User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-43908-20150311013943/@comment-9435571-20150827204420

Even if they weren't originally meant to be the same incarnation, some minor differences in physical description aside (not any more than with early book Benny vs. Lisa Bowerman, both are young women with dark hair and a fringe), there isn't really any information on the two third Romanas that is actually in conflict. Not any more than between book Romana II and "Gallifrey" Romana II characterization-wise. So I still don't see much of a reason to have separate pages for the two if they are found to both directly follow Lalla Ward.

I know that the *creator* of Trey didn't intend her to be the same Romana III as the one in the books, but in the end, she turned out to be similar enough that any discrepancies aren't really on the level of a red-haired Twelfth Doctor or Shalka Doctor and Eccleston.