Howling:When the Doctor died in Turn Left...
did he really die too quickly to regenerate? Or did he simply refuse to regenerate?
As we all know, "Turn Left" focused on an alternate history where the Doctor in his tenth incarnation died under the Thames during the events of "The Runaway Bride". So, I was watching the episode again and when the Doctor's body is put into the ambulance, the UNIT soldier suggests that the Doctor did not regenerate into his eleventh incarnation because his death "happened too fast" but there has been another theory: that the Doctor chose not to regenerate.
According to this theory, the Doctor let himself drown because of his depression over losing Rose. This idea has been portrayed in several fanfics on "Turn Left" such as these: http://www.fanfiction.net/s/4543093/1/Drowning-Pains and http://www.fanfiction.net/s/9159383/1/Self-Destruction Some would say that the Doctor would NOT just let himself die because he lost her. They argue that he lost several friends and STILL continued on, they also argue that he said goodbye to several companions when they left him and he STILL helped the Earth.
But there are several reasons to believe in the theory that the Doctor chose not to regenerate as opposed to the "it happened too fast" claim.
1. In "Last of the Time Lords", it is implied that regeneration is an option which can be chosen: despite the Doctor's pleas, the Master refused to regenerate after being shot by Lucy Saxon.
2. You gotta admit, the Doctor did seem almost suicidal after losing Rose since he did demand the Daleks to kill him in "Evolution of the Daleks" and he did threaten to blow himself up with the Sontarans in "The Poison Sky"(even if he was faking both).
3. In the "Runaway Bride", when the Doctor watched as the Racnoss drowned, his eyes were full of darkness and pain.
I know this almost certainly didn't happen in the episode but I love the theory that the Doctor chose not to regenerate and that he thought of Rose as he died.
So what do you think? Did the Doctor refuse to regenerate when he died in "Turn Left?" Regardless of whether he tried to regenerate or not, do you think he was thinking of Rose when he drowned? 92.15.130.239
- Please sign your posts.
- We know in The Impossible Astronaut (even through it was the teselecta) that if he was killed while already in the process of regenerating, it would cancel the regen and that'd be it. Whether he wanted to regenerate or not, he may truly not have had a chance to escape. Because he'd never been at Donna's reception, he probably never picked up the exploding Christmas ornaments, so he may have used a different, possible more destructive method of flooding the Racnoss's chamber with the Thames. Because we only see the aftermath, any such varying details can't be confirmed or denied. —BioniclesaurKing4t2 - "Hello, I'm the Doctor. Basically, . . . run." 13:57, June 19, 2013 (UTC)
- It's easiest and the most helpful to sign with "~~~~", as it automatically gives username/IP address plus talk page link and timestamp. —BioniclesaurKing4t2 - "Hello, I'm the Doctor. Basically, . . . run." 15:34, June 19, 2013 (UTC)
Depending on the specifics, if he was still underwater when he regenerated, it might not have helped. Of course the Thames was drained when Donna and the Doctor climbed out, so we really cannot say that in "Turn Left" there was more water, but where he was when he let it loose, and how he did it could have changed things substantially.Phil Stone ☎ 06:08, June 24, 2013 (UTC)
Here's a thought: The Doctor had a flashback of him and Rose dancing earlier in the episode. At the end of Doomsday, some time has clearly passed since he lost Rose. Perhaps he may have actually been intending to kill himself as soon as the opportunity presented itself. If you look at the shot of him during the disco scene, it really looks as if he's in deep thought. Maybe he was actually going to, since the flood was done quite dramatically, and it seemed as if he were genuinely about to commit an act. I think Donna could have definitely saved him from it. "Sometimes I think you need someone to stop you." There could be several meanings to that. Gallifrey102 ☎ 16:18, June 24, 2013 (UTC)
- I haven't seen Doomsday in a while. When is the disco scene? Thanks! Shambala108 ☎ 00:25, June 25, 2013 (UTC)
