Theory:Doctor Who television discontinuity and plot holes/Mission to the Unknown: Difference between revisions

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
no edit summary
No edit summary
No edit summary
Tag: 2017 source edit
Line 5: Line 5:
::It's pretty clear that, for some reason, almost every astronomical term we use means something different in the "galactic universe of the solar system" of Doctor Who. I think we have to assume they're using some term that has no real equivalent to anything in our world's science, and "solar system" is just a bad translation.
::It's pretty clear that, for some reason, almost every astronomical term we use means something different in the "galactic universe of the solar system" of Doctor Who. I think we have to assume they're using some term that has no real equivalent to anything in our world's science, and "solar system" is just a bad translation.
:::Possibly relevant: Back in ''[[The Daleks (TV story)]]'' there is a moment where the Doctor asks Dyoni "And this- is this a solar system?" - referring to a star chart. Dyoni responds "Yes- Skaro is the twelfth planet." Interestingly however, Hartnell's diction as he delivers the line- whilst hunched over and leaning forward- makes it ambiguously possible to interpret what is spoken as "And this- is this Earth's solar system?"- hence making Dyoni's reply denote Skaro as a notional twelfth planet of ''our'' solar system. Granted, this is rather more astronomically unfeasible than usual, given the temperate climate of Skaro, not to mention its unlikelyhood in relation to almost every other story, but, perhaps, Terry Nation was remembering this line as delivered, when Malpha refers to the Daleks as "A power from the Solar System", and later, to humans as "hostile beings from the ''centre'' of the Solar System", and considering the Daleks as originating on one of the outer planets of our own star system- far closer to home than is usually considered the case.  It doesn't really rationalise it consistently within the fiction, because placing Skaro there would be lunacy from a continuity point of view, but it may explain the presence of the lines in the dialogue.
:::Possibly relevant: Back in ''[[The Daleks (TV story)]]'' there is a moment where the Doctor asks Dyoni "And this- is this a solar system?" - referring to a star chart. Dyoni responds "Yes- Skaro is the twelfth planet." Interestingly however, Hartnell's diction as he delivers the line- whilst hunched over and leaning forward- makes it ambiguously possible to interpret what is spoken as "And this- is this Earth's solar system?"- hence making Dyoni's reply denote Skaro as a notional twelfth planet of ''our'' solar system. Granted, this is rather more astronomically unfeasible than usual, given the temperate climate of Skaro, not to mention its unlikelyhood in relation to almost every other story, but, perhaps, Terry Nation was remembering this line as delivered, when Malpha refers to the Daleks as "A power from the Solar System", and later, to humans as "hostile beings from the ''centre'' of the Solar System", and considering the Daleks as originating on one of the outer planets of our own star system- far closer to home than is usually considered the case.  It doesn't really rationalise it consistently within the fiction, because placing Skaro there would be lunacy from a continuity point of view, but it may explain the presence of the lines in the dialogue.
:::: Alternatively, the line as delivered in this story is, "We six from the outer galaxies, joining with a power from the Solar System; the Daleks!" Perhaps Malpha meant the six outer galactic powers, plus an unspecified and not yet present power from the Solar system (as revealed in [[The Daleks' Master Plan (TV story)]] to be Mavic Chen), plus the Daleks.


[[Category:DW TV discontinuity]]
[[Category:DW TV discontinuity]]
97

edits

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.