Theory:Doctor Who television discontinuity and plot holes/The Big Bang: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
Theory:Doctor Who television discontinuity and plot holes/The Big Bang (edit)
Revision as of 13:27, 15 March 2022
, 15 March 2022no edit summary
No edit summary Tag: 2017 source edit |
No edit summary Tag: 2017 source edit |
||
| Line 271: | Line 271: | ||
:: Same reason Amy was able to remember the Clerics in Flesh and Stone; they weren't part of her timeline. | :: Same reason Amy was able to remember the Clerics in Flesh and Stone; they weren't part of her timeline. | ||
:: River may have remembered fully, but it was Amy who had the gift to bring the Doctor back due having grown up with a crack in her bedroom. There's also the possibility that River didn't really remember, but had subconscious memories nagging her. So she followed | :: River may have remembered fully, but it was Amy who had the gift to bring the Doctor back due having grown up with a crack in her bedroom. There's also the possibility that River didn't really remember, but had subconscious memories nagging her. So she followed her instincts. | ||
* How come if there were two Stone Daleks only one came alive? | * How come if there were two Stone Daleks only one came alive? | ||
| Line 283: | Line 283: | ||
:: Amy is an anomaly, or a complex space-time event. | :: Amy is an anomaly, or a complex space-time event. | ||
::: No she's not, her parents were not erased from all history, they were simply taken from a moment after she was born, and she forgot them. Which means there is no paradox in her existing. | ::: No she's not, her parents were not erased from all history, they were simply taken from a moment after she was born, and she forgot them. Which means there is no paradox in her existing. | ||
:::: They were erased from being born per the crack's effect. | |||
* Also if there were no stars, how is Amy even born. No stars would change history in so many ways. If there were nothing beyond the earth but darkness, then religion would dominate science. Indeed several religions where stars are significant would not exist and Amy would never ever be born. You can't say the TARDIS would hold this event in time, because nothing in the show says that. And its bad, "not thought out" writing if everyone else has to make up stuff that isn't there to make sense of the plot. Also why would it hold certain things like Amy being born but not others like what you see in the museum. | * Also if there were no stars, how is Amy even born. No stars would change history in so many ways. If there were nothing beyond the earth but darkness, then religion would dominate science. Indeed several religions where stars are significant would not exist and Amy would never ever be born. You can't say the TARDIS would hold this event in time, because nothing in the show says that. And its bad, "not thought out" writing if everyone else has to make up stuff that isn't there to make sense of the plot. Also why would it hold certain things like Amy being born but not others like what you see in the museum. | ||
