User:SOTO/Forum Archive/The Panopticon/@comment-43908-20150311013943/@comment-28349479-20190206004950

Scrooge MacDuck wrote: So, we know for sure that the two Romana IIIs were intended to be different, even if they end up describing "the same thing" within wider Doctor Who continuity. Not only do I think this means they ought to get two separate pages, but this is the precedented procedure. Any arguments?

Here's one: What exact precedent do you think was established in Thread:231584? Czech and I had some back-and-forth, but that never came to a resolution; the final decision was the result of a completely independent conversation between Revantrelundar and me, which fixated on the details of the specific scenario at hand. I'm really not sure what you're trying to generalize out of that discussion.

All that said, a few months have passed, and I think I'm in favor of splitting up the pages: or, more accurately, moving all info about the Juliet Landau incarnation to a separate page, dab termed per T:DAB OTHER to indicate that she comes from another reality (specifically, the aborted timeline where Intervention Earth happened and Braxiatel didn't stop Romana II from regenerating: the name for this timeline would need to be determined by further discussion). All information about Trey would go on this page as well, now that we can acknowledge that the incarnation who regenerates in The Tomb of Valdemaar is different from the one in Incarnation Earth. Information about the Shadows of Avalon incarnation (and her regeneration into Romana IV) would remain on regular old undabbed Romana III.

I believe this is the best path to resolving the discrepancies in this thread. Thoughts?