User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-1506468-20190827123101/@comment-1350697-20190828201850

Scrooge MacDuck wrote: So they are, for my money. Although concerning whether it's "in the same club as The Incomplete Death's Head" — well, I think the meat of the debate this time around wasn't a matter of Rule 4, but rather of Rule 3: Amorkuz disagrees (disagreed?) on whether Wylder's way of distributing the works counted as properly "publishing" them.

I make this point in the post above, but just in case it gets lost in there: The BBC themselves have frequently made stories available exclusively as text on a web page or as PDFs -- The Lonely Computer, The Advent of Fear (short story), Wish You Were Here, etcetera -- so the idea that these forms of release are in some way inadequate seems to me to be baseless -- and if this wiki has policies to the effect that the form of release matters at all in this way, I'm not aware.