Talk:The mighty 200

I do not think this page sahould be deleted it was a poll conducted in doctor who magizine and therefor seeing as this wiki is dedicated to all things doctor who I think it whould stay. If it is deleted then I will make another one and if that version is deleted then I will make another do I make myself clear. --Catkind121 14:47, December 7, 2009 (UTC)

How is this page any more special or relevant than the numerous other polls that DWM have run? Or indeed any more/less special than any of the other articles that DWM creates?

Additionally I might note that this is not the first time this article has been created, The Mighty 200, Doctor Who Magazine: The Mighty 200, The Mighty 200 (2) all of which were created around September, and deleted. This wiki is an encyclopaedia of Doctor Who yes, however 'The Mighty 200' was a reader poll of Doctor Who, the opinions/votes are from the readers of Doctor Who Magazine, the awards were given by what the readers have voted on. Which means the poll is the reader's views on Doctor Who rather than being about Doctor Who. --Tangerineduel 15:14, December 7, 2009 (UTC)

I belive this is a Doctor who wiki, and therefore since this covers Doctor Who and Doctor Who Mercandising, then I belive that it should stay. JM 18:13, December 7, 2009 (UTC)

Yes, this wiki does cover merchandising. But the poll isn't merchandise. The Doctor Who Magazine is the merchandise. The poll is a section within the magazine.

How is this article doing anything more than re-publishing what's in the magazine? Or servicing information?

What about the DWM 79 - Season Poll, DWM 169 - Annual Poll, DWM 176 - DWM Poll and DWM 332 - DVD Poll? Plus the numerous other polls that are within the DWM issues that don't currently have articles. --Tangerineduel 03:23, December 8, 2009 (UTC)

This should stay as it still covers Doctor Who, those other polls can be as they are linked with Doctor Who. I think as this is linked with the episodes, and 200 episodes was a landmark celebrated, I feel that the artical should stay.JM 17:42, December 8, 2009 (UTC)

All the articles within the Doctor Who Magazine (and Doctor Who Adventures for that matter) cover Doctor Who, that's hardly an argument for each article from the magazine to have their own articles here.

Again I come back to the validity of the poll, given that it was a reader poll and as I've said is reader opinion rather than facts about Doctor Who/concerning Doctor Who. --Tangerineduel 12:01, December 9, 2009 (UTC)

No, we don't need this page. It's just the opinions of some of the people in 2009. It's only really relevant until they make more episodes or there's new fans of the show or people's opinions change. Unless it was the opinions of the actual creators of the show, it's irrelevant for the Tardis Wiki (even then, it would probably just be a small section for the individual pages). If you want opinions on episodes, there are plenty of Doctor Who sites which aren't encyclopedias. -<Azes13 19:16, December 9, 2009 (UTC)

I agree. It is a pointless page which does not contribute to the wiki in any positive way. Tardis1963 20:59, December 9, 2009 (UTC)

Well we do I think iot is a nice feature. --Catkind121 09:22, December 10, 2009 (UTC)

With two admins against the article will be deleted. As a concession I've re-written the DWM 413 with info concerning the top 10, as these were actual articles with analysis of the stories. --Tangerineduel 14:00, December 10, 2009 (UTC)