Howling:Water References
It has come to my attention through re-watching the new series of Doctor Who that there are a number of references, particularly in the names of companions, to bodies of water. They are as follows;
What these names mean is, as of yet, a mystery to me, though the connection to "The Waters of Mars" may be relevant, as two people who were supposed to die on Mars no longer did.
- Please sign your posts! Type "~" four times to do this. But this is an interesting pattern. I think you may be on to something. River Song, of course, showed up in the Moffat-penned Silence in the Library. Monkey with a Gun 06:17, April 18, 2010 (UTC)
Steven Moffat said it was a conicidence when asked about the water-theme. Delton Menace 07:51, April 18, 2010 (UTC)
Well, I'm sure there's some Freudian explanation for why his subconscious keeps coming up with water-related names....
Also, now that everyone's pointed it out to him repeatedly, he might decide to make it mean something. But I expect that if he does deal with it at all, it'll only be as a joke--maybe River Song or Amy Pond will make a joke about the Doctor's Freudian obsession with water names, ask him if he's a big Veronica Lake fan, say "Let's go back to the 1980s and meet Billy Ocean," etc. --99.37.227.199 09:34, April 18, 2010 (UTC)
It might have started as a coincidence, but I think that if it keeps coming now that he's aware, it's going to mean something. (If I see someone coming up with a name like del Rio or Bay or Marsh, I'm going to keep an eye on them.) (Unsigned)
Better watch out for Haff, too. A haff is a variety of lagoon and, as it's not a well known word, might be used to try to slip one past us. 2.96.18.149 18:01, June 1, 2011 (UTC)
I can't believe it's a coincidence. "The only water in the forest is the river" and the silly scene about the duck pond in Ledworth. (Although I keep waiting for "duck, Pond!" to almost get someone killed because Amy or Rory doesn't realize it actually means "Amelia, get your head down!" Grooaaaan.) And I think ... I hope ... I seriously freaking need to believe ... that there is SOME connection, even if it's something red-herring-ish, like River idolizing Amy, and choosing 'River Song' as an alias, in honor of Melody.
Not sure if this is another red herring, but The Waters of Mars was a huge milestone in the Doctor's ongoing god complex storyline, and now we're leading up to a Season VI-2 episode by that name. Also note that in Curse of the Black Spot, the Doctor's first theory was that the water was the key... and had to admit that he was wrong about it, repeatedly. Agonaga 19:12, June 1, 2011 (UTC)
The "Duck, Pond!" idea occurred to me, too. Something along those lines was actually used in (I think) Silver Nemesis. The Doctor said, "Duck!" and Ace ducked. "No! Duck," said the Doctor, pointing to a waterfowl waddling beside the TARDIS. 89.240.247.98 12:40, June 2, 2011 (UTC)
Agonaga, I think you should have mentioned that the title of 6.7, A Good Man Goes to War looks like a gloss on Bishop Heber's hymn The Son of God Goes Forth to War. Those of you who are not familiar with the piece can find it here on Youtube: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FpeQj_835Ow . It is the hymn sung by Sean Connery & Michael Caine in The Man Who Would Be King. 12:59, June 2, 2011 (UTC) Boblipton 13:00, June 2, 2011 (UTC)
- Blopington, I hadn't ever heard of that hymn before. I couldn't make out the lyrics from the youtube link you sent, so I searched for them in text... and it's interesting. I hope I'll be forgiven, for pasting them here:
The Son of God goes forth to war, A kingly crown to gain; His blood-red banner streams afar: Who follows in His train? Who best can drink his cup of woe, Triumphant over pain, Who patient bears his cross below, He follows in His train. The martyr first, whose eagle eye Could pierce beyond the grave, Who saw his Master in the sky, And called to Him to save: Like Him, with pardon on his tongue, In midst of mortal pain, He prayed for them that did the wrong: Who follows in his train? A glorious band, the chosen few On whom the Spirit came, Twelve valiant saints, their hope they knew, And mocked the cross and flame. They met the tyrant's brandished steel, The lion's gory mane, They bowed their necks, the death to feel: Who follows in their train? A noble army, men and boys, The matron and the maid, Around the Savior's throne rejoice, In robes of light arrayed. They climbed by strength divine from heaven, Through peril, toil, and pain: O God, to us may grace be given To follow in their train.
- I noticed a few notes of potential interest to Whovians... the capitolized name of the Master; mention of a Matron and a Maid; the pardoning of the enemy; our first S6 episode had a martyr; and a couple things played well into my own pet theories, such as a crown to be claimed (the Doctor would love to see Gallifrey reborn, and naturally Rassilon would have to be deposed afterward). Many other lyrics here could be twisted to whatever meaning you want, of course. Any case, thanks for the thought, Blop. Agonaga 18:36, June 2, 2011 (UTC)
- I've put further thoughts on this hymn in another thread to avoid derailing this one: see Howling:Son_of_God_Goes_Forth_to_War Agonaga 19:24, June 2, 2011 (UTC)
Getting back on topic, then:
In A Good Man Goes to War, we get the reveal that River Song is Melody Pond, and "the only water in the forest is the river" means that "River Song" was an inaccurate translation of "Pond, Melody" for the people of the Gamma Forest, because the only water in the Gamma Forest is the river.
So, does this tie the whole thing up, or is there more to be revealed? Are Jackson Lake, Adelaide Brooke, etc. just coincidences?
I think the answer is "probably, but that could change". River and Pond were likely a coincidence at first, but the Moff later chose to turn that coincidence into a plot point. It's unlikely that he'll do the same with Lake or Brooke or the Haff, mainly because it's unlikely we'll ever hear about any of them again, but there's no reason he couldn't make it work if he wanted to. --99.8.228.227 03:33, June 5, 2011 (UTC)
