Talk:Melody Pond: Difference between revisions

Talk:Melody Pond (edit)

Revision as of 21:43, 25 April 2011

2,167 bytes added , 25 April 2011

→‎The Impossible Astronaut

Looq

60

edits

@@ Line 85: / Line 85: @@
 Something happens at the end of Day of the Moon, that in my opinion puts this before The Pandorica Opens/The Big Bang - if it was after something would have happened in those episodes - you'll understand when you see it - also she pretty much confirms it in The Imposible astronaught that they're are traveling in oposite directions - as for not knowing Rory - well he was erased from time, never exisisted so that can be atributed to her not knowing him, either that or she is a great actress and clever when it comes to hiding spoilers...[[Special:Contributions/91.108.5.196|91.108.5.196]] 12:46, April 25, 2011 (UTC)
-River stated explicitly that her and the Doctor were meeting in reverse.  I think we should use that for her timeline.  -- [[User:Ripmssmith|Rest In Peace Sarah Jane]] \ [[User_talk:Ripmssmith|Talk to me!]] 15:01, April 25, 2011 (UTC)
+River stated explicitly that her and the Doctor were meeting in reverse. I think we should use that for her timeline. -- [[User:Ripmssmith|Rest In Peace Sarah Jane]] \ [[User_talk:Ripmssmith|Talk to me!]] 15:01, April 25, 2011 (UTC)
 Leave the timeline as it is and wait for part two to shed some light on it.----[[User:Skittles the hog|Skittles the hog]]--<small>[[User talk:Skittles the hog|Talk]]</small> 15:22, April 25, 2011 (UTC)
-As a "PS" to my above, River told the Doctor "that's when everything changes" at the end of ''[[The Big Bang]]'', and things changed pretty drastically with the Doctor getting.  Part 2 will likely shed more light on things, but I think given what she told Rory and and the Doctor, that the exact reverse order is the correct one.  Any other thoughts?  -- [[User:Ripmssmith|Rest In Peace Sarah Jane]] \ [[User_talk:Ripmssmith|Talk to me!]] 15:44, April 25, 2011 (UTC)
+As a "PS" to my above, River told the Doctor "that's when everything changes" at the end of ''[[The Big Bang]]'', and things changed pretty drastically with the Doctor getting. Part 2 will likely shed more light on things, but I think given what she told Rory and and the Doctor, that the exact reverse order is the correct one. Any other thoughts? -- [[User:Ripmssmith|Rest In Peace Sarah Jane]] \ [[User_talk:Ripmssmith|Talk to me!]] 15:44, April 25, 2011 (UTC)
+I would say that the order is likely to be:
+*''[[The Pandorica Opens (TV story)|The Pandorica Opens ]]''(52)
+*''[[The Big Bang]]''
+*''[[The Impossible Astronaut]]''
+*''[[Day of the Moon]]''
+*''[[The Time of Angels|The Time of Angels (51)]]''
+*''[[Flesh and Stone]]''
+*''[[Silence in the Library]]''
+*''[[Forest of the Dead]]''
+We know TPO happens before ToA (from her point of view) because River says as much.
+We know they meet in a general reverse order because of the diaries (if there were major mix-ups they would have to match up every single event in them rather than just "have we dont this yet"), even though it can get mixed up and isn't a perfect reverse order. So while we can generalise and use it as a trend, we cannot use it to make a specific order.
+As she doesn't know who Rory is in TPO we have to assume the TIA comes after that from her point of view as she clearly knows who he is (there would be no reason for her to pretend not to know him, its not like she hides her time-travling nature and fore-knowledge).
+The only other peice of evidence of where the timeline occured in reguards to ToA is the Vortex Manipilator. It's not hard evidence (it could be a different one) but its the only evidence we have. So until the better evidence is provided I think we will have to assume that TIA occures before ToA where she had returned to prision and presumably had her Vortex Manipulator confiscated.
+As for her being in prision in the 52ndC in TPO and the 51st in ToA (in her personal future but the actual past) there are two explanations. 1) She was recaptured in the 51stC and taken to back prision (as the Time Agency exists it is possible the time travel is factored in when serving a sentence). I find it less likely that she would have turned herself in, in a time period before she was origionally in prision (possibly before she had even commited the crime). 2) It was a mistake. When working out the dates for TPO someone involved in the episode read "51st Cenutry" from ToA and made up a date begining with "51??" (5145 as it turned out); which I think is an easy enough mistake to make. [[User:Looq|Looq]] 21:43, April 25, 2011 (UTC)