User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-24894325-20161219001033/@comment-25117610-20170528205339

Ok, it's been a while since we discussed anything on here. While it's clear we haven't reached a consensus on what to do with the navigation templates, I believe the one thing we got was: Big Finish uses "ranges" in a different way we do.

For them, it makes sense to put The Jago & Litefoot Revival and The Tenth Doctor Adventures: Volume One under the same "range", because a buyer is much more likely to find a Tenth Doctor story in "The Tenth Doctor Collected" than in "Short Trips".

However, putting Destiny of the Doctor: The Complete Adventure, Assembled and The Ninth Doctor Chronicles in the same range is just a bit messy (for our perspective).

Therefore, I believe {{NS}} really needs to be split, because each audio series in there is completly different from each other. It would be like trying to put Graceless (audio series), Charlotte Pollard (audio series), Fourth Doctor Adventures (audio series) and Doom Coalition (audio series) all in the same navbox: uninformative, and just crowded.

As of now, only The Ninth Doctor Chronicles (though, IMO, it is part of a "New Who Companion Chronicles", even though we don't have an official name yet.)

By my logic, we'd need nav for: The War Doctor (audio series), The Diary of River Song (audio series), The Churchill Years (audio series), Classic Doctors, New Monsters: Volume One and The Tenth Doctor Adventures (audio series), because these are established audio series, much like UNIT: The New Series, which does have an navbox of it's own.