25,433
edits
Talk:The Haunting (audio story): Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
m
→Changing the title is premature
(→Changing the title is premature: adding info about cover in SoundCloud) Tag: sourceedit |
Tag: sourceedit |
||
| Line 51: | Line 51: | ||
:::: In my view, if it is possible to buy a product with a particular cover, it is one of the final covers. So then one needs to determine which cover takes precedence, which would be a matter of policy to be created. RogerAckroydLives says that this situation is, unfortunately, widespread. | :::: In my view, if it is possible to buy a product with a particular cover, it is one of the final covers. So then one needs to determine which cover takes precedence, which would be a matter of policy to be created. RogerAckroydLives says that this situation is, unfortunately, widespread. | ||
:::: There are several precedents here. Unfortunately, they are partially contradictory/ | :::: There are several precedents here. Unfortunately, they are partially contradictory/indecisive. One maxima (see [[T:CASTCREW]]) is to use the earliest release (transmission) as the primary. This would sometimes give primality to the download (as in ''River Song Diary'' case) but in most cases, including this one I think, would equate the two as the download is usually made available simultaneously with mailing the CDs, which is the determining date. | ||
:::: Secondly, perhaps based on our discussion about the difference in the cast lists between CDs and download, [[User:SOTO|SOTO]] has recently amended [[T:CAST]] to emphasise the primality of CD releases with respect to casts. (I only learned about this amendment today, and it might change my position on this particular renaming.) There the situation is clear: the CD cast list is more complete than the download one. | :::: Secondly, perhaps based on our discussion about the difference in the cast lists between CDs and download, [[User:SOTO|SOTO]] has recently amended [[T:CAST]] to emphasise the primality of CD releases with respect to casts. (I only learned about this amendment today, and it might change my position on this particular renaming.) There the situation is clear: the CD cast list is more complete than the download one. | ||
