The Ultimate Foe (TV story)

Synopsis

The final episode in the season-long 'Trial of a Time Lord' saga, a surprise appearance of the Master reveals the treachery of the High Council of Time Lords, and that the Valeyard is not what he appears to be.

Plot

With the evidence complete, the Doctor learns that the Master has gained illicit access to the Matrix in his TARDIS. Glitz is now revealed to be the Master's associate and the 'secrets' to be information stolen from the Matrix.

The Valeyard admits his identity as a distillation of the dark side of the Doctor's nature, somewhere between his twelfth and thirteenth incarnations, out to take control over his remaining lives.

With the help of Mel, who along with Glitz has been brought to the space station by the Master, the Doctor defeats his future self - although, as they leave in the TARDIS with all charges in the trial having been dropped, it appears that the Valeyard has taken over the body of the Keeper of the Matrix and may not have been as completely vanquished as they had thought...

Cast

Crew

References

Individuals

Sabalom Glitz and Melanie Bush are brought to the space station by the Master.
The Master previously entered the Matrix using a duplicate key, and has been watching the whole trial.
The Valeyard and the Master have had contract.
The Valeyard was promised the Doctor's remaining incarnations by the High Council. He is an amalgamation of all the Doctor's evil, and is between the Doctor's twelfth and final incarnation.

Time Lords

The Doctor says, looking around at the Time Lords "In all my travelling throughout the universe I have battled against evil, against power mad conspirators. I should have stayed here. The oldest civilisation: decadent, degenerate, and rotten to the core. Power mad conspirators, Daleks, Sontarans... Cybermen, they're still in the nursery compared to us. Ten million years of absolute power. That's what it takes to be really corrupt."
The Keeper of the Matrix carries the Key of Rassilon.
The High Council have been deposed, and insurrectionists are running amok in the Capitol.
Sensory overload causes Time Lords to fall into a catatonic state

Technology

The Valeyard has (hidden) in the Matrix a Particle Disseminator that disseminates gravitons, quarks and tau mesons (destroys matter, basically). It's a physically real weapon (disguised in apt Victorian style) that will kill all those watching the Matrix in the court room.
Glitz wears mark seven postidion life preserver.
Some of the space station furniture is made of machonite.
The Master has his TARDIS inside the Matrix, diguised as a beach house and a statue of Queen Victoria.

Story Notes

This was Colin Baker's last appearance as the Doctor, though he was unaware of it at the time of filming. Baker was fired by the BBC. He was invited to come back for a final four-part story which would have ended in his regeneration, but he declined the offer.
Originally, Robert Holmes was to have written both episodes, but he took ill and died before he could do so. Script editor Eric Saward finished the second episode from Holmes' notes, but the original plan to end the story, and the 23rd season, on a cliffhanger leaving the battle between the Doctor and Valeyard unresolved, was rejected by John Nathan-Turner. As chronicled in the "making of" documentary included with the 2008 DVD release of the story, this led to a falling out between Saward and Nathan-Turner and Saward resigned his position as script editor. Nathan-Turner commissioned Pip and Jane Baker on short notice to compose a concluding episode.
This story was also known as Time Inc.
Part Fourteen is around half an hour long; when editing of it was completed it was discovered that it had considerably overrun, but John Nathan-Turner was able to gain permission for the series' slot to be extended by five minutes for the week of its transmission so that most of the recorded material could be retained.
A brief clip of Peri is seen at the story's conclusion, when it is revealed that she has not in fact been killed but has escaped to become the consort of King Yrcanos. According to commentary by Colin Baker on the 2008 DVD release, this conceit was the result of him idly asking a production team member if Peri had "really" died in Mindwarp, coupled with negative audience reaction to the character's apparent death. The same commentary also includes Nicola Bryant's generally unfavourable reaction as she watches the scene for the very first time.
At the very end, the Valeyard breaks the fourth wall by looking directly into the camera and laughing.

Ratings

Numbers in refer to the individual parts of this story.

Part Thirteen (1) - million viewers
Part Fourteen (2) - million viewers

Myths

to be added

Filming Locations

Camber Sands, Camber, East Sussex
Gladstone Pottery Museum, Uttoxeter Road, Longton, Stoke-on-Trent
Rye Harbour Nature Reserve, Rye, East Sussex
BBC Television Centre (TC1), Shepherd's Bush, London

Discontinuity, Plot Holes, Errors

Mel leaves with the Doctor at the end of this story, despite being from the Doctor's future. This is extremely odd, since it dramatically increases the probability that this "older" Mel will encounter her younger self at some point, and fall victim to the Blinovitch Limitation Effect. This possibility was neatly sidestepped by the following story, Time and the Rani. Since it immediately depicts the regeneration of the Sixth Doctor, there is presumably a wide gap between it and Foe. The arrival of the Seventh Doctor instantly mooted any televised treatment of the asynchronicity between the Sixth Doctor and Mel. Nevertheless, the issue has been addressed in other media. In the novelisation there is an epilogue in which the Doctor returns Mel to his own future self, who then embarks on the journey that leads to Lakertya. This assumption was followed in the MA: Time of Your Life, where writer Steve Lyons posited that the younger Sixth Doctor immediately took Mel back to his older self. The issue of the Doctor's knowledge of Mel prior to their first meeting is examined in PDA: Business Unusual, while the fact of there being a substantial interval between this story and Time and the Rani has been addressed through the myriad of novels and audio dramas featuring the Sixth Doctor, yet taking place between the trial and his official first meeting with Mel. An alternative assumption is made by The Universal Databank which speculates that the events of the Trial destroyed the future timeline Mel was from.
Given that article 7 cannot be ignored, and the Doctor is definately guilty of it, the inquisitor is remakably quick to let the Doctor off.
Just why does the valeyard dress up as Mr Popplewick?
How does no-one notice the valleyard switching places with the keeper of the matrix?
No-one attempts to stop Mel entering the Matrix the second time.
why does The Doctor take glitz into the Matrix with him?
Why do they land at different times when they went through together?
How do Glitz and The Master manage to escape the Matrix?
Why did the valleyard pick the events on Ravalox as evidence if he knew about the secrets - all it would do would be to get the doctor and the court suspicious about these things
How did Peri manage to escape from the events of Mindwarp?
Although Mel never directly heard the Doctor saying that the he opposed the evidence of the matrix, the parts that she does here would be more than enough to give her that idea - so the doctor's logic doesn't really work.

Continuity

Another account of when Peri encounters the Doctor again is in NA: Bad Therapy.
The Valeyard appears in PDA: Matrix.
An alternate version of the Valeyard features in DWU: He Jests at Scars....

DVD and Video Releases

DVD release

Released as part of The Trial of a Time Lord boxset on the 29th September 2008.

Video Releases

Released as Doctor Who: The Ultimate Foe

Released:

UK October 1993 (Released with the other Trial of the Timelord stories in a Tardis-shaped tin with a random picture of one of the (then) seven Doctors on the base)
US October 1993 (Same as the UK release except packed in a cardboard box in honor of Doctor Who's 30th anniversary)
Australia October 1993

DVD release