Forum:Deleted Scenes and Rule 4 By Proxy: Difference between revisions

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
no edit summary
Tag: 2017 source edit
No edit summary
Line 316: Line 316:


Additionally, regarding ''The Pilot Episode'', I do see value in its use as a valid source. It'd help fleshing out what exactly the [[Fourth dimension]] meant back then, at least! I'm uncertain, however, if the changes between the Pilot and aired episode are of the same level as [[Dr. Who and the Daleks (theatrical film)]] for separate pages to be an advantage; the shift from the Pilot's characterizations to those of later episodes is more gradual and part of the journey that was aired, and even the backstories given in the Pilot have relevance to the aired episodes (it's not like we're living in the universe of ''[[The Pitch of Fear (TV story)|The Pitch of Fear]]''). Regarding [[Palimpsest universe]]s, as was already mentioned in the opening post, the idea expressed in the late '90s novels was that all the shifts in backstory lore were in-universe temporal shifts, including the half-human and loom stuff, that resulted in the universe being in-universe as contradictory and multi-possibility as it is in reality; we cover those later things in "accounts" language, no [Seventh Doctor (Lungbarrow] and [Seventh Doctor (The Enemy Within)], and I believe the same would work with the Pilot (same introductory story and events, just with different speeches). The core idea of ''Unnatural History'' is that the Doctor is in-universe the same character in all their versions and overwritten timelines: the human of the 1960s becomes the Time Lord of the 1970s becomes the half-human of the 1990s, a form of "continuity of consciousness" even if the 1990s Doctor doesn't usually remember his other backstories. Perhaps this argument interferes with the careful balance being sought here, but that's my two cents. Never hurts to explore the horizon, ''said Icarus''. [[User:TheChampionOfTime|<span style="font-family:Old English Text MT">CoT</span>]]  [[User talk:TheChampionOfTime|<span title="Talk to me">?</span> ]] 16:21, 10 May 2023 (UTC)
Additionally, regarding ''The Pilot Episode'', I do see value in its use as a valid source. It'd help fleshing out what exactly the [[Fourth dimension]] meant back then, at least! I'm uncertain, however, if the changes between the Pilot and aired episode are of the same level as [[Dr. Who and the Daleks (theatrical film)]] for separate pages to be an advantage; the shift from the Pilot's characterizations to those of later episodes is more gradual and part of the journey that was aired, and even the backstories given in the Pilot have relevance to the aired episodes (it's not like we're living in the universe of ''[[The Pitch of Fear (TV story)|The Pitch of Fear]]''). Regarding [[Palimpsest universe]]s, as was already mentioned in the opening post, the idea expressed in the late '90s novels was that all the shifts in backstory lore were in-universe temporal shifts, including the half-human and loom stuff, that resulted in the universe being in-universe as contradictory and multi-possibility as it is in reality; we cover those later things in "accounts" language, no [Seventh Doctor (Lungbarrow] and [Seventh Doctor (The Enemy Within)], and I believe the same would work with the Pilot (same introductory story and events, just with different speeches). The core idea of ''Unnatural History'' is that the Doctor is in-universe the same character in all their versions and overwritten timelines: the human of the 1960s becomes the Time Lord of the 1970s becomes the half-human of the 1990s, a form of "continuity of consciousness" even if the 1990s Doctor doesn't usually remember his other backstories. Perhaps this argument interferes with the careful balance being sought here, but that's my two cents. Never hurts to explore the horizon, ''said Icarus''. [[User:TheChampionOfTime|<span style="font-family:Old English Text MT">CoT</span>]]  [[User talk:TheChampionOfTime|<span title="Talk to me">?</span> ]] 16:21, 10 May 2023 (UTC)
:Wow, I almost missed this thread! After reading through the above, I agree with [[User:Aquanafrahudy|Aquanafrahudy]]'s analysis of the Rule 1 concerns, [[User:Pluto2|Pluto2]]'s comment on Rule 3, and [[User:OncomingStorm25th|OS25]]'s treatment of Rule 4 (especially given [[User:TheChampionOfTime|<span style="font-family:Old English Text MT">CoT</span>]]'s comment, which I believe heartily bolsters the case for ''The Pilot Episode''). For these reasons, I support the coverage of ''P.S.'', ''The Pilot Episode'', and the scenes from ''Remembrance'' and ''Journey's End'' as valid DVD extras. I have many further thoughts regarding R4BP, [[Carnathon]], and {{tlx|NCmaterial}}, but I'll save them for a different occasion. – [[User:NateBumber|n8]] ([[User talk:NateBumber|☎]]) 17:11, 10 May 2023 (UTC)
emailconfirmed, Administrators
15,041

edits

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.