133
edits
The Doctor's Daughter (TV story): Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
→Discontinuity, Plot Holes, Errors: some changes
Whoniverse93 (talk | contribs) |
(→Discontinuity, Plot Holes, Errors: some changes) |
||
| Line 198: | Line 198: | ||
*If the war had only been fought for seven days that implied that no soldiers from the human side have survived past seven days otherwise they would know what happened. This is implausible.''But not impossible just a bit unlikely and the machine could have not updated the original one with the date of how long the fight had been going on, or there were really bad tactics.'' | *If the war had only been fought for seven days that implied that no soldiers from the human side have survived past seven days otherwise they would know what happened. This is implausible.''But not impossible just a bit unlikely and the machine could have not updated the original one with the date of how long the fight had been going on, or there were really bad tactics.'' | ||
*If both the Hath and the humans are in a military state and just want soldiers they have no reason to use sexual reproduction and instead use the progenitor. | *If both the Hath and the humans are in a military state and just want soldiers they have no reason to use sexual reproduction and instead use the progenitor. 'they do' | ||
*It's unclear why the progenitor would be set to create soldiers as it is a colonisation ship. ''It is stated in the episode that the machine was set to create soldiers rather than colonists meaning it was altered''. | *It's unclear why the progenitor would be set to create soldiers as it is a colonisation ship. ''It is stated in the episode that the machine was set to create soldiers rather than colonists meaning it was altered''. | ||
*When Donna, Jenny and the Doctor are put in the cell no one searches them. This seems a major oversight. In addition to this the guard is standing right outside the door yet fails to hear the sonic screwdriver or the Doctor talking on his mobile phone. | *When Donna, Jenny and the Doctor are put in the cell no one searches them. This seems a major oversight. In addition to this the guard is standing right outside the door yet fails to hear the sonic screwdriver or the Doctor talking on his mobile phone. ''A very bad guard. But he does belive that they are pacefists and thus are no threat and have no weapons. The conversation on the phone was traced to The Hath as seen in one of the cut scenes'' | ||
*Near the end of the episode, a softbox light can be seen inside the TARDIS, lighting the set. | |||
*Near the end of the episode, a softbox light can be seen inside the TARDIS, lighting the set.'' | |||
*Immediately after Jenny was 'progenated', the soldiers ignore the Doctor, Martha and Donna - and don't bother cloning them. It's as if they know automatically that the Doctor is the only one who should be cloned. It would make more sense if the Doctor was cloned and as Jenny stepped out, the band of attacking Hath attacked immediately. ''They were preparing for an attack just before the Hath attacked, suggesting that they knew an attack was coming and had no time to process Donna or Martha. Moreover Cline appeared to prompt Jenny to see if she knew what she was doing just before the attack. All these factors probably distracted them from the processing of Donna and Martha.'' | *Immediately after Jenny was 'progenated', the soldiers ignore the Doctor, Martha and Donna - and don't bother cloning them. It's as if they know automatically that the Doctor is the only one who should be cloned. It would make more sense if the Doctor was cloned and as Jenny stepped out, the band of attacking Hath attacked immediately. ''They were preparing for an attack just before the Hath attacked, suggesting that they knew an attack was coming and had no time to process Donna or Martha. Moreover Cline appeared to prompt Jenny to see if she knew what she was doing just before the attack. All these factors probably distracted them from the processing of Donna and Martha.'' | ||
*Why are the clones 'born' with clothes? ''On several occasions such as [[The Invisible Enemy]] clones are created with clothes. As with Jenny at the start of the episode clones may need to fight second after there creation so it would take to much time for them to put clothes on in a combat situation. Also the machine produced her with tied back heir presumably to keep it from getting in the way. Also a show such as Doctor Who not | *Why are the clones 'born' with clothes? ''On several occasions such as [[The Invisible Enemy]] clones are created with clothes. As with Jenny at the start of the episode clones may need to fight second after there creation so it would take to much time for them to put clothes on in a combat situation. Also the machine produced her with tied back heir presumably to keep it from getting in the way. Also a show such as Doctor Who would not show full frontal nudity'' | ||
*The Doctor has previously said that he can feel in his mind whether other Time Lords exist still, so why doesn't he feel Jenny still being alive? She is a Time Lord, and is very closely related to the Doctor. ''He also refers to her at one point as "an echo" - if he still feels her presence he may simply dismiss it as an echo.'' | *The Doctor has previously said that he can feel in his mind whether other Time Lords exist still, so why doesn't he feel Jenny still being alive? She is a Time Lord, and is very closely related to the Doctor. ''He also refers to her at one point as "an echo" - if he still feels her presence he may simply dismiss it as an echo.'' | ||
