→The Impossible Astronaut
| Line 216: | Line 216: | ||
* He may have all ready had that meeting with her - we don't actually know that he didnt go see River before regenerating from the 10th to 11th - the pinc may have been apart of the 10ths goodbye to everyone[[User:LagunaVII|LagunaVII]] 18:01, May 3, 2011 (UTC) | * He may have all ready had that meeting with her - we don't actually know that he didnt go see River before regenerating from the 10th to 11th - the pinc may have been apart of the 10ths goodbye to everyone[[User:LagunaVII|LagunaVII]] 18:01, May 3, 2011 (UTC) | ||
Sitting down for a picnic wouldn't fit the basic pattern of the Tenth Doctor's final meetings with everyone. He hardly knew River at the time, and for everybody else | Sitting down for a picnic wouldn't fit the basic pattern of the Tenth Doctor's final meetings with everyone. He hardly knew River at the time, and for everybody else he ust stood off to the side and stared at them. Besides, the Tenth Doctor's sonic screwdriver didn't have red settings, and the Eleventh Doctor still had the Tenth Doctor's sonic screwdriver.[[User:Icecreamdif|Icecreamdif]] 03:54, May 4, 2011 (UTC) | ||
: While it probably wouldn't have been during Ten's "goodbye tour", the picnic at Asgard ''must ''have involved him. Otherwise River asking Ten if he remembered Asgard after she'd ''already established'' that he came before Eleven (with the Byzantium question) would make ''no sense whatsoever''. The most plausible scenario is that the picnic at Asgard took place in the "early days" from BOTH of their perspectives: Ten and a young River, neither one knowing exactly how much the other knows about their future. Again, despite what River says at the end of'' Day of the Moon'', it is simply <u>not possible</u> for every single meeting to occur in reverse order, as River and Future!Eleven both remembered doing Easter Island.[[Special:Contributions/95.150.87.220|95.150.87.220]] 19:20, May 18, 2011 (UTC) | |||
== Punctuation == | == Punctuation == | ||