1,767
edits
Talk:Series 5 (Doctor Who 2005)/Archive 1: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
Talk:Series 5 (Doctor Who 2005)/Archive 1 (edit)
Revision as of 07:28, 18 February 2010
, 18 February 2010no edit summary
(→Let's get a consensus on what to call this article: forgot to sign) |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 221: | Line 221: | ||
Episode 6 & 10== | Episode 6 & 10== | ||
Until the episode names for 6 and 10 are confirmed by a reliable source, I'm removing them. [[User:Jim393|Jim393]] 14:46, February 6, 2010 (UTC) | Until the episode names for 6 and 10 are confirmed by a reliable source, I'm removing them. [[User:Jim393|Jim393]] 14:46, February 6, 2010 (UTC) | ||
Many people have seen River Song filming for the finale at Stone Henge with the Doctor and Amy. I saw the pictures, too. [[User:Delton Menace|Delton Menace]] 07:28, February 18, 2010 (UTC) | |||
== Nick Briggs and Barnaby Edwards in ep12/13 note. == | == Nick Briggs and Barnaby Edwards in ep12/13 note. == | ||
| Line 235: | Line 237: | ||
I haven't seen DWM 418 yet (it won't be available in Canada for another month) but according to this article Moffat has made the announcement that "Series 5" (or, as he called it in DWM 417, Series Fnarg) is going to be officially known as Season 31. Now I'd rather wait to see what happens when the BBC officially announces its schedule whether they actually do this or not. If they do, then we need to come up with a consensus as to what to call not only this article, but retroactively the 2005-2008 seasons. If 2010 is called Season 31 officially, do we rename the other articles Seasons 27-30? Or do we stick with 1-4 despite the discontinuity in numbering? Or do we keep the original and revival series separate (even if Moffat is clearly integrating them by using Season 31) and stick with Series 5? It's just numbering, but this is actually an emotional issue for some people and I don't really want to see us start a "Move edit war" over this. I'd rather we come to an agreement before articles are moved, or remain where they are. My personal view is if Series 5 is "Season 31" officially, we should retroactively rename the other seasons articles for the sake of simplicity. However I'm not one of those who treats this as an emotional issue so I'm quite fine to leave things status quo. (Just as long as the BBC doesn't follow through with the "Series 1" idea, I'm happy.) [[User:23skidoo|23skidoo]] 03:58, February 18, 2010 (UTC) | I haven't seen DWM 418 yet (it won't be available in Canada for another month) but according to this article Moffat has made the announcement that "Series 5" (or, as he called it in DWM 417, Series Fnarg) is going to be officially known as Season 31. Now I'd rather wait to see what happens when the BBC officially announces its schedule whether they actually do this or not. If they do, then we need to come up with a consensus as to what to call not only this article, but retroactively the 2005-2008 seasons. If 2010 is called Season 31 officially, do we rename the other articles Seasons 27-30? Or do we stick with 1-4 despite the discontinuity in numbering? Or do we keep the original and revival series separate (even if Moffat is clearly integrating them by using Season 31) and stick with Series 5? It's just numbering, but this is actually an emotional issue for some people and I don't really want to see us start a "Move edit war" over this. I'd rather we come to an agreement before articles are moved, or remain where they are. My personal view is if Series 5 is "Season 31" officially, we should retroactively rename the other seasons articles for the sake of simplicity. However I'm not one of those who treats this as an emotional issue so I'm quite fine to leave things status quo. (Just as long as the BBC doesn't follow through with the "Series 1" idea, I'm happy.) [[User:23skidoo|23skidoo]] 03:58, February 18, 2010 (UTC) | ||
:Even if this year's episodes are officially listed-as/called/referred- to-by/addressed-as/nicknamed/shadowmongered/hufnied/produced-under-the-title-of Season 31 I don't think we should retroactively change anything officially listed as Series' 1 through 4 either in this wiki or anywhere else. Firstly it will be a massive headache and secondly my boxset says The complete series 3 and that's what I'm calling it forever. | :Even if this year's episodes are officially listed-as/called/referred- to-by/addressed-as/nicknamed/shadowmongered/hufnied/produced-under-the-title-of Season 31 I don't think we should retroactively change anything officially listed as Series' 1 through 4 either in this wiki or anywhere else. Firstly it will be a massive headache and secondly my boxset says The complete series 3 and that's what I'm calling it forever. --[[User:Stillnotginger|Stillnotginger]] 04:16, February 18, 2010 (UTC) | ||
