Brief Encounter: Difference between revisions
(tweaks all over the place; getting sentence agreement now that the title is properly rendered in the singular; improving definitions gerally) |
|||
| Line 13: | Line 13: | ||
''Brief Encounter'''s "what if?" format was meant to challenge reader's perceptions of the then-fledgling "[[Doctor Who universe|''Doctor Who'' universe]]". At the time, original, ''professional'' ''Doctor Who'' prose fiction had only just begun to be published on a frequent basis. There wasn't much in the ''Doctor Who'' canon for these ''Brief Encounter'' stories to offend. However, its publication in the pages of a physical magazine posed obvious problems of access. As time went on, it was increasingly difficult for later writers to even ''read'' these vignettes — much less incorporate their content into later works. Some of the concepts were thus later contradicted. For instance, according to the ''Brief Encounter'', ''[[Down to Earth (short story)|Down to Earth]]'', [[Liz Shaw]]'s first trip in [[the TARDIS]] was with the [[Fourth Doctor]], who had deliberately found Liz in order to apologise for not saying goodbye to her. The later novel, ''[[The Wages of Sin]]'', clearly states that the Third Doctor did indeed give Liz a trip in the TARDIS, with [[Jo Grant]], and that there would have been no need for the apology the Fourth Doctor offered in ''Down to Earth''. | ''Brief Encounter'''s "what if?" format was meant to challenge reader's perceptions of the then-fledgling "[[Doctor Who universe|''Doctor Who'' universe]]". At the time, original, ''professional'' ''Doctor Who'' prose fiction had only just begun to be published on a frequent basis. There wasn't much in the ''Doctor Who'' canon for these ''Brief Encounter'' stories to offend. However, its publication in the pages of a physical magazine posed obvious problems of access. As time went on, it was increasingly difficult for later writers to even ''read'' these vignettes — much less incorporate their content into later works. Some of the concepts were thus later contradicted. For instance, according to the ''Brief Encounter'', ''[[Down to Earth (short story)|Down to Earth]]'', [[Liz Shaw]]'s first trip in [[the TARDIS]] was with the [[Fourth Doctor]], who had deliberately found Liz in order to apologise for not saying goodbye to her. The later novel, ''[[The Wages of Sin]]'', clearly states that the Third Doctor did indeed give Liz a trip in the TARDIS, with [[Jo Grant]], and that there would have been no need for the apology the Fourth Doctor offered in ''Down to Earth''. | ||
Further frustrating the series' long-term impact on DWU fiction | Further frustrating the series' long-term impact on DWU fiction was the fact that many of them were simply ''whimsical''. Amongst the more imaginative ideas covered in the series were: | ||
*the implication that the [[Third Doctor]] watched [[Peter Cushing]] in ''[[Dr. Who and the Daleks]]'' | *the implication that the [[Third Doctor]] watched [[Peter Cushing]] in ''[[Dr. Who and the Daleks]]'' | ||
*the clear inference that [[writer]] [[John Lucarotti]] is himself a character in the [[Doctor Who universe|DWU]] | *the clear inference that [[writer]] [[John Lucarotti]] is himself a character in the [[Doctor Who universe|DWU]] | ||
Beyond anomalies of content are questions of style. It's not unusual to find ''Brief Encounter'' stories which | Beyond anomalies of content are questions of style. It's not unusual to find ''Brief Encounter'' stories which were written in the [[wikipedia:first person narrative|first person]]. Though not completely unknown in other prose work, it's still generally rare to find stories in the DWU which give such a personal perspective. Even the Doctor occasionally narrated proceedings — as in ''[[An Unfulfilled Dream]]'' — which is almost never the case in longer-form prose material. | ||
==Writers== | ==Writers== | ||
Revision as of 13:54, 5 September 2011
Brief Encounter was the umbrella title for an occasional series of vignettes that appeared in the Doctor Who Magazine family of publications from 1990 to 1994. The series tried to investigate characterisation and mood more than plot. Towards this end, it combined characters who had not been paired on television. While many of the stories featured the Doctor, a number did not, preferring to examine the lives of companions or villains at a time other than known adventures with the Doctor.
Overview
Brief Encounter's mandate was to ask "what if?" questions.
- What if this companion met that companion?
- What if this incarnation of the Doctor met another incarnation's assistant?
- What if this villain met that monster?
- What if we explored a tiny emotional beat in the life of a known character?
Examples of stories resulting from asking these sorts of questions included: a pedestrian collision between Sarah Jane Smith and Dodo Chaplet, a chess match between the Celestial Toymaker and Fenric and a wedding anniversary between the Brigadier and Doris Lethbridge-Stewart.
A largely forgotten corner of the DWU
Brief Encounter's "what if?" format was meant to challenge reader's perceptions of the then-fledgling "Doctor Who universe". At the time, original, professional Doctor Who prose fiction had only just begun to be published on a frequent basis. There wasn't much in the Doctor Who canon for these Brief Encounter stories to offend. However, its publication in the pages of a physical magazine posed obvious problems of access. As time went on, it was increasingly difficult for later writers to even read these vignettes — much less incorporate their content into later works. Some of the concepts were thus later contradicted. For instance, according to the Brief Encounter, Down to Earth, Liz Shaw's first trip in the TARDIS was with the Fourth Doctor, who had deliberately found Liz in order to apologise for not saying goodbye to her. The later novel, The Wages of Sin, clearly states that the Third Doctor did indeed give Liz a trip in the TARDIS, with Jo Grant, and that there would have been no need for the apology the Fourth Doctor offered in Down to Earth.
Further frustrating the series' long-term impact on DWU fiction was the fact that many of them were simply whimsical. Amongst the more imaginative ideas covered in the series were:
- the implication that the Third Doctor watched Peter Cushing in Dr. Who and the Daleks
- the clear inference that writer John Lucarotti is himself a character in the DWU
Beyond anomalies of content are questions of style. It's not unusual to find Brief Encounter stories which were written in the first person. Though not completely unknown in other prose work, it's still generally rare to find stories in the DWU which give such a personal perspective. Even the Doctor occasionally narrated proceedings — as in An Unfulfilled Dream — which is almost never the case in longer-form prose material.
Writers
The stories were quite often written by professional writers, and notably included the final work of television writer John Lucarotti and the first work of Paul Cornell. On at least one occasion in 1991, however, the series was the focus of a DWM competition, in which amateur writers were encouraged to submit their own "brief encounter" for possible publication. Andrew Cartmel, the Seventh Doctor's then-recently-disemployed script editor judged the competition, and pronounced a Seventh Doctor/K9 story the winner of the under-15 category, and a poignant meeting between the Doctor and a 6-year-old Katarina, the winner of the all-age group.
History of the format
The series began in DWM 167 with a very deliberate nod to the anniversary of Doctor Who. Since issue 167 was the November 1990 edition, Brief Encounter launched with a story by John Lucarotti, someone who had written during the First Doctor's era. The one-page, illustrated story became the norm for the series as seen in the pages of Doctor Who Magazine, clearly distinguishing it from other, longer short stories that the magazine occasionally published. Future instalments would stick to this format, or perhaps add a second page.
The series would also travel to a few of the DWM specials and the first couple of editions of the Doctor Who Yearbook series. However, the series was over by July 1994 in DWM proper, and it didn't extend past the DWMS Holiday 1992 special issue and the 1993 yearbook.
However, because short stories continued in the Yearbook series, some reference works have lumped stories in, say, the 1995 yearbook with the Brief Encounter series. Such grouping is unjustified. These later Yearbook stories never get the Brief Encounter masthead. Moreover, they're far longer than the typical entry in the series — often extending to five or six pages. They also use combinations of characters that would be expected from watching the television series, and therefore read as merely another adventure for a particular TARDIS crew. Indeed, short stories after the 1993 Yearbook have much more in common with stories in the annualss of the 21st century than they do with the Brief Encounter series.
