Trusted
49,191
edits
Forum:Temporary forums/Relaxing the past-tense requirement: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
Forum:Temporary forums/Relaxing the past-tense requirement (view source)
Revision as of 19:55, 6 April 2023
, 6 April 2023→Discussion
m (→Discussion) |
|||
| Line 47: | Line 47: | ||
::: However. | ::: However. | ||
::: I strongly '''reject''' the idea of having an "out of universe box" on the top of articles. '''''Just no.''''' With the tops of articles, they are already cluttered with templates like {{tlx|character stub}}, {{tlx|ImageLink}}, etc. {{tlx|You may}}, {{tlx|for}}, {{tlx|dab page}} are the worst cases of templates at the top of pages, and while their clunky appearance will be fixed if converted to hatnotes, these will take up a lot of room at the top of articles. ''And this isn't even factoring in @[[User:Bongolium500|Bongo50]]'s tab template for [[T:SUBPAGE|subpages]]!'' We absolutely do not need another template at the top of articles. Additionally, I feel being limited to just three sentences will remove any ability to write with nuanced details, or even if we want to include last regular appearance dates, multiple actors, or | ::: I strongly '''reject''' the idea of having an "out of universe box" on the top of articles. '''''Just no.''''' With the tops of articles, they are already cluttered with templates like {{tlx|character stub}}, {{tlx|ImageLink}}, etc. {{tlx|You may}}, {{tlx|for}}, {{tlx|dab page}} are the worst cases of templates at the top of pages, and while their clunky appearance will be fixed if converted to hatnotes, these will take up a lot of room at the top of articles. ''And this isn't even factoring in @[[User:Bongolium500|Bongo50]]'s tab template for [[T:SUBPAGE|subpages]]!'' We absolutely do not need another template at the top of articles. Additionally, I feel being limited to just three sentences will remove any ability to write with nuanced details, or even if we want to include last regular appearance dates, multiple actors, or characters retroactively named or conflated, etc. And this won't even allow us to say if the character we're talking about was only a minor character in their debut story but was expanded upon in later stories or adaptions. Therefore, the only possible soloution I see is to have completely out of universe leads. | ||
::: This being said, it doesn't mean we have to completely redo every single article lead. I still feel they should contain a brief summary of their biographical details, but if it is to be done from an out-of-universe perspective we can, for example, talk about the conflicting accounts of the [[Eighth Doctor]]'s life with an additional layer of detail than something like "''Leading a life of great temporal complexity, the Eighth Doctor was so frequently involved in time paradoxes and parallel universes that it was impossible to know with certainty how the major epochs of his existence fitted together.''"; we can briefly detail Eight's main series (e.g. EDAs, DWM comics, Big Finish) and how they all intersect (and not) and then explain that certain stories (e.g. ''[[Zagreus (audio story)|Zagreus]]'') attempts to reconcile the discrepancies. | ::: This being said, it doesn't mean we have to completely redo every single article lead. I still feel they should contain a brief summary of their biographical details, but if it is to be done from an out-of-universe perspective we can, for example, talk about the conflicting accounts of the [[Eighth Doctor]]'s life with an additional layer of detail than something like "''Leading a life of great temporal complexity, the Eighth Doctor was so frequently involved in time paradoxes and parallel universes that it was impossible to know with certainty how the major epochs of his existence fitted together.''"; we can briefly detail Eight's main series (e.g. EDAs, DWM comics, Big Finish) and how they all intersect (and not) and then explain that certain stories (e.g. ''[[Zagreus (audio story)|Zagreus]]'') attempts to reconcile the discrepancies. | ||
::: Otherwise, I agree with @[[User:Jack "BtR" Saxon|Jack "BtR" Saxon]] about implementing tenses on real world people pages and on pages about future releases. I am a little unsure about using present tense on pages like [[yellow]] and [[arm]]. In understand where this idea is coming from, and it does make sense, but on the flipside @Jack "BtR" Saxon does have a good point about potential confusion. | ::: Otherwise, I agree with @[[User:Jack "BtR" Saxon|Jack "BtR" Saxon]] about implementing tenses on real world people pages and on pages about future releases. I am a little unsure about using present tense on pages like [[yellow]] and [[arm]]. In understand where this idea is coming from, and it does make sense, but on the flipside @Jack "BtR" Saxon does have a good point about potential confusion. | ||
::: If needs be, I can draft what I feel would be best for an out-of-universe lead. {{User:Epsilon the Eternal/signature}} 19:53, 6 April 2023 (UTC) | ::: If needs be, I can draft what I feel would be best for an out-of-universe lead. {{User:Epsilon the Eternal/signature}} 19:53, 6 April 2023 (UTC) | ||
