User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-188432-20130129081336/@comment-5473162-20130401111447

OttselSpy25 wrote:

Sigh... BECAUSE IN The Way Through the Woods THE DOCTOR AND RORY HAVE A LONG CONVERSATION WHERE THEY AGREE THAT ALTHOUGH RORY AND HIS AUTON DUPLICATE WERE THE SAME THEORETICALLY, THEY WERE ALSO DIFFERENT. EVEN THOUGH HE SHARED SOME OF THEIR MEMORIES, THEY WERE SAID TO BE DIFFERENT PEOPLE.

There, you happy? The reason is that we have an in-universe secondary page on Rory is that we have an in-universe source that says that they were different. Now will everyone please stop trying to relate the case of Clara to other cases? I've heard one too many irrelevant and stupid "Ooooh, but the Master is all together" "what about the teselecta?" arguments in these and they're quite frankly annoying and tedious. The case of the Claras is a unique one that will take decisions based off of it's own right, so let's just discuss it as it is and not as a theoretical relation; ALRIGHT?

Sorry to get mad, but no one seems to be able to focus in this discussion!

Could you be any more insulting to people? Really, relax. I know we're all fans, but it's still just a TV show.

If I could make a general suggestion, why don't we take a page from how we have information for the Doctor and Romana on here - one page with the basic character information, and separate pages for each incarnation? Boom. Everybody wins.