product of the BBC Wales version of the television programme, the concept certainly pre-dates the 2005 series. Three prose examples of Doctor-lite stories are the novels ''[[Who Killed Kennedy]]'', ''[[Birthright (novel)|Birthright]]'' and ''[[The Face of the Enemy]]''. In comics, ''[[Happy Deathday (comic story)|Happy Deathday]]'' is ultimately revealed to be a Doctor-lite story, in which the [[Eighth Doctor]] is never actually seen, but the entirety of the story is revealed to be something that happened on a video game [[Izzy Sinclair|Izzy]] was playing on the TARDIS' [[Time-Space Visualiser]].
Companion-lite stories are comparatively rarer in other media, but there's at least one example that, however narrowly, predates [[Midnight (TV story)|the introduction of the concept to television]]. The comic strip ''[[The Lodger (comic story)|The Lodger]]'' gave readers a [[Rose Tyler|Rose]]-lite, [[Mickey Smith|Mickey]]-heavy story at a time well before Mickey joined the TARDIS crew in [[TV]]: ''[[School Reunion]]''. [[PROSE]]: ''[[The Banquo Legacy]]'' was a Doctor-lite, with supporting characters centred by their retelling of the narrative. Equally, the two short stories ''[[Amy's Escapade (short story)|Amy's Escapade]]'' and ''[[Rory's Adventure (short story)|Rory's Adventure]]'' in ''[[Doctor Who The Official Annual 2012]]'' are Doctor-lite stories starring each companion, set simultaneously.


Companion-lite stories are comparatively rarer in other media, but there's at least one example that, however narrowly, predates [[Midnight (TV story)|the introduction of the concept to television]]. The comic strip ''[[The Lodger (comic story)|The Lodger]]'' gave readers a [[Rose Tyler|Rose]]-lite, [[Mickey Smith|Mickey]]-heavy story at a time well before Mickey joined the TARDIS crew in [[TV]]: ''[[School Reunion]]''. [[PROSE]]: ''[[The Banquo Legacy]]'' was a Doctor-lite with supporting characters centred by their retelling of the narrative.
Historically, though, the earliest companion-lite stories can be found in [[World Distributors]] [[Doctor Who annual|annual]]s and ''[[TV Comic]]''. Annual short stories like ''[[Fungus (short story)|Fungus]]'' and others featured a Doctor whose companion-less status — even though companions were present elsewhere in the annual — was never explained.


A Doctor-lite and a companion-lite story occurs in [[COMIC]]: ''[[Rory's Story]]''. [[Rory Williams]] becomes the central character with the [[Eleventh Doctor]] and [[Amy Pond]] in the TARDIS for the comic.
Any number of [[Polystyle]]'s comic stories suddenly had a regular character drop out of site without explanation.  But stories like ''[[The Duellists (comic story)|The Duellists]]'', where [[Jamie McCrimmon]] is suddenly absent after having been in the comic for dozens of weeks, is perhaps not the purest application of the term "companion-lite".  This sort of turnover happens with regularity in comics. After all, one issue [[Destrii]] and [[Ace]] were in [[Doctor Who Magazine comic stories|''DWM'' comic stories]], and the next they weren't.


The two short stories ''[[Amy's Escapade (short story)|Amy's Escapade]]'' and ''[[Rory's Adventure (short story)|Rory's Adventure]]'' in ''[[Doctor Who The Official Annual 2012]]'' are Doctor-lite stories starring each companion, set simultaneously.
However, there are examples that are less ambiguous.
* Several [[First Doctor|First]] and [[Second Doctor]] strips scantly feature [[John and Gillian]].  A good example is ''[[The Hunters of Zerox (comic story)|The Hunters of Zerox]]'', in which they don't really show up until the very end.  Even better is ''[[The Extortioner (comic story)|The Extortioner]]'', where he just leaves them in [[the TARDIS]] altogether, like [[Nyssa]] in ''[[[Kinda (TV story)|Kinda]]''.
* ''[[Double Trouble (comic story)|Double Trouble]]'' was a [[Sarah-Jane Smith]]-less [[Fourth Doctor]] story in the middle of two stories that ''did'' feature her.


== Usage in spin-off shows ==
== Usage in spin-off shows ==

Revision as of 00:33, 9 May 2013

RealWorld.png

Doctor-lite is a term originated by the BBC Wales production team to describe televised episodes which, in order to be able to film all commissioned episodes in time and on budget, didn't have an extensive appearance by the Doctor.

One of the earliest known uses of the term was in 2007, when Steven Moffat called Blink "the cheap, no CGI, Doctor-lite episode" of series 3 in Doctor Who Magazine #393. DWM staff writer David Darlington, who was conducting an interview with Moffat in that issue, picked up on this "behind-the-scenes" meaning of the word, and called Blink the "double-banking episode", which Moffat confirmed was "the one that doesn't have the Doctor in". DWM subsequently reprinted Moffat in DWMSE #17's exploration of the making of Blink. Thus, from a behind-the-scenes viewpoint, a "Doctor-lite" episode of Doctor Who is one that, for budgetary reasons, features less of the Doctor than is typical for an episode.

2008's Midnight brought an innovation. It was only companion-lite, since David Tennant was fully engaged in that story. During Steven Moffat's executive producership, the definition of the term "companion-lite" has become blurred, largely through the innovative use of the recurring characters like Craig Owens and Madame Vastra. While it's clear that The Lodger was filmed to allow Karen Gillan to work elsewhere during that production block, the fact that Craig returns in an equally prominent role in Closing Time makes him a de facto companion. Thus, there is room for fans to debate whether his two adventures are "companion-lite" or just, as it were, "companion-different".

Another meaning of the term — though it may just be a fan co-option of the BBC Wales production term — is simply any story where the role of the Doctor and/or recurring companion is significantly reduced. This is the sense that is applied to stories from any media, and indeed there are several examples of this sort of narratively Doctor-lite story going back as far as the old World Distributors annuals.

Usage in Doctor Who

Doctor-lite episodes are not usually considered to be parts of serials of the 1963 version in which the Doctor or his companions do not appear. This often happened in the 1960s as a way to give an actor a week off. Nor are they stories in which are set in the DWU, but not released as a Doctor Who story, such as Torchwood, the Doctor Who Magazine backup comics, or any of a number of Big Finish Productions ranges. Rather, they are entire stories in which the Doctor makes only a brief or incidental appearance. Companion-lite stories are likewise not those in which the Doctor is travelling entirely without a companion. Rather, they are ones in which a companion is established as being an ongoing resident of the Doctor's TARDIS, but sidelined from the main action of a story.

The term came into vogue with the broadcast of Love & Monsters, the first intentionally Doctor-lite episode of the televised programme. Monsters was followed by Blink, Turn Left, and the companion-lite episode, Midnight. All of these were deliberately written to allow for double-banking, a process which enables two separate stories to be recorded simultaneously because of the reduced need for the main cast.

In other media

Though the term may have been a product of the BBC Wales version of the television programme, the concept certainly pre-dates the 2005 series. Three prose examples of Doctor-lite stories are the novels Who Killed Kennedy, Birthright and The Face of the Enemy. In comics, Happy Deathday is ultimately revealed to be a Doctor-lite story, in which the Eighth Doctor is never actually seen, but the entirety of the story is revealed to be something that happened on a video game Izzy was playing on the TARDIS' Time-Space Visualiser.

Companion-lite stories are comparatively rarer in other media, but there's at least one example that, however narrowly, predates the introduction of the concept to television. The comic strip The Lodger gave readers a Rose-lite, Mickey-heavy story at a time well before Mickey joined the TARDIS crew in TV: School Reunion. PROSE: The Banquo Legacy was a Doctor-lite, with supporting characters centred by their retelling of the narrative. Equally, the two short stories Amy's Escapade and Rory's Adventure in Doctor Who The Official Annual 2012 are Doctor-lite stories starring each companion, set simultaneously.

Historically, though, the earliest companion-lite stories can be found in World Distributors annuals and TV Comic. Annual short stories like Fungus and others featured a Doctor whose companion-less status — even though companions were present elsewhere in the annual — was never explained.

Any number of Polystyle's comic stories suddenly had a regular character drop out of site without explanation. But stories like The Duellists, where Jamie McCrimmon is suddenly absent after having been in the comic for dozens of weeks, is perhaps not the purest application of the term "companion-lite". This sort of turnover happens with regularity in comics. After all, one issue Destrii and Ace were in DWM comic stories, and the next they weren't.

However, there are examples that are less ambiguous.

Usage in spin-off shows

Torchwood followed this model in its episode Random Shoes in Series 1, portraying the main cast other than Gwen Cooper only through those glimpses seen by Eugene Jones. Series 2's Adrift mostly centred on Gwen and Andy Davidson.

The Sarah Jane Adventures uses this model in Whatever Happened to Sarah Jane? (series 1), The Mark of the Berserker (series 2), Mona Lisa's Revenge (series 3) and The Empty Planet (series 4).