Trusted
25,502
edits
Forum:Validity: Consider Yourself One of Us… (edit)
Revision as of 16:44, 3 December 2024
, 3 December→Opening
(Created page with "{{Forumheader|Inclusion debates}} <!-- Please put your content under this line. Be sure to sign your edits with four tildes ~~~~ --> == Opening == I'm gonna try my hand at arguing for validity on something that really has no strong evidence one way or the other, but that I think should be valid anyway because, well, I don't see why it ''can{{'}}t'' be. {{cs|Consider Yourself One Of Us... (TV story)}} was BBC One's big Christmas promo for 2011. It featured a host o...") |
|||
| Line 9: | Line 9: | ||
The promo takes a dip into meta-fictional territory: [[Brendan O'Carroll]] appears in full get-up as the [[Agnes Brown|titular matriarch]] of ''[[Mrs. Brown's Boys (series)|Mrs. Brown's Boys]]'', and [[The Gruffalo (character)|the Graffalo]], in all his animated glory, even gets a brief look-in. | The promo takes a dip into meta-fictional territory: [[Brendan O'Carroll]] appears in full get-up as the [[Agnes Brown|titular matriarch]] of ''[[Mrs. Brown's Boys (series)|Mrs. Brown's Boys]]'', and [[The Gruffalo (character)|the Graffalo]], in all his animated glory, even gets a brief look-in. | ||
And of course, we get a Cyberman playing Twister with Matt Smith and Karen Gillan - ''or'' the [[Eleventh Doctor]] and [[Amy Pond]], depending on your interpretation. The latter is ''my'' interpretation | And of course, we get a Cyberman playing Twister with Matt Smith and Karen Gillan - ''or'' the [[Eleventh Doctor]] and [[Amy Pond]], depending on your interpretation. The latter is, if course, ''my'' interpretation. | ||
It was decided a while back that not all BBC idents should necessarily be invalid by default. Previously invalid idents like {{cs|The Doctor and the Reindeer (TV story)}} and {{cs|Sprout Boy meets a Galaxy of Stars (TV story)}} were welcomed into the validity club. ''Consider Yourself'' was not one of them, because… I dunno. Why not? | It was decided a while back that not all BBC idents should necessarily be invalid by default. Previously invalid idents like {{cs|The Doctor and the Reindeer (TV story)}} and {{cs|Sprout Boy meets a Galaxy of Stars (TV story)}} were welcomed into the validity club. ''Consider Yourself'' was not one of them, because… I dunno. Why not? | ||