The Highlanders (TV story): Difference between revisions

The Highlanders was the fourth story of Season 4 of Doctor Who. It was the last of the "pure historical" genre of Doctor Who television stories until Black Orchid in 1982. These had been a regular feature of the show since its inception. It was also the first appearance of Frazer Hines as companion Jamie McCrimmon, the longest serving male companion in the series' history.

Synopsis

The time travellers arrive in Scotland just after the Battle of Culloden. The Second Doctor gains the trust of a small band of fleeing Jacobites by offering to tend their wounded Laird, Colin McLaren. While Polly and the Laird's daughter, Kirsty, are away fetching water, he and the others are all captured by Redcoat troops commanded by Lieutenant Algernon Ffinch.

Grey, a crooked solicitor who sells prisoners to slavery for transportation in the West Indies, secures the group into his custody. Polly and Kirsty blackmail Ffinch into helping and the Doctor wins the day by smuggling arms to the Highlanders who are being held on board a stolen ship, the Annabelle.

Grey and the ship's unscrupulous captain, Trask, are overpowered and the vessel is returned to its rightful owner, Willie Mackay, who agrees to take the rebels to safety in France.

The Doctor, Polly and Ben return to the Doctor's TARDIS, where they are joined on their travels by the young piper Jamie McCrimmon.

Plot

Episode 1

Members of the clan McLaren, including piper Jamie McCrimmon, flee the battlefield at Culloden Moor in 1746. The Laird, Colin McLaren, is wounded, and son Alexander and daughter Kirsty McLaren help him.

The TARDIS arrives nearby. Ben, Polly and the Doctor emerge. Ben is pleased as he sees that it is Earth and suspects it may be home until he dodges an incoming cannonball. The Doctor wants to leave, but Ben has gone to look around and Polly insists they follow him.

Meanwhile, the party of Scots have taken refuge in a ruined cottage. They lament the failure of the battle. Jamie curses the Prince who fled the battle and is berated by his brother. They hear something outside and prepare to strike.

The Doctor, Ben and Polly are examining a "spiked" cannon. The Doctor sees a Highland bonnet on the ground, tries it on and casts it to the ground. The Scots surround them. Alexander forces the Doctor to pick up the hat. They force the Doctor and his friends inside the cottage.

The Doctor realises the hat belongs to Prince Charles Edward, "Bonnie Prince Charlie." The Jacobites intend to show no more mercy than the Redcoats as they suspect that they are Englishmen come to steal from the dead. However, when Kirsty hears Polly refer to the Doctor, she begs for them to live long enough to treat her father. With this distraction, Ben steals a gun and points it at the Laird whilst the Doctor disarms them. The Doctor tends to the Laird, sends Kirsty and Polly to fetch water and tells Ben to put down the gun when the Highlanders give their word not to harm them. Ben throws the gun on the table, but it discharges. This draws the attention of a half dozen nearby Redcoats.

Algernon Ffinch and his men surround the cottage, but when Alexander emerges, attempting to draw them off, he is shot and killed. The Redcoats enter the hut. They take Ben to be a Highlander, and when he reveals his accent they suspect him to be a deserter and intend to kill him. The Doctor undertakes the guise of a German, "Doktor von Wer," and speaks with a heavy accent. He says he is waiting for an escort to return him to England. Ffinch is unmoved at Ben's insistence that they are prisoners of war. He says rebels are not treated as such and orders them to be hanged.

Solicitor Grey and his clerk, Perkins, watch the battle and lament the needless killing of the rebel troops as a "waste of manpower". In his role as his Majesty's Commissioner of Prisons, Grey intends to profit from this rebellion by selling prisoners as slaves in the West Indies. After remonstrating Perkins for serving him corked wine, the two move off to try to "save" some of the Scots.

Polly and Kirsty return. They try to cause a diversion by throwing stones at the soldiers. Ffinch follows Kirsty and Polly after recollecting that the Prince may be trying to escape disguised as a woman. Kristy and Polly quickly run away from the soldiers. Polly's shoes make it hard to keep up with Kristy's pace. She discards them and continues on barefoot.

The sergeant tries to hang the prisoners with the officer away. They are on the verge of having the stools kicked away from them but are stopped by Grey and Perkins. Grey bribes the sergeant. The men are released into his charge to be sent to Inverness. Grey rejects the Doctor and the Laird and orders them hanged, but "von Wer" quotes a point of law that convinces Grey to take him, with the Laird under the Doctor's care.

Kirsty hides Polly and herself in a cave known to her family. Polly searches for valuables they can sell to bribe guards. She realises their friends will be put in gaol. She spots Kirsty's gold ring, but Kirsty won't allow it to be sold. It belongs to her father, who entrusted it to her. As Polly argues that they would need the money to get to Inverness, Kirsty pulls a knife on her. Polly, frustrated, goes off on her own. Kristy warns her she's liable to get lost in the dark. With light fading, Polly walks down a path until she falls into an animal pit. As she struggles to get out of the trap, she's confronted by someone above, holding a dagger.

Episode 2

Polly is relieved to find that it is Kirsty. She tries to help Polly out but falls in. Polly climbs on top of Kirsty and tries to get out, but spots Ffinch and his men searching, forcing them to duck back in. Ffinch decides to stay and berates his men for losing the girls before sending them back for his horse. Polly and Kirsty draw him towards the trap until he falls in, and the women take him prisoner. Kirsty disarms him and threatens to shoot him.

At Inverness, the men are thrown into a dank, waterlogged cell. The Doctor tends to the Laird, feeling he will recover, but must use a bit of trickery to convince his 18th century friends that he knows what he's doing as they insist on blood-letting. The Doctor discovers that the Laird is wearing (and protecting) the Prince's standard. The Doctor takes charge of it, saying both that he won't escape the gallows with that found on him and that it's very nice and warm. He incites the prisoners to sing a rebel dirge, then uses his German persona to convince the guard to let him out, claiming they sung the song to incite him and saying he has news of a plot to kill the Duke of Cumberland. The prisoners turn on him but Ben sticks up for him; however, he worries about how high the water level will rise in their cell, pointing to a watermark near the ceiling.

Kirsty and Polly have taken twenty guineas from Ffinch. Finding his credentials, they threaten to discredit him with his identity disc in case they need an ally in the colonel of the Redcoats. They take a lock of his hair and leave him.

At the Sea Eagle inn, Grey orders Captain Trask and his men to load their cargo and the prisoners aboard Trask's ship, the Annabelle. The Doctor is brought before Grey who pulls a gun to protect himself before dismissing Trask and Perkins. The Doctor admits the reason he wanted to see Grey was to show him the Prince's standard so as to split the reward for the Prince's capture. Suddenly, the Doctor throws the flag over Grey, disarms him and locks him, bound and gagged, in a closet. When Perkins arrives, the Doctor convinces him he's ill and prescribes rest at the solicitor's desk for at least an hour; he blindfolds him and insists that the knocking and moaning noises he hears are only in his mind.

Ffinch is delighted when the sergeant finally arrives, but enraged when the sergeant exploits the situation by refusing to help Ffinch escape the pit unless paid. Ffinch offers money — then realises the women took it all. He promises payment when they return to Inverness.

Trask returns to find Perkins and release Grey. They go to seek out the Doctor.

The Doctor, meanwhile, has hidden himself in the Sea Eagle's scullery. He disguises himself as an old crone.

Trask takes his next lot of prisoners and selects Jamie, Ben and the Laird on a rowboat to be taken to the Annabelle. They are led past the Doctor, who sees where they are being taken. They are led to an underground canal where they are boarded onto a rowboat.

The Doctor distracts a guard with food to get to the trap door through which the prisoners were herded.

As the prisoners approach the Annabelle, Trask orders a bound man to be thrown over the side and allowed to drown. That's the only way they'll ever get off the Annabelle, warns Trask.

Episode 3

Ben, Jamie and the Laird are shoved into the Annabelle's hold. A rebel prisoner threatens Ben suspecting him to be an English spy but the Laird vouches for him. The man, Willie Mackay, recognises the Laird and says any friend of the Laird is a friend of his. Mackay says he is the true captain of the Annabelle, having been betrayed by Trask. Ben works out that they are to become slave labourers.

Polly and Kirsty hide in a barn near Inverness. Kirsty has gone out to collect items of use whilst Polly watches the place at gun point. When Kirsty returns she comes with dresses and oranges as Polly's plan is to pass as orange sellers to get themselves nearer to the soldiers.

Ffinch arrives at the Sea Eagle's dining room, exhausted and humiliated. The Doctor is there, still disguised. Polly and Kirsty are brought to see the lieutenant, wading through the soldiers' roving hands. The sergeant suspects these are the women they were chasing, but Ffinch is forced to confirm they are simply "old friends" as they surreptitiously threaten him. The sergeant dismisses his soldiers and the three speak freely. Ffinch reluctantly tells the women about Grey. When Perkins enters, Ffinch directs him to them. The Doctor is unable to alert his friends to his presence.

Solicitor Grey addresses the prisoners. They have three choices: one, become witnesses — or traitors; two, be hanged if they don't wish to turn King's evidence; three, sign seven-year contracts as plantation workers in the West Indies. Mackay warns the others against signing, saying they will not survive seven years. The others eventually come forward to sign, while Ben, Jamie, McLaren and Mackay hold back. Ben seemingly changes his mind and asks to sign. Under the guise of "reading it first," he tears up the contracts. Trask breaks out his whip, knocking Ben unconscious. Grey orders Ben clapped in irons. Grey goes off to have new contracts drawn up.

Polly and Kirsty are "entertained" by Perkins while waiting for Grey. They grow uneasy and try to leave, but Perkins threatens them and they stay as Perkins offers a game of whist. An old woman offers herself as their fourth. It is the Doctor with Grey's pistol in his hand. The Doctor threatens Perkins and explains he is not to love. As the game starts, Grey arrives to witness this strange scene. He impatiently calls Perkins away and leaves. The Doctor insists that "we girls" leave first, ordering Perkins to wait for ten minutes or experience more symptoms of his "illness." Perkins, fearful of being shot, complies. Polly and Kirsty take the Doctor back to the barn. He reveals that the gun is not loaded, citing his dislike of weapons. The Doctor explains that Ben is on a ship. Polly wants to make a plan, but the Doctor wants to sleep. Polly drags an idea out of him: use the money they've stolen to buy weapons from the British soldiers and smuggle them aboard the Annabelle.

Meanwhile, Grey and Perkins return to the Annabelle with three fresh sets of contracts. Grey orders Trask to ensure that all prisoners sign the contracts. When Trask says he'll use the whip, Grey orders that he is to treat them mercifully until they arrive safely in Barbados. Regarding Ben, he orders a ducking and for him to be brought on deck.

The women return to the barn. They have had little luck getting weapons; their haul consisting of a broken sword, a pitchfork and a couple of knives. The Doctor returns with a wheelbarrow full of swords, muskets and pistols. He spots the ring on Kirsty's hand and recognises it as the Prince's. Kirsty confirms that her father saved the Prince's life. She is finally willing to part with it, and the Doctor intends to use it to save her father's life as "bait for a very greedy man".

That night, Ben, completely bound, is tossed overboard the Annabelle.

Episode 4

Trask pulls up the rope. Ben is no longer attached to it. He emerges from the water on the other side of the ship and swims through the freezing water. Exhausted, he makes it to shore, only to find a musket pointed at him. Fortunately for him, the Redcoat at the other end of it is the Doctor. He takes Ben to safety but not before alerting him to the rowboat full of weapons.

Grey tells Trask to set sail tomorrow with his cargo. Trask questions Grey's authority but is soon over ruled.

Ben tells his friends about his escape, and they put their plan into action. The Doctor will return to the ship, rowed by Ben. While the Doctor distracts Grey and the crew, Ben will deliver the weapons to the prisoners in the hold. Polly and Kirsty insist on going along, so the Doctor gives Ben a different job.

Meanwhile, Mackay laments their brothers' playing into Grey's hands and the Laird, seemingly resigned to death, and longs to see his daughter Kirsty one more time.

Preparing to go ashore, Grey is surprised when Trask enters with the Doctor in his grasp. The Doctor presents the Prince's ring and claims he got it from the Prince himself, who is, at this moment, in prison. The Doctor tries to strike a deal for his whereabouts asking for 10,000 guineas.

Meanwhile Polly and Kirsty row out and find access to the hold. Kirsty whispers to her father and delivers the arms to him.

Grey agrees to the Doctor's demands, and the Doctor claims the Prince is in the hold of the ship. He claims the piper, Jamie, is the Prince. They all go to the hold to see for themselves. They make their way quietly, and the Doctor points out Jamie at the far end. As they make their way over to the figure, the Laird lets out a battle cry. All the prisoners are up, and the fight begins. The captors storm the deck. Most sailors are quickly taken, but Mackay and Trask fight. Both men are wounded, but Trask escapes from Mackay out of the hold. Up top, the fight continues: Ben, who was prepared for such an attack, confronts Trask and is almost killed, but Jamie saves him by cutting a rope and swinging it into Trask, knocking him to the groumd. Jamie fights Trask until Trask is forced over the side. Mackay takes command of the ship and bids his newly established crewmen to make ready to leave for France.

The Doctor, his friends and Grey pile onto the rowboat where Kirsty is reunited with her father, and the Doctor and Ben are reunited with Polly. Perkins begs to be allowed to accompany the Scots to France, which Mackay agrees to.

Back on the dock, Ben and Polly watch the ship disappear. The travellers and Jamie intend to use Grey as a way of evading the Redcoats whilst returning to the TARDIS. Redcoats come snooping along the quayside, and they duck into a boathouse. Grey cries out, and the Doctor, Ben and Jamie must fight the Redcoats. They win, but Grey escapes. They realise they'll have to find another "ally" to help them.

They head to the Sea Eagle where they find Lieutenant Ffinch. The Doctor uses the ruse of the Prince's ring to extract Ffinch from a colonel, with whom Ffinch has been drafted to play whist. Polly produces Ffinch's identity disc to ensure his cooperation.

The next morning, they are back at the cottage where they were captured. Ffinch is now on their side, having heard the tale of Solicitor Grey. Suddenly, they are surrounded by Redcoats led by Grey, who congratulates Ffinch on capturing the rebels. As Grey threatens them, Ffinch silences him, claiming he is a villain. Grey argues that he has done nothing wrong: the prisoners signed contracts and it is thus perfectly legal. He reaches for the contracts in his coat pocket, but they are gone! The Doctor, Jamie and Ben deny their existence. Ffinch has Grey arrested, gagged and marched to Inverness prison. Once Ffinch has gone, with a kiss from Polly, the Doctor produces the contracts from his pocket. Encouraged by Polly, the Doctor asks Jamie to join them on the TARDIS. He agrees as long as Jamie teaches him the bagpipes. They all leave in the TARDIS.

Cast

Dr. Who - Patrick Troughton
Ben Jackson - Michael Craze
Polly - Anneke Wills
Jamie McCrimmon - Frazer Hines
Alexander McLaren - William Dysart
The Laird - Donald Bisset
Kirsty McLaren - Hannah Gordon
Lieutenant Algernon Ffinch - Michael Elwyn
Sergeant - Peter Welch
Grey - David Garth
Perkins - Sydney Arnold
Sentry - Tom Bowman
Trask - Dallas Cavell
Mollie - Barbara Bruce
Willie Mackay - Andrew Downie
Sailor - Peter Diamond
Colonel Attwood - Guy Middleton

Crew

Assistant Floor Manager - Nicholas John
Costumes - Sandra Reid
Designer - Geoffrey Kirkland
Fight Arranger - Peter Diamond
Make-Up - Gillian James
Producer - Innes Lloyd
Production Assistant - Fiona Cumming
Script Editor - Gerry Davis
Special Sounds - Brian Hodgson
Studio Lighting - George Summers, Ken MacGregor
Studio Sound - Larry Goodson
Theme Arrangement - Delia Derbyshire
Title Music - Ron Grainer

References

Food, beverages and substances

Perkins and Gray drink corked wine.
Kirsty offers a wheat biscuit to Polly. Polly mistakes it for a dog biscuit.
Ffinch smokes tobacco with a pipe.
Polly and Kirsty steal chicken and bread from Ffinch.

Individuals

The Highlanders are fighting for Prince Charles Edward Stuart a.k.a. "Bonnie Prince Charlie", while the Redcoats fight for King George II. His father, King George I, was from Hanover, Germany, which is why the Second Doctor takes up his German guise and makes a remark about speaking better English than the King. The King's son, the Duke of Cumberland a.k.a. "the Butcher", is also mentioned.
Polly brings up Nell Gwyn in reference to her and Kirsty's posing as orange-sellers.
Ben credits Houdini with his successful escape.
Jamie is a piper like his father and his grandfather.

Historical accounts

The Doctor blurts out with Kirsty that seven years later Scottish people would have been safe in the British isles (implicitly, because of the end of the war with England).
Kirsty is amazed that Polly is wearing a short skirt, even if she is "a grown woman".
The currency used is guineas, specified as being taken by Polly and Kirsty from Ffinch.

Items

Kirsty is given a spyglass when she goes and searches for clean water.
The Doctor uses a magnifying glass while pretending to be a medical doctor.
Polly longs for matches while in the cave with Kirsty.

Music

The Doctor plays traditional Scottish music with his recorder.

Places and peoples

Plantation workers are required in the colonies in the West Indies. Grey wonders what price his slaves will fetch in Jamaica or Barbados.
The prison is at Inverness.
Eventually, many rebels are going to emigrate to France.
According to the Doctor, English soldiers would sell their own grandmother for half penny.

Popular beliefs

Bloodletting is proposed by the Highlanders to save the Laird's life and questioned by Ben.
The Doctor pretends to invoke Isis and Osiris and to use astrological criteria in his medical practice.

Sports

Ben compares the noise of the cannonballs to the ones of a cup final, likely football.

The Doctor

The Doctor pretends to be a German physician, named Doktor Von Wer, which, roughly translated from German, means "Doctor (of) Who".
The Doctor can speak common words in German.
The Doctor again expresses a fondness for various hats.
The Doctor disguises himself as an old woman and a soldier wounded in battle.
The Doctor would like to learn to play bagpipes from Jamie.

Vehicles

McKay's cargo ship is called Annabelle.

Weapons

In the first battle, ten-pounder cannonballs are used, according to the Doctor.

Story notes

This story had the working title of Culloden. (REF: The Second Doctor Handbook)
The next "pure historical" serial, Black Orchid, would not be broadcast until 1982. However, Highlanders is the last historical to use events from real history, as Orchid is entirely fictional.
Although commissioned to write the story, Elwyn Jones in fact carried out no work on it. The scripts were written by story editor, Gerry Davis. Unlike other cases in which the story/script editor substantively wrote (or rewrote) scripts, however, Davis actually did get on-screen credit for it. As evidenced by contemporaneous documents available on the BBC's official website, Jones and Davis were in fact jointly credited.
While still an actor in the early 1960s, this serial's director, Hugh David, had been considered for the role of the First Doctor but, being only thirty-eight years old at the time, was deemed to be too young by the series' original producer, Verity Lambert.^[1]
Solicitor Grey is the only real-world historical person to appear in the story.

Ratings

Episode 1 - 6.7 million viewers
Episode 2 - 6.8 million viewers
Episode 3 - 7.4 million viewers
Episode 4 - 7.3 million viewers

Myths

It was decided to keep Jamie on as companion due to a positive audience reaction. (The decision was made well before the transmission of the story.)

Filming locations

Production errors

If you'd like to talk about narrative problems with this story — like plot holes and things that seem to contradict other stories — please go to this episode's discontinuity discussion.

In episode 2, Polly reads Ffinch's name as Algernon Thomas Alfred Ffinch; but in Episode 3 she taunts him as "Alfred Algernon Thomas..."

Continuity

Polly is pleased that she does not have to dress up in boys' clothes, as she had to in her last adventure in the past. (TV: The Smugglers)
The Doctor, Jamie and their companion Zoe Heriot would later meet Bonnie Prince Charlie's paternal grandparents, King James II and Queen Mary of Modena, during the Glorious Revolution in November 1688. When they met the latter, she had the infant James Stuart, Prince of Wales (the Old Pretender), the future father of Bonnie Prince Charlie, in her arms. (AUDIO: The Glorious Revolution)
Jamie was 22 years old when he first met the Doctor. (AUDIO: Shadow of Death)
The Second Doctor once again plays his recorder. (TV: The Power of the Daleks)
After Jamie was returned to his native time by the Time Lords with his memories of travelling with the Doctor suppressed, he and Kirsty married and had at least eight children. By 1788, they had numerous grandchildren. (AUDIO: The Glorious Revolution) One of their distant descendants was a 21st century history student at the University of Edinburgh named Heather McCrimmon, who became a companion of the Tenth Doctor. (COMIC: The Chromosome Connection)
The Glaswegians fought on the side of King George II during the Jacobite Rising. (PROSE: The Wheel of Ice)
Quaddriger Stoyn tracked the TARDIS to Scotland in 1746. (AUDIO: The Dying Light)

Home video and audio releases

DVD release

No complete episodes from this story survive. Existing "censor" clips from Episode 1 were released on the Lost in Time boxset.

Audio release

It was released by the BBC Radio Collection on 7 August 2000, narrated by Frazer Hines.
It was re-released as part of the Adventures in History box set released on 4 August 2003 (with the same content).
It was re-released again on 4 August 2011 as part of the box set Doctor Who: The Lost TV Episodes - Collection Three.

CD Release
Adventures in History
The Lost TV Episodes - Collection Three

Footnotes

↑ DWM 391 - Verity Lambert obituary.

External links

[autogenerated2-1] DWM 391 - Verity Lambert obituary.

[1]

@@ Line 271: / Line 271: @@
 {{TitleSort}}
 {{ImageLinkTV}}
+[[de:{{StoryTitle}}]]
+[[Category:Doctor Who (1963) television stories]]
+[[Category:Second Doctor television stories]]
+[[Category:Stories set in Scotland]]
+[[Category:Historical stories]]
+[[Category:Stories set in 1746]]
+[[Category:1966 television stories]]
+[[Category:1967 television stories]]
+[[Category:Stories with missing episodes]]
+[[Category:Season 4 stories]]
+[[Category:Four part serials]]

Anonymous

Search