85
edits
Howling:Hmm: Difference between revisions
From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
no edit summary
Magic Afro (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
Phil Stone (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
| Line 38: | Line 38: | ||
Trenzalore is not a planet of truth. Dorium was describing conditions when he wouldn't have a choice due to his personality, and, surprisingly, he chose not to. River saved them. [[User:Magic Afro|<font size="3" color="DarkRed" face="Comic Sans MS">Afro</font> <font size="3" color="OrangeRed" face="Comic Sans MS">Circus</font> <font size="3" color="DarkOrange" face="Comic Sans MS">Afro</font>]] [[Message Wall:Magic Afro|<font size="3" color="Orange" face="Comic Sans MS">Circus</font> <font size="3" color="Gold" face="Comic Sans MS">Afro</font> <font size="3" color="YellowGreen" face="Comic Sans MS">Polka</font>]] [[User blog:Magic Afro|<font size="3" color="Green" face="Comic Sans MS">Dot</font> <font size="3" color="Blue" face="Comic Sans MS">Polka</font> <font size="3" color="MidnightBlue" face="Comic Sans MS">Dot</font>]] [[Special:Contributions/Magic Afro|<font size="3" color="Indigo" face="Comic Sans MS">Polka</font> <font size="3" color="DarkMagenta" face="Comic Sans MS">Dot</font> <font size="3" color="DarkViolet" face="Comic Sans MS">Afro!</font>]] 22:33, December 14, 2013 (UTC) | Trenzalore is not a planet of truth. Dorium was describing conditions when he wouldn't have a choice due to his personality, and, surprisingly, he chose not to. River saved them. [[User:Magic Afro|<font size="3" color="DarkRed" face="Comic Sans MS">Afro</font> <font size="3" color="OrangeRed" face="Comic Sans MS">Circus</font> <font size="3" color="DarkOrange" face="Comic Sans MS">Afro</font>]] [[Message Wall:Magic Afro|<font size="3" color="Orange" face="Comic Sans MS">Circus</font> <font size="3" color="Gold" face="Comic Sans MS">Afro</font> <font size="3" color="YellowGreen" face="Comic Sans MS">Polka</font>]] [[User blog:Magic Afro|<font size="3" color="Green" face="Comic Sans MS">Dot</font> <font size="3" color="Blue" face="Comic Sans MS">Polka</font> <font size="3" color="MidnightBlue" face="Comic Sans MS">Dot</font>]] [[Special:Contributions/Magic Afro|<font size="3" color="Indigo" face="Comic Sans MS">Polka</font> <font size="3" color="DarkMagenta" face="Comic Sans MS">Dot</font> <font size="3" color="DarkViolet" face="Comic Sans MS">Afro!</font>]] 22:33, December 14, 2013 (UTC) | ||
Dorium was explaining the Prophecy, as well as he understood it. He offered no explanation of why no living being (not specifically the Doctor, but anyone) would be unable to lie, and be forced to answer. And that is not what happened. But you are assuming that because what did happen can be stretched to appear to fit the Prophecy, that this is what the prophecy meant all along, that The Doctor could not help but answer just because he is The Doctor. Even though in fact the Doctor could not answer. If the Doctor understood what damage could be wrought through access to his tomb, and there is every reason to believe he did, then it isn't at all surprising that he could withhold an answer. So the Prophecy was just wrong. If your interpretation is correct. | |||
When River was linked with Vastra, Jenny and Clara for the meeting, why does the connection only survive to Clara? Why cannot Vastra & Jenny & Strax see her? I think the connection is more important than just a way for the Doctor to cheat the Prophecy.[[User:Phil Stone|Phil Stone]] [[User talk:Phil Stone|<span title="Talk to me">☎</span>]] 05:37, December 16, 2013 (UTC) | |||
