8
edits
Talk:Flesh and Stone (TV story): Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
→The Doctor's Jacket
Mc hammark (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 39: | Line 39: | ||
Well if the two doctors theories are ridiculous, can you explain what he said when he came back wearing the jacket? he told her to remember what he told her when she was 7. This wasn't mentioned later in that episode, as if it didn't have anything to do with it. It clearly has a significance in a future episode, where we will find out what he meant and what is the important thing he told her. Plus, the next shot goes directly to the doctor (with no jacket), River and the bishop all together, as they left together, so the doctor didnt go back to Amy and rush back to them. If he is the same doctor and the jacket is just a production mistake, then at least at the end of the episode the doctor should have told Amy what he wanted her to remember, and why was it important for her to remember! certainly not significant to this story.[[Special:Contributions/91.73.110.104|91.73.110.104]] 09:40, May 3, 2010 (UTC) | Well if the two doctors theories are ridiculous, can you explain what he said when he came back wearing the jacket? he told her to remember what he told her when she was 7. This wasn't mentioned later in that episode, as if it didn't have anything to do with it. It clearly has a significance in a future episode, where we will find out what he meant and what is the important thing he told her. Plus, the next shot goes directly to the doctor (with no jacket), River and the bishop all together, as they left together, so the doctor didnt go back to Amy and rush back to them. If he is the same doctor and the jacket is just a production mistake, then at least at the end of the episode the doctor should have told Amy what he wanted her to remember, and why was it important for her to remember! certainly not significant to this story.[[Special:Contributions/91.73.110.104|91.73.110.104]] 09:40, May 3, 2010 (UTC) | ||
What I think really gives the scene away, is the way he says "Later Amy! River, gonna need your computer!" the line sort of quietens down as if hes moving away - there is also a lot of shots showing the doctors sleeves down. Then...Cut to rolled up sleeves, a new jacket, and a different doctor - I cant imagine it being a production error - it seems to well silly why when none of the other shots in the forest have him in the jacket, does he suddenly wear it? Makes no sense to me to be one - also lets not forget who is penning the series now? Moffet likes his little paradox stories - in my opinion its another Doctor - though we wont know until we know the significance of that line. "Remember what I told you when you were 7" I've watched the 11th hour several times and I cant think about what line he could mean" | |||
