60
edits
Talk:Melody Pond: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
→The Impossible Astronaut
| Line 153: | Line 153: | ||
I think its fair enough to say that the current order it reversed, but it might not always be the case for two simple reasons: | I think its fair enough to say that the current order it reversed, but it might not always be the case for two simple reasons: | ||
1) The Diaries wouldn't work. If the order was perfect reverse | 1) The Diaries wouldn't work. If the order was in perfect reverse compared to the other, there would be no point in the diaries whatsoever, because there would be no events in the Doctor's that would be in River's at the same time except for the events that they just experienced together (and even then only before they parted ways). For an event to be in both their pasts then they must meet out of (reverse) order some of the time. Although the order is clearly ''generally ''reversed. | ||
2) We have know of two specific out of order events: | 2) We have know of two specific out of order events: | ||
A) River has not been given the Doctor's Sonic Screwdriver from our perspective; therefore a Doctor from our future must contact a River from our past (i.e. between Silence in the Library and The Time of Angels). I believe it was the "picnic as asgard" where their timelines seemed to be in sync (his last meeting with her, and her second to last meeting with him). | A) River has not been given the Doctor's Sonic Screwdriver from our perspective yet; therefore a Doctor from our future must contact a River from our past (i.e. between Silence in the Library and The Time of Angels). I believe it was the "picnic as asgard" where their timelines seemed to be in sync (his last meeting with her, and her second to last meeting with him). | ||
B) The FutureDoc10 from the begining of the Impossible Astronaut, who seemed to be "in-sync" with the River of that time (unlike the PresentDoc10 to whom River is still a fairly new companion).[[User:Looq|Looq]] 02:41, May 1, 2011 (UTC) | B) The FutureDoc10 from the begining of the Impossible Astronaut, who seemed to be "in-sync" with the River of that time (unlike the PresentDoc10 to whom River is still a fairly new companion). [[User:Looq|Looq]] 02:41, May 1, 2011 (UTC) | ||
We need to wait to see how the Doctor's death resolves/unresolves/whatever, but River does say that they went to see the opera just before ''Silence in the Library''/''Forest of the Dead'' when she presumably receives the screwdriver. This could very easily be right before the Doctor sends the geo letters. [[User:Witoki|Witoki]] 02:43, May 1, 2011 (UTC) | We need to wait to see how the Doctor's death resolves/unresolves/whatever, but River does say that they went to see the opera just before ''Silence in the Library''/''Forest of the Dead'' when she presumably receives the screwdriver. This could very easily be right before the Doctor sends the geo letters. [[User:Witoki|Witoki]] 02:43, May 1, 2011 (UTC) | ||
