User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-188432-20130129081336/@comment-1293767-20130402130105

Witoki wrote: Total semantic point, but how would we order the C.O.O. page? Oswin, Clara Oswin, Clara? I get the feeling that Clara's run in with TGI influences how Oswin and Clara Oswin are so clever, but obviously we have no proof of that thus far.

Also, how do we deal with things like "Home Planet" and "Affiliation", or even "Name" if they are not all the same? Would we have three separate Infoboxes within the article? We also have a birth and death date for Clara Oswin, and the issue of species for Oswin (human or Dalek?)

It's somewhat ironic that the conversation has bent in the direction of one page, when before we met the contemporary Clara, the consensus seemed to point to separation until proven same.

Also, minor point against "same person": Clara Oswin died just after her 23rd birthday (her gravestone), while Clara is at least 24 when she meets the Doctor (her book).

All things I agree with. It would be a mess to try and have them all on one page. There's too much contradiction and blatant speculation. (Except on your last point: Clara Oswin Oswald was 26 when she died [born on November 23], but Clara Oswald's book points to her being only 24. Your general point still stands though.)