User:SOTO/Forum Archive/Inclusion debates/@comment-45314928-20200606025128/@comment-45692830-20200606035103

Well they asked her about the unproduced story, not the short story he wrote. So obviously she answered the question they asked. It's incredibly bizarre that you want us to "go with what was stated by Harness himself" but aren't willing to actually read what Cook said and take her at her word. You're quite clearly misinterpreting.

I did say "at best". I don't think this reading is at all plausible. He posted this as part of the Lockdown! event, we know that Lockdown! releases are in some sense coordinated with Chibnall, and we know that similar framing devices have happened before. (Note that his earlier Lockdown! release itself had a similarly meta framing device.)

Also, Shambala, out of curiosity, why the change from Real World to invalid? I'm not sure how these discussions go but that seems to me to violate T:BOUND, changing a neutral stance to a negative one. Does starting a debate instantly change the tag? I'm curious as to why that happened.