Howling:The Little Girl's True Identity: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
Howling:The Little Girl's True Identity (view source)
Revision as of 09:47, 29 May 2011
, 29 May 2011no edit summary
No edit summary |
No edit summary |
||
| Line 59: | Line 59: | ||
I'm afraid that you're failing to distinguish between "evidence" and "speculation". The above is speculation. It isn't evidence. Other points apart, it would be difficult to find any moment in any episode where it would '''not '''be possible for an invisible TARDIS to be involved, especially if its engines were on silent. [[Special:Contributions/2.96.25.48|2.96.25.48]] 08:50, May 29, 2011 (UTC) | I'm afraid that you're failing to distinguish between "evidence" and "speculation". The above is speculation. It isn't evidence. Other points apart, it would be difficult to find any moment in any episode where it would '''not '''be possible for an invisible TARDIS to be involved, especially if its engines were on silent. [[Special:Contributions/2.96.25.48|2.96.25.48]] 08:50, May 29, 2011 (UTC) | ||
Some comments and questions (answers in short supply): | |||
River, when she's not on unauthorised leave of absence, is in jail in the 52nd century for killing someone. She's not at all likely to be there for killing someone <b>more than 3000 years earlier</b>. | |||
River has been stated to be "100% human", in circumstances where Steven Moffatt is extremely unlikely to have been lying. Not just "human" but "100% human". Human <b>and nothing else</b>. | |||
A spacesuit which may or may not have had someone in it apparently killed the Doctor in 2011. Its visor was undamaged. | |||
Just before it shot him, the Doctor spoke to the spacesuit as to someone he knew. | |||
A similar spacesuit had a little girl in it in 1969 <b>but she escaped from it in that year</b>. Was she put back in it before the incident with the Doctor and how old was she by then? If she lived through the intervening time normally, she'd be in the region of 51. The bullet hole in the visor could have been repaired almost any time in the 40-odd years since 1969. Alternatively, in the girl's timeline, did the incident with the Doctor occur before her escape in 1969? That's possible if she travelled in time and would explain why the visor had no bullet hole. Amy hadn't yet shot at it. | |||
The spacesuit containing the little girl allowed her to phone for help and defaulted to phoning the US President. Whilst talking to the President, the girl spoke of a spaceman coming to eat her. If she wasn't in the spacesuit at the time, how did she phone the President? If she was in the spacesuit at the time, who/what was the spaceman that was coming to eat her? Another spacesuit? Something else? If it was another spacesuit, that suit wouldn't have a bullet hole from Amy's shot. | |||
In early 1970, the little girl was in New York and was dying, so she regenerated in what seems to be the same way as a Time Lord. It didn't just happen to her, she knew she could do that and seemed to have a fairly good idea what to expect from the process. Even if she were a full Time Lord, not a half-human and not some new kind of being created in imitation of the Time Lords, how did she know? Who told her? Had she seen the process before? [[Special:Contributions/78.146.188.114|78.146.188.114]] 09:47, May 29, 2011 (UTC) | |||
