User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-188432-20130129081336/@comment-1166667-20130402153114

The fact is that three women with similar names and similar characteristics were portrayed by the same woman.

That is all you have to go on. For all we know, they're all just related and there is a familial link. We cannot assume a connection that has yet to be explained.

Meanwhile, in the "separate" camp, we have two women dead and one alive. Basic biology that has yet to be disproven. How is death speculation?

You stake your claim on this show being one where people have beaten death before, but likewise this show has had beings that change and morph their appearance. You cannot assume anything until the show explicitly states it. And the show has not done that. The Doctor has no idea what's going on. He's hypothesizing.

If you are so sure that these three women from different centuries are the same woman, then tell us in no uncertain terms how that is the case. Give me the fact of how they are the same and I will concede.