More actions
The Star Trek universe has made several references to the Doctor Who universe, and the two also share many similarities.
- For a discussion of the Star Trek franchise from an in-universe perspective, see Star Trek.
Overview
References to Doctor Who in Star Trek media
Television
- A computer console seen in the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode "The Neutral Zone" shows the names of the first six actors to play the Doctor. Despite this being an obvious reference, a basic mistake was made where Peter Davison's name was misspelled as "Peter Davidson".
- The Argolis Cluster, first mentioned in the Next Generation episode "I Borg", was named after the planet Argolis (DW: The Leisure Hive).
- "Future Tense", an episode of Star Trek: Enterprise, features a TARDIS-like spacecraft that can travel through time, is bigger on the inside than on the outside, and has an interior design featuring TARDIS-like roundels. The show's production team has acknowledged this as an homage.
- San Francisco has appeared in both Doctor Who and Star Trek. The TARDIS materializes in San Francisco on the 30th December 1999 (DW: Doctor Who). In Star Trek, Starfleet Headquarters is located in the city.
Other media
- The Star Trek novel "Ishmael" makes an indirect reference to the Time Lords, a direct reference to Metebelis crystals, and features cameos by the Second Doctor and the Fourth Doctor. (Per a directive from Trek creator Gene Roddenberry and the franchise owners, Paramount Pictures, novels are not considered part of Trek canon.)
- Several Star Trek stories have made mention of the use of "sonic screwdrivers" as Starfleet engineering tools.
- A direct reference to the Doctor Who franchise is made in the novel My Enemy, My Ally which describes USS Enterprise crewmembers watching a Fourth Doctor episode.
- The novel A Singular Destiny features an alien race called the Thals, although they have no connection to those seen in Doctor Who.
- Greater Than The Sum features the names Lyton and Telos.
Watching the Clock
- As a story focusing on the consequences of time travel, author Christopher L. Bennett has included many allusions to the the Doctor Who franchise in his Star Trek novel Department of Temporal Investigations: Watching the Clock. [1]
- The book features an epigram of the Tenth Doctor's line from "Blink" (credited to Stephen Moffat) describing time as "a big ball of wibbly-wobbly... timey-wimey... stuff."
- The character of Rani Mohindra is named after Rani Chandra from The Sarah Jane Adventures and her actor, Anjli Mohindra.
- A ship named the Verity is named after producer Verity Lambert.
- The character of Ian Purvis is named after actors Ian Marter and Peter Purves.
- Canary Wharf is also mentioned. While the novel makes no specific links to its status in Doctor Who, the author specifically mentions it, and its importance, in his online annotations.[2] Likewise with Ealing. [3]
- The Tigellian chronic hysteresis is a reference to Tigella.
- The unit of measurement known as a "Maloc" is based on the "Malcolm", coined by Dr. Malcolm Taylor.
- The Shirna, archenemies of the already established Vogon were named after Shirna, partner of Vorg.
- A "large, blue, boxlike artefact" is seen in a Federation storehouse of alien time-travel devices.
- The character of Adrienne Markham is named after Adrienne Hill.
- A planet is also described as having silver trees and an orange sky, and its inhabitants as a society who have been monitoring history for thousands of years.
- A character Professor Vard, has a physical description reminiscent of the Second Doctor and displays the hubris and techno-babble associated with the Doctor in many incarnations.
Cast connections
To date, the only major Doctor Who star, to have appeared in the Star Trek franchise is Daphne Ashbrook. Prior to playing the Eighth Doctor's companion, Grace Holloway, she played the character of Melora Pazlar on the Star Trek: Deep Space Nine episode, Melora.
In contrast to this however, there have been several major Star Trek stars who have appeared in the Doctor Who franchise. As regular cast members throughout the entire run of Deep Space Nine, Alexander Siddig and Nana Visitor are the most experienced Star Trek actors to appear in any Doctor Who franchise productions. Siddig portrayed Rosto in the Eighth Doctor audio dramas, Sisters of the Flame and The Vengeance of Morbius, whereas Visitor portrayed Olivia Colasanto in Torchwood: Miracle Day. Added to this, John de Lancie, who appeared as Q in twelve episodes across three Star Trek series', also has a recurring role in Miracle Day, Allen Shapiro.
Simon Pegg is so far the only actor to have a lead role in a Star Trek feature film, Montgomery Scott in Star Trek, and have significant involvement in Doctor Who. Not only did he play The Editor in The Long Game, but also narrated a series of Doctor Who Confidential, and performed vocal work for Big Finish in Invaders from Mars. Although David Warner appeared in the Star Trek films The Final Frontier, The Undiscovered Country and a two part TV story, he did so only in supporting roles. Also, his contributions to Doctor Who have only been audio work, including an alternative Doctor, and Isaac Newton among others for Big Finish, as well as Lord Azlok in the animated adventure, Dreamland.
Others who have appeared in both Star Trek and Doctor Who productions include Ed Bishop, John Franklyn-Robbins, Barrie Ingham, Christopher Neame, Gregg Palmer, Olaf Pooley, Maurice Roëves, Deep Roy, Mark Sheppard, William Morgan Sheppard, and Guy Siner. Amy Benedict, Alan Dale, Van Epperson and Robin Sachs have also all appeared in Torchwood.
Star Trek stars who were considered for the 1996 Doctor Who TV movie include Patrick Stewart who was considered for the role of the Eighth Doctor and The Master. Stewart has stated in a recent interview that he might have been considered for the roles but he was never formally approached. Kate Mulgrew was considered for the role of Grace Holloway (though her involvement in Star Trek: Voyager for rival network UPN would likely have precluded her involvement), while legendary voice actor Frank Welker was considered to voice several aliens had the TV movie pilot been extended into a series.
Anthony Head also narrated a Star Trek audiobook, volume 1 of "The Rise and Fall of Khan Noonien Singh".
Crew connections
According to The Nth Doctor, in 1994 Leonard Nimoy, the actor who played the original Mr. Spock and who also directed two Star Trek feature films, was reportedly under consideration to direct one of the many aborted Doctor Who feature film projects under consideration during the 1989-96 interregnum.
TV movie composer John Debney also composed scores for the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode "The Pegasus" and the Star Trek:Deep Space Nine episodes "The Nagus" and "Progress". Tony Dow, who worked as visual effects producer for the TV movie, later directed the Deep Space Nine episode "Field of Fire".
Writer connections
Numerous writers who have contributed to the Trek franchise have also contributed to Doctor Who. To date two writers of televised Star Trek stories have crossed over to Doctor Who. One is David Wise, who won an Emmy for co-writing the Star Trek: The Animated Series episode "How Sharper Than a Serpent's Tooth" in 1974; in 2011 his script for BFG: Gallifrey: Forever was produced by Big Finish Productions. Diane Duane, co-writer of the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode "Where No One Has Gone Before", as well as numerous novels and novelisations, contributed Doctor Who short fiction to the Big Finish Short Trips series of books, as well as for unofficial charity publications. Other Trek novelists with ties to Doctor Who include Peter David, Keith R.A. DeCandido, Diane Duane, Una McCormack David A. McIntee, and John Peel.
There are only two who have written televised episodes for both franchises however. Torchwood Series 4 writers Jane Espenson and John Shiban have also written episodes for Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and Star Trek: Enterprise respectively.
Potential official crossover
In April, 2009, Russell T Davies revealed in an interview that he had considered writing a Doctor Who episode that crossed over with Star Trek Enterprise.
- "I would have loved to have done a Star Trek crossover," said Davies. "The very first year, we talked about it. Then Star Trek finally went off air. Landing the Tardis on board the Enterprise would have been magnificent. Can you imagine what their script department would have wanted, and what I would have wanted? It would have been the biggest battle."
Given the vast settings of both franchises and the number of companies involved in the international rights, it is highly unlikely such an episode would have been made. In addition, there have been several references made to Star Trek as an entertainment franchise in Doctor Who — most notably when Rose Tyler dubs the Doctor "Mr. Spock" in DW: The Empty Child — which could have presented a continuity challenge. Star Trek, for its part, has never made a direct reference to Doctor Who in any TV episode or film, beyond a few visual references and in-jokes not intended to link to the canon; the direct reference to the series that occurs in the novel My Enemy, My Ally has no bearing on canon as in the 1990s Paramount Pictures took the (for some) controversial step of announcing what aspects of the Trek franchise would be considered canon; the novels, Paramount decreed, are not.
Other information
- The fan novella The Doctor and the Enterprise by Jean Airey, initially was published privately as a stand-alone fanzine and then in a professional edition in 1989 by Pioneer Books. Many other amateur fan fiction crossovers between the two universes have been written over the years, though Airey's book remains (as of 2009) the only one to be published professionally, if unofficially.
- There have only been two periods in which the rights to publish comic books based upon Star Trek have been held by the same company holding the rights to publish same based upon Doctor Who. The first was in the 1979-81 period when Marvel Comics published a monthly Star Trek comic at the same time it published (with comic strips) Doctor Who Weekly in the UK (although Marvel's licence on Trek had ended by the time it began republishing the DWM strips in America). More recently, IDW Publishing began a line of Doctor Who originals and reprints in 2007, concurrent with its own ongoing line of Trek-based comic books. In 2010-11 IDW published a story arc that connected the Trek, Transformers, Ghostbusters, and GI Joe franchises (also published by IDW), but not Doctor Who, leading industry publication Wizard Magazine to suggest a crossover in its January 2011 issue.
- In October 2008, Trek actor Zachary Quinto, who also appears in the latest "Trek" film as Mr. Spock, announced David Tennant as the winner of that year's National Television Awards; it was during Tennant's acceptance speech broadcast live via remote that Tennant announced his departure from Doctor Who. Like Tennant, and most other actors who have portrayed the Doctor, Quinto, Pegg and several others of the Star Trek cast are having to take over iconic roles from popular actors.
- David Tennant has been cast in the remake of cult film Fright Night opposite Anton Yelchin who played Chekov in the latest Star Trek film
- In 2008 David Tennant appeared in both a stage and BBC television production of Hamlet opposite Patrick Stewart, with Tennant playing the title character and Stewart as Claudius. In 1980, Stewart played Claudius in another BBC TV production of Hamlet, in which Lalla Ward played Ophelia.
External links
- Memory Alpha, a Star Trek wiki focusing on the television and films
- Memory Alpha's page on Doctor Who
- Memory Beta, a Star Trek wiki focusing on the expanded media, such as books and comics.
- Memory Beta's page on Doctor Who
