Doctor Who and the Cave-Monsters (novelisation): Difference between revisions

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference

Doctor Who and the Cave-Monsters (novelisation) (edit)

Revision as of 20:51, 3 November 2024

3,623 bytes added ,  3 November
m
Bot: Cosmetic changes
No edit summary
m (Bot: Cosmetic changes)
 
(44 intermediate revisions by 24 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{title dab away}}
{{title dab away}}
{{real world}}
{{real world}}
{{Infobox Story
{{Infobox Story SMW
|image=Cave-Monsters novel.jpg
|image       = <gallery>
|series=[[Target novelisation]]s
Cave-Monsters novel.jpg|1974 edition
|number= 9 (given to later editions)  
4CaveMonsters.jpg|1992 edition
|novelisation of= Doctor Who and the Silurians (TV story)
</gallery>
|doctor=Third Doctor  
|number       = 9 (given to later editions)  
|companions=[[Liz Shaw|Liz]]
|novelisation of = Doctor Who and the Silurians (TV story)
|featuring=[[Alistair Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart|The Brig]]
|doctor       = Third Doctor  
|enemy= [[Silurian]]s
|companions   = [[Liz Shaw|Liz]]
|setting= [[Earth]], circa [[1970s]]
|featuring   = [[Alistair Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart|The Brigadier]]
|writer= [[Malcolm Hulke]]
|enemy       = [[Silurian]]s
|read by=[[Caroline John]]
|setting     = [[Earth]], late [[20th century]]
|publisher= Target Books
|writer       = Malcolm Hulke
|publisher2= W.H. Allen
|read by     = [[Caroline John]]
|cover = [[Chris Achilleos]]
|publisher   = Target Books
|release date= [[17 January (releases)|17 January]] [[1974 (releases)|1974]]
|publisher2   = W.H. Allen
|format= Hardcover and paperback editions; 19 Chapters, 158 Pages  
|cover       = [[Chris Achilleos]]
|isbn= ISBN 0-426-11471-X
|release date = 17 January 1974
|series = Publication order
|format       = Hardcover and paperback editions; 19 Chapters, 158 Pages  
|prev= Doctor Who and the Auton Invasion
|isbn         = ISBN 0-426-11471-X
|next= Doctor Who and the Doomsday Weapon
|series       = [[Target novelisation]]s
|series2 = [[Target novelisation]] numbering
|prev         = Doctor Who and the Auton Invasion (novelisation)
|prev2= Doctor Who and the Carnival of Monsters
|next         = Doctor Who and the Doomsday Weapon (novelisation)
|next2= Doctor Who and the Claws of Axos
|series2     = [[Target novelisation]] numbering
|series3 = TV series order
|prev2       = Doctor Who and the Carnival of Monsters (novelisation)
|prev3= Doctor Who and the Auton Invasion  
|next2       = Doctor Who and the Claws of Axos (novelisation)
|next3= The Ambassadors of Death (novelisation)
|series3     = TV series order
|prev3       = Doctor Who and the Auton Invasion (novelisation)
|next3       = The Ambassadors of Death (novelisation)
}}
}}
'''''Doctor Who and the Cave-Monsters''''' was the novelisation of ''[[Doctor Who and the Silurians (TV story)|Doctor Who and the Silurians]]''. Interestingly enough, even though the [[serial]] it adapted was accidentally given a Target-style title, the novelisation didn't take the chance to carry the same title and instead gave it a completely different one.
'''''Doctor Who and the Cave-Monsters''''' was the novelisation of ''[[Doctor Who and the Silurians (TV story)|Doctor Who and the Silurians]]''. Interestingly enough, even though the [[serial]] it adapted was accidentally given a Target-style title, the novelisation didn't take the chance to carry the same title and instead gave it a completely different one. In a foreword for the 2011 reprint, [[Terrance Dicks]] said editor [[Richard Henwood]] changed titles to things he felt were more commercial.


== Publisher's summary ==
== Publisher's summary ==
Line 77: Line 79:


== Deviations from televised story ==
== Deviations from televised story ==
* As one of the early titles in the Target range, the writer was encouraged to flesh out his script for the novelisation. As he also has to fit seven episodes into 45,000 words, he rewrote the story with an altered structure, dropped and revised scenes, and substantially rewritten dialogue. The 2011 reprint's "Between The Lines" feature also argues the characterisation of the Doctor, Brigadier, and Liz Shaw are altered to reflect how the characters had developed over the 1970s and in Liz's case, depicting her more like [[Jo Grant]].
* A prologue tells of the [[Silurian]]s going into hiding to avoid catastrophe.
* A prologue tells of the [[Silurian]]s going into hiding to avoid catastrophe.
* Each of the reptile men is given an individual name and personality.
* Each of the reptile men is given an individual name and personality.
*The Dinosaur controlled by the Silurians in the caves is explicitly stated to be a [[Tyrannosaurus rex]], while in the televised story its species is unclear, although it does appear to be a Tyrannosaur of some sort. It is hinted to be a species genetically created by the Silurians themselves by the fact that the Doctor is unable to identify it.
* The dinosaur controlled by the Silurians in the caves is explicitly stated to be a [[Tyrannosaurus rex]], while in the televised story its species is unclear, although it does appear to be a [[Theropod]] of some sort. It is hinted to be a species genetically created by the Silurians themselves by the fact that the Doctor is unable to identify it.
* All the scenes with [[Spencer (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Spencer]] and [[Davis (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Davis]] in the caves are cut out; they are replaced by Quinn and the Brigadier explaining the events.
* All the scenes with [[Spencer (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Spencer]] and [[Davis (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Davis]] in the caves are dropped, being replaced by Quinn and the Brigadier explaining the events.
* The Brigadier meets the Doctor and Liz at the lift when they arrive at the centre. In the televised episode, a soldier informs the Brigadier, who is in the conference room.
* The Brigadier meets the Doctor and Liz at the lift when they arrive at the centre. In the televised version, a soldier informs the Brigadier, who is in the conference room.
* A UNIT corporal named [[Grover (Doctor Who and the Cave Monsters)|Grover]] tells Liz that the Doctor is working on Bessie.
* A UNIT corporal named [[Grover (Doctor Who and the Cave-Monsters)|Grover]] tells Liz that the Doctor is working on Bessie.
* The Doctor's humming of ''[[Jabberwocky]]'' is removed.
* The Doctor's humming of ''[[Jabberwocky]]'' is removed.
* A new scene features some security guards at the main gate checking the Doctor and Liz's passes. Liz gives a password, which is "Silurians".
* A new scene features some security guards at the main gate checking the Doctor and Liz's passes. Liz gives a password, which is "Silurians".
* Liz goes straight from the conference room at the research facility to the [[medical bay]]. In the televised version, she briefly goes to the cyclotron room with the Doctor.
* Liz goes straight from the conference room at the research facility to the [[medical bay]]. In the televised version, she briefly goes to the cyclotron room with the Doctor.
* The scenes when the Doctor first visits the Cyclotron room are cut out.
* The scenes when the Doctor first visits the cyclotron room are removed.
* Meredith is described as a good-looking young man, while in the televised serial he is older.
* Dr. Meredith is described as "a good-looking young man", while in the televised version he is older.
* More background is given to Miss [[Phyllis Dawson|Dawson]]; she is said to have lived in London her whole life, looking after her old mother, while all her other siblings went to [[America]] and [[Australia]]. Her mother then died, and she took the job at Wenley Moor. She is also given the first name of Phyllis.
* More background is given to Miss [[Phyllis Dawson|Dawson]]; she is said to have lived in London her whole life, looking after her old mother, while all her other siblings went to [[America]] and [[Australia]]. Her mother then died, and she took the job at Wenley Moor. She is also given the first name of Phyllis.
* The entire third chapter is devoted to Miss Dawson, including her past life and her experiences with Dr Quinn.
* The entire third chapter is devoted to Miss Dawson, including her past life and her experiences with Dr Quinn.
Line 94: Line 97:
* At one point, the Doctor is referred to as "Doctor Who".
* At one point, the Doctor is referred to as "Doctor Who".
* Major Baker is renamed "Major Barker".
* Major Baker is renamed "Major Barker".
* The scenes featuring [[Roberts (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Roberts]] are different from the televised story: on-screen, Roberts tries to strangle Miss Dawson when she tries to shut off the reactor, but in the novelisation, Liz notices him drawing extinct animals on his clipboard. When the Doctor confronts him, Roberts tries to strangle Liz, but is hit by Barker with his revolver, killing him. He is also given the first name of George.
* The scenes featuring [[Roberts (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Roberts]] are different from the televised version: on-screen, Roberts tries to strangle Miss Dawson when she tries to shut off the reactor, but in the novelisation, Liz notices him drawing extinct animals on his clipboard. When the Doctor confronts him, Roberts tries to strangle Liz, but Barker hits Roberts over the head with his revolver — killing him. He is also given the first name of George.
* When Quinn goes to see the Silurians to warn them about UNIT, he speaks with Okdel in person, rather than over a speaker system as in the televised serial.
* When Quinn goes to see the Silurians to warn them about UNIT, he speaks with Okdel in person, rather than over a speaker system as in the televised version.
* The Silurian that is wounded and forced to the surface is named as [[Morka]]. He is also the younger Silurian who kills [[Okdel L'da|the leader]], a distinction which is not made clear in the television story (where the two are played by different actors).
* The Silurian that is wounded and forced to the surface is the same character as the [[Morka|Young Silurian]] (here named Morka) who kills [[Okdel L'da|the ageing leader]]. In the show, these were different Silurians played by different actors. In another diversion, the leader and Young Silurian disagree on whether Quinn should have been killed ("he tried to keep one of us prisoner") on their own; in the novel, the Doctor reveals to the leader Quinn is dead, and Morka dismisses it as "he tried to hold me prisoner".
* Morka kills [[Squire (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Squire]] by breaking his neck, rather than Squire dying of fright as in televised serial.
* Morka kills [[Squire (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Squire]] by breaking his neck, rather than Squire dying of fright as in the televised version.
* Captain [[Sam Hawkins|Hawkins]] is demoted to Sergeant.
* Captain [[Sam Hawkins|Hawkins]] is demoted to Sergeant.
* Only the Doctor, the Brigadier, Major Barker, Sergeant Hawkins and an unnamed soldier go into the caves to search for the Dinosaur. On-screen, there is more than one unnamed soldier.
* Only the Doctor, the Brigadier, Major Barker, Sergeant Hawkins and an unnamed soldier go into the caves to search for the Dinosaur. On-screen, there is more than one unnamed soldier.
* Morka hides in the cellar of the barn at the farm. On-screen, there is no cellar, and the Silurian hides in the hay.
* Morka hides in the cellar of the barn at the farm. On-screen, there is no cellar; and the Silurian hides in the hay loft.
* Major Barker is not guarded when he leaves the [[medical bay|sickbay]]. On-screen, a UNIT sergeant is guarding Baker when he leaves.
* Major Barker is not guarded when he leaves the [[medical bay|sickbay]]. On-screen, a UNIT sergeant is guarding Baker when he leaves.
* The death of Dr Quinn differs from the televised episode. On-screen, Quinn is killed by the Silurian and the Doctor discovers his body. In the novelisation, Quinn is talking with Miss Dawson when the Silurian (Morka) burns down the door of the store room he is locked in. When Quinn tries to talk to him, Morka kills him and knocks out Dawson and escapes. Dr Meredith later comes to the cottage searching for the recently-escaped Major Barker and finds Quinn's body. He then finds Dawson has succumbed to her race memories and is drawing pictures of Silurian's and animals on the walls from the ash of the burnt door.
* The Doctor is far friendlier to Quinn in his cottage than in the show, where he's trying to unsettle him.
* [[Edward Masters|Masters]]' first name is changed from Edward to Frederick. He and Dr Lawrence attended prep school together.
* The death of Dr Quinn differs from the televised version. On-screen, Quinn is killed by the captive Silurian and the Doctor discovers his body. Right after, he runs into the escaped Silurian, cautiously greets it, and tries to convince it to explain its situation to the humans. In the novelisation, Quinn is talking with Miss Dawson when the Silurian (Morka) burns down the door of the store room he is locked in. When Quinn tries to talk to him, Morka kills him and knocks out Dawson and escapes. Dr Meredith later comes to the cottage searching for the recently escaped Major Barker and finds Quinn's body. He then finds Dawson has succumbed to her race memories and is drawing pictures of Silurians and animals on the walls from the ash of the burnt door.
* [[Edward Masters|Masters]]' first name is changed from Edward to Frederick. He and Dr. Lawrence attended prep school together.
* The Brigadier and his team realise the Doctor has gone into the caves ahead of them when they find Bessie by the entrance.
* The Brigadier and his team realise the Doctor has gone into the caves ahead of them when they find Bessie by the entrance.
* The Doctor and Liz enter the Silurian shelter through a air ventilation tunnel, instead of using the calling device he took from Dr Quinn as in the televised story.
* The Doctor and Liz enter the Silurian shelter through a air ventilation tunnel, instead of using the calling device he took from Dr Quinn as in the televised version.
* Morka is able to control [[Steve Robins|Robins]]' mind and forces him to leap off a chasm to his death.
* Morka is able to control [[Steve Robins|Robins]]' mind and forces him to leap off a chasm to his death.
* The Brigadier and his team are attacked by the Silurian's dinosaur while escaping.
* The Brigadier and his team are attacked by the Silurian's dinosaur while escaping.
Line 113: Line 117:
* The Doctor instructs Sergeant Hawkins to tell the police that there is an outbreak of the [[bubonic plague]] at the hospital so they'll cordon off the area.
* The Doctor instructs Sergeant Hawkins to tell the police that there is an outbreak of the [[bubonic plague]] at the hospital so they'll cordon off the area.
* Masters' death is different from the televised serial: in the novelisation, his train is stopped to prevent him from spreading the virus. Masters exits the train, but not before infecting the train guard. He manages to get a hire-car and goes to London, but dies in the car. The hire-car driver and a policeman are also infected by Masters.
* Masters' death is different from the televised serial: in the novelisation, his train is stopped to prevent him from spreading the virus. Masters exits the train, but not before infecting the train guard. He manages to get a hire-car and goes to London, but dies in the car. The hire-car driver and a policeman are also infected by Masters.
* Dr Meredith helps the Doctor and Liz find the cure for the virus.
* The virus is stated to have reached [[Peterborough]] and then spread to [[Paris]] (confirmed right after the Brigadier hoped it could be contained in Britain) is fleshed out: two cases instead of one, caused by two nurses from the Royal Free Hospital — where the infected policeman was admitted — going on a weekend trip. Whereas the Doctor cracks the antidote in the televised version just after Paris is confirmed, in the novelisation it's also by then spread to [[Frankfurt]] and [[Belgrade]], as well as the [[Midlands]] in England.
* The characters of Sergeant [[Hart (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Hart]], Private [[Wright (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Wright]], Private [[Upton]] and Corporal [[Nutting]] are completely removed.
* Dr. Meredith helps the Doctor and Liz find the cure for the virus.
* The characters of Sergeant [[Hart (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Hart]], Private [[Wright (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Wright]], Private [[Upton]] and Corporal [[Nutting]] do not appear in the novelisation.
* Sergeant Hawkins is not killed by the Silurians.
* Sergeant Hawkins is not killed by the Silurians.
* Dr Lawrence is killed by the Silurians while in the Cyclotron room, instead of being killed by the virus as in the televised serial.
* Dr. Lawrence is killed by the Silurians while in the cyclotron room, instead of being killed by the virus as in the televised serial.
* Liz witnesses the Silurians' kidnapping of the Doctor.
* Liz witnesses the Silurians' kidnapping of the Doctor.
* At the end, the Brigadier only seals the Silurians in the caves, as opposed to blowing them up. The Doctor's reaction is more muted.
* At the end, the Doctor is planning to meet the [[Prime Minister of the United Kingdom|Prime Minister]] and convince him to go to the [[United Nations]] about sharing Earth with the Silurians. He's aware the Brigadier is up to something and Liz Shaw is fully aware of things. The Brigadier is stated to only be sealing the base rather than blowing it up, and the Doctor's reaction is more muted: anger that we'll never know if coexistence was possible, rather than horror that the Silurians have been massacred.
* [[Travis (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Travis]] is now a female technician. She saves the day when the reactor overloads.
* [[Travis (Doctor Who and the Silurians)|Travis]] is now a female technician. She saves the day when the reactor overloads.
* As one of the early titles in the Target range, the writer was encouraged to flesh out his script for the novelisation.
* In reference to the Silurians, the Doctor gives the name "homo reptilia", a term which was not used on-screen until 2010's {{cs|The Hungry Earth (TV story)}}.


== Notes ==
== Notes ==
* The back-cover blurb on the original edition features a scientific error, as the Tyrannosaurus rex is referred to as a mammal, when in fact dinosaurs were reptiles.
* The back-cover blurb on the original edition features a scientific error, as the Tyrannosaurus rex is referred to as "the biggest, most savage mammal that ever trod the earth!", when in fact dinosaurs were reptiles.
* This was the second of two Target novelisations to include “Based on the Popular BBC Television Serial” beneath the author’s name on the front cover.
* This novelisation was later released as part of ''[[The UNIT Collection]]''.
* This novelisation was later released as part of ''[[The UNIT Collection]]''.


Line 132: Line 138:
4CaveMonsters.jpg|1992 edition.<br />Cover by [[Alister Pearson]]
4CaveMonsters.jpg|1992 edition.<br />Cover by [[Alister Pearson]]
And the Cave-Monsters 2011.jpg|2011 BBC Books edition.
And the Cave-Monsters 2011.jpg|2011 BBC Books edition.
</gallery>
== Illustrations ==
Illustrations by [[Chris Achilleos]]
<gallery position="center" captionalign="center" hideaddbutton="true">
Siluriansp6.jpg|Page 6
Siluriansp24.jpg|Page 24
Siluriansp44.jpg|Page 44
Siluriansp52.jpg|Page 52
Siluriansp71.jpg|Page 71
Siluriansp80.jpg|Page 80
Siluriansp89.jpg|Page 89
Siluriansp104.jpg|Page 104
Siluriansp120.jpg|Page 120
Siluriansp132.jpg|Page 132
Siluriansp145.jpg|Page 145
</gallery>
=== Japanese illustrations ===
<gallery position="center" captionalign="center" hideaddbutton="true">
Cave Monsters Japan 1.png|Illustration 1
Cave Monsters Japan 2.png|Illustration 2
Cave Monsters Japan 3.png|Illustration 3
Cave Monsters Japan 4.png|Illustration 4
</gallery>
</gallery>


Line 147: Line 177:


== Editions published outside Britain ==
== Editions published outside Britain ==
* Published in the Netherlands by Unieboek/De Gooise in about 1975/76 as a paperback edition, newly translated by FF van den Hulst-Brander and published as ''Doctor Who en de Holenmonsters'', it was one of eight Dutch novelisations; despite the broadcaster TROS showing [[Season 12|Seasons 12]] and [[Season 13|13]] at this time the cover still depicts the [[First Doctor]], however [[Chris Achilleos]]' image of the [[Fourth Doctor]] from [[The Doctor Who Monster Book]] does appear on the back cover.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.wonderfulbook.co.uk/basedon/|title=Based on the Popular BBC Television Serial 3rd Edition}}</ref>
* Published in the Netherlands by Unieboek/De Gooise in about 1975/76 as a paperback edition, newly translated by FF van den Hulst-Brander and published as ''Doctor Who en de Holenmonsters'', it was one of eight Dutch novelisations; despite the broadcaster TROS showing [[Season 12 (Doctor Who 1963)|Seasons 12]] and [[Season 13 (Doctor Who 1963)|13]] at this time the cover still depicts the [[First Doctor]], however [[Chris Achilleos]]' image of the [[Fourth Doctor]] from [[The Doctor Who Monster Book]] does appear on the back cover.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.wonderfulbook.co.uk/basedon/|title=Based on the Popular BBC Television Serial 3rd Edition}}</ref>
* Published in Finland by Weilin + Goos in 1976 as a hardback edition, translator unknown and published as ''Tohtori Kuka Ja Luolahirviöt'', it was one of two Finnish novelisations.
* Published in Finland by Weilin + Goos in 1976 as a hardback edition, translator unknown and published as ''Tohtori Kuka Ja Luolahirviöt'', it was one of two Finnish novelisations.
* Published in Japan by [[Hayakawa Bunko]] in 1980 as a paperback edition, translated by Yukio Sekiguchi and published as ''Senritsu! Chitei Monsutaa'', it was one of five Japanese novelisations.
* Published in Japan by [[Hayakawa Bunko]] in 1980 as a paperback edition, translated by Yukio Sekiguchi and published as 戦慄！地底モンスター (''Senritsu! Chitei Monsutā'', "Shudder! Underground Monsters"), it was one of five Japanese novelisations.
* Published in Portugal by Editorial Presenca in 1983 as a paperback edition, translated by Conceicao Fardium and Eduardo Nogueria and published as ''Doutor Who E Os Monstros Das Cavernas'', it was one of ten Portuguese novelisations.
* Published in Portugal by Editorial Presença in 1983 as a paperback edition, translated by Conceição Fardim and Eduardo Nogueria and published as ''Doutor Who E Os Monstros Das Cavernas'', it was one of ten Portuguese novelisations.


<gallery position="center" captionalign="center" hideaddbutton="true">
<gallery position="center" captionalign="center" hideaddbutton="true">
Line 160: Line 190:


== Audiobook ==
== Audiobook ==
This Target Book was released on [[3 September (releases)|3 September]] [[2007 (releases)|2007]] complete and unabridged by [[BBC Audio]] and read by [[Caroline John]].
This Target Book was released as an audiobook on [[3 September (releases)|3 September]] [[2007 (releases)|2007]] complete and unabridged by [[BBC Audio]] and read by [[Caroline John]].


The cover blurb and thumbnail illustrations were retained in the accompanying booklet with sleevenotes by [[David J. Howe]]. Music and sound effects by [[Simon Power]].
The cover blurb and thumbnail illustrations were retained in the accompanying booklet with sleevenotes by [[David J. Howe]]. Music and sound effects by [[Simon Power]].


It was later reissued as an MP3-CD alongside action figures of [[Amy Pond]] and a Silurian as part of [[Character Options series 5 action figures|Character Options' Panodrica wave]].
It was later reissued as an MP3-CD alongside action figures of [[Amy Pond]] and a Silurian as part of [[Character Options series 5 action figures|Character Options' Pandorica wave]].
 
The audiobook was reissued on [[5 April (releases)|5 April]] [[2018 (releases)|2018]] as part of ''[[The UNIT Collection]]''.


<gallery position="center" captionalign="center" hideaddbutton="true">
<gallery position="center" captionalign="center" hideaddbutton="true">
File:CaveMonstersAudio.jpg|Audiobook cover
CaveMonstersAudio.jpg|Audiobook cover
The UNIT Collection.jpg|The UNIT Collection
</gallery>
</gallery>


Line 177: Line 210:
{{DWN}}
{{DWN}}
{{TitleSort}}
{{TitleSort}}
[[Category:Target novelisations]]
[[Category:The UNIT Collection novels]]
[[Category:The UNIT Collection novels]]
[[Category:1974 novels]]
[[Category:1974 novels]]
Line 183: Line 218:
[[Category:Stories set in Derbyshire]]
[[Category:Stories set in Derbyshire]]
[[Category:Stories set in the distant past]]
[[Category:Stories set in the distant past]]
[[Category:Brigadier Lethbridge-Stewart novels]]
SV7
Tech, Bots, Bureaucrats, emailconfirmed, Administrators
229,659

edits

Retrieved from "https://tardis.wiki/wiki/Special:MobileDiff/2876580...3891931"
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.
More information