8
edits
Talk:War Doctor: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
→Hurt as ninth Doctor
No edit summary |
|||
| Line 38: | Line 38: | ||
Each of us has their own views but I think it's common sense if Hurt is acknowledged as the ninth Doctor. An encyclopaedia should show things as they are. It should be logical, not philosophical. There shouldn't be room for interpretation. Only facts. And facts say Hurt is the ninth incarnation of that particular Time Lord who calls himself "the Doctor". Even if it means a lot of work changing titles of articles, altering redirections I think it should be done. Otherwise - what's the point of maintaining the Tardis Data Core? | Each of us has their own views but I think it's common sense if Hurt is acknowledged as the ninth Doctor. An encyclopaedia should show things as they are. It should be logical, not philosophical. There shouldn't be room for interpretation. Only facts. And facts say Hurt is the ninth incarnation of that particular Time Lord who calls himself "the Doctor". Even if it means a lot of work changing titles of articles, altering redirections I think it should be done. Otherwise - what's the point of maintaining the Tardis Data Core? | ||
EDIT: I just read the announcement from [[User:CzechOut]]. Probably no one gives a damn what I think but I appreciate there are others who think of Hurt as a true Ninth incarnation. Just wanted to say one more thing. [[User:CzechOut]] says it's only Smith's Doctor who is fully aware of the whole situation. I want to ask then - from what point of view is this Wikia written? Other Wikias about about franchises - for example Star Trek or Star Wars are written as if everything they described happened in the past. Obviously we can't write about things that WILL happen in the series. I feel that leaving things as they are because of past incarnations' ego is not right. [[User:Jamjumetley|Jamjumetley]] [[User talk:Jamjumetley|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 15:03, November 24, 2013 (UTC) | EDIT: I just read the announcement from [[User:CzechOut|CzechOut]]. Probably no one gives a damn what I think but I appreciate there are others who think of Hurt as a true Ninth incarnation. Just wanted to say one more thing. [[User:CzechOut|CzechOut]] says it's only Smith's Doctor who is fully aware of the whole situation. I want to ask then - from what point of view is this Wikia written? Other Wikias about about franchises - for example Star Trek or Star Wars are written as if everything they described happened in the past. Obviously we can't write about things that WILL happen in the series. I feel that leaving things as they are because of past incarnations' ego is not right. [[User:Jamjumetley|Jamjumetley]] [[User talk:Jamjumetley|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 15:03, November 24, 2013 (UTC) | ||
