Powell Estate: Difference between revisions
66 Seconds (talk | contribs) |
No edit summary |
||
| (23 intermediate revisions by 8 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
{{Subpage tabs}} | |||
{{Wikipediainfo|Brandon Estate}} | |||
{{ImageLink}} | {{ImageLink}} | ||
{{Infobox Location | {{Infobox Location | ||
|image = Powell Estate | |image = Powell Estate.jpg | ||
|type = [[Council estate]] | |type = [[Council estate]] | ||
|location = [[Kennington]] or [[Peckham]], [[London Borough of Southwark]] | |location = [[Kennington]] or [[Peckham]], [[London Borough of Southwark]] | ||
|first | |first cs = Rose (TV story) | ||
|appearances = {{appears}} | |appearances = {{appears}} | ||
|clip = Doctor Who Series 2 - Christmas Invasion Clip 1 | |clip = Doctor Who Series 2 - Christmas Invasion Clip 1 | ||
| Line 11: | Line 13: | ||
The '''Powell Estate''' was a [[council estate]] in the [[London Borough of Southwark]] where [[Rose Tyler|Rose]] and [[Jackie Tyler]] and [[Mickey Smith]] lived. | The '''Powell Estate''' was a [[council estate]] in the [[London Borough of Southwark]] where [[Rose Tyler|Rose]] and [[Jackie Tyler]] and [[Mickey Smith]] lived. | ||
Both the [[Ninth Doctor|Ninth]] and [[Tenth Doctor]]s visited the estate frequently throughout their time travelling with Rose Tyler, typically materialising [[the Doctor's TARDIS|the TARDIS]] on [[Maddock Way]]. As Rose's entire world was opened up in ways she could never have imagined upon meeting the Doctor, she found domestic life at the estate to be impossible to go back to. The Doctor would go on to form friendships with some of the other residents, in particular Mickey, whom he initially derided and mocked. | |||
The | |||
== Geography == | |||
{{Oou box|For a detailed out-of-universe explanation, please see the [[#In-universe location|behind the scenes]] section.}} | |||
Although the Powell Estate was located in the [[London Borough of Southwark]], ([[TV]]: {{cs|Father's Day (TV story)}}) in [[South East London]], ([[PROSE]]: {{cs|Doctor Who: The Encyclopedia (reference book)}}) its exact location varied between accounts. | |||
=== Kennington === | |||
According to many accounts, the Powell Estate was located in [[Kennington]]. | |||
This was evident from various landmarks being visible from the roof of [[Bucknall House]], from several [[Cotton Gardens|distinctive]] [[Wyndham Estate|council estates]] to the [[London Eye]] and [[the Gherkin]], ([[TV]]: {{cs|Aliens of London (TV story)}}, etc.) as well as its relative proximity to [[the Oval]] and the [[Thames]], ([[TV]]: {{cs|Rose (TV story)}}) with [[UNIT United Kingdom|UNIT]] personnel indeed confirming its Kennington location. ([[PROSE]]: {{cs|Rose Tyler (short story)}}) | |||
=== Peckham === | |||
According to other accounts, the Powell Estate was located in [[Peckham]]. | |||
This was asserted by many accounts, ([[COMIC]]: {{cs|Silver Scream (comic story)}}, [[PROSE]]: {{cs|Downtime: Child of the New World (novel)}}, [[AUDIO]]: {{cs|Ghosts (Redacted audio story)}}) with one account specifying North Peckham. ([[PROSE]]: {{cs|The Time Traveller's Almanac (reference book)|chaptnum=3|chaptname=Everything Changes|page=71}}) Its nearest [[train station|station]] was [[Peckham Rye station|Peckham Rye]]. ([[AUDIO]]: {{cs|Ghosts (Redacted audio story)}}) | |||
=== Layout === | |||
The layout of the Powell Estate was mostly consistent between accounts, although not without its own contradictions. | |||
Generally, the Powell Estate was shown to be accessible from [[Cooks Road|a road]]; turning on to [[Maddock Way]], there was [[Napier House|one block of flats]] to the left before a building filled with shops, which ended before another building containing the [[Powell Estate Library|library]] and [[Powell Youth Centre|youth centre]]. On the right, a longer building, also filled with shops, ran the length of Maddock Way. On the other side laid a [[car park]]. At the end of Maddock Way laid [[Bucknall House]], a squat block of flats which ran parallel to the road Maddock Way was accessible from. Beyond Bucknall House laid six tall towers, arranged approximately in a u-shape. ([[TV]]: {{cs|Rose (TV story)}}, {{cs|Aliens of London (TV story)}}, {{cs|The Christmas Invasion (TV story)}}, {{cs|The End of Time (TV story)|part=Two}}, [[COMIC]]: {{cs|Revolving Doors (comic story)}}, etc.) | |||
The shops on the left included [[Mart Ltd]] and [[Maddock Way Chemist]], ([[TV]]: {{cs|The Christmas Invasion (TV story)}}, {{cs|The End of Time (TV story)|part=Two}}) and the shops on the right included [[Consumers Food + Wine]], ([[TV]]: {{cs|Aliens of London (TV story)}}) [[Maddock Way Surgery]], ([[TV]]: {{cs|The Christmas Invasion (TV story)}}) and [[Maddock Cleaners]]. ([[TV]]: {{cs|World War Three (TV story)}}) Without any indication to its exact location, there was also a [[chinese takeaway, Powell Estate|Chinese takeaway]]. ([[PROSE]]: {{cs|Winner Takes All (novel)|chaptnum=1|page=13}}) | |||
According to one account, however, the Powell Estate had merely two towers of sixteen floors, unofficially called [[Enoch Tower|Enoch]] and [[Powell Tower|Powell]], with six flats per storey. The towers rose above a squat quadrant with shops, such as [[Newsagents, Powell Estate|a newsagents]], [[Dev (Rose)|Dev]] the bookie's and [[Chicken Shack & Rack]]. ([[PROSE]]: {{cs|Rose (novelisation)}}) | |||
Furthermore, where individuals such as [[Mickey Smith]] lived was also subject to contradiction. | |||
==== Mickey Smith's flat ==== | |||
{{Main|Mickey Smith's flat}} | |||
Mickey was shown to live in [[Napier House|the tower]] nearest [[Cooks Road|the road]], in [[Mickey Smith's flat|flat 90]]. ([[TV]]: {{cs|Rose (TV story)}}, {{cs|Aliens of London (TV story)}}, {{cs|World War Three (TV story)}}, etc.) However, another account claimed Mickey lived in 90 Bucknall House, the same block of flats as Rose. ([[PROSE]]: {{cs|Doctor Who: The Encyclopedia (reference book)|ed=2011 reprint|page=281|name="encyclopedia"}}) According to a third account, Mickey lived in 10 Bucknall House. ([[PROSE]]: {{cs|Mickey (reference book)|namedpart=Mickey Data|page=6|name="data"}}) According to to a fourth, in which there were only two towers, Mickey lived in 90 Powell Tower. ([[PROSE]]: {{cs|Rose (novelisation)}}) | |||
== Residents == | == Residents == | ||
Between [[2005]] and [[2006]], its residents included [[Rose Tyler|Rose]] and [[Jackie Tyler]], [[Mickey Smith]], ([[TV]]: ''[[Rose (TV story)|Rose]]'') [[Arianna]], [[Jolene (Retail Therapy)|Jolene]], [[Gemma (Retail Therapy)|Gemma]], ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Retail Therapy (audio story)|Retail Therapy]]'') [[Trisha Delaney]], [[Rosita (Wednesday For Beginners)|Rosita]], [[Yasmin (Wednesday For Beginners)|Yasmin]], [[Henry (Wednesday For Beginners)|Henry]], [[Frank (Wednesdays For Beginners)|Frank]], [[Doris (Wednesdays For Beginners)|Doris]], [[Bill (Wednesdays For Beginners)|Bill]], [[Maxine (Wednesdays For Beginners)|Maxine]], [[Boufakis|Mrs Boufakis]], ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Wednesdays For Beginners (audio story)|Wednesdays For Beginners]]'') [[McGregor (Winner Takes All)|Mrs McGregor]], [[Pye (Winner Takes All)|Mrs Pye]], [[Darren Pye|Darren]], ([[PROSE]]: ''[[Winner Takes All (novel)|Winner Takes All]]'') [[Sandra (The Christmas Invasion)|Sandra]], [[Jason Overton|Jason]] and [[Tina (A Groatsworth of Wit)|Tina]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Christmas Invasion (TV story)|The Christmas Invasion]]'') | Between [[2005]] and [[2006]], its residents included [[Rose Tyler|Rose]] and [[Jackie Tyler]], [[Mickey Smith]], ([[TV]]: ''[[Rose (TV story)|Rose]]'') [[Arianna]], [[Jolene (Retail Therapy)|Jolene]], [[Gemma (Retail Therapy)|Gemma]], ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Retail Therapy (audio story)|Retail Therapy]]'') [[Trisha Delaney]], [[Rosita (Wednesday For Beginners)|Rosita]], [[Yasmin (Wednesday For Beginners)|Yasmin]], [[Henry (Wednesday For Beginners)|Henry]], [[Frank (Wednesdays For Beginners)|Frank]], [[Doris (Wednesdays For Beginners)|Doris]], [[Bill (Wednesdays For Beginners)|Bill]], [[Maxine (Wednesdays For Beginners)|Maxine]], [[Boufakis|Mrs Boufakis]], ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Wednesdays For Beginners (audio story)|Wednesdays For Beginners]]'') [[McGregor (Winner Takes All)|Mrs McGregor]], [[Pye (Winner Takes All)|Mrs Pye]], [[Darren Pye|Darren]], ([[PROSE]]: ''[[Winner Takes All (novel)|Winner Takes All]]'') [[Sandra (The Christmas Invasion)|Sandra]], [[Jason Overton|Jason]] and [[Tina (A Groatsworth of Wit)|Tina]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Christmas Invasion (TV story)|The Christmas Invasion]]'') In an ultimately-undone [[timeline (73 Yards)|timeline]], [[Ruby Sunday]] moved in in [[2029]] and remained there until at least [[2046]]. ([[PROSE]]: {{cs|73 Yards (novelisation)|page=98, 103, 146-147}}) | ||
== History == | == History == | ||
| Line 54: | Line 77: | ||
[[Cleo Proctor]] grew up at the Powell Estate. ([[AUDIO]]: {{cs|Interrogation (audio story)}}) | [[Cleo Proctor]] grew up at the Powell Estate. ([[AUDIO]]: {{cs|Interrogation (audio story)}}) | ||
In an ultimately-undone [[timeline (73 Yards)|timeline]], [[Ruby Sunday]] moved in to a small apartment on the Powell Estate in [[2029]], and remained there until at least [[2046]]; she had watched the [[streetlight]]s, cars and [[office block]]s around the Estate change over the years. She could see [[UNIT HQ, City of London|Unit Tower]], which later became The Unit, from her window. ([[PROSE]]: {{cs|73 Yards (novelisation)|page=98, 103, 145-147}}) | |||
== Behind the scenes == | == Behind the scenes == | ||
=== In-universe location === | === In-universe location === | ||
First and foremost, it should be clarified that the scenes for the Powell Estate block of flats were, primarily, filmed at the Brandon Estate in [[Kennington]],<ref> | First and foremost, it should be clarified that the scenes for the Powell Estate block of flats were, primarily, filmed at the [[Brandon Estate]] in [[Kennington]],<ref>{{cite web | ||
|url=https://www.doctorwholocations.net/locations/brandonestate | |||
|title=Brandon Estate, Kennington, London | |||
|website name=Doctor Who: The Locations Guide | |||
|writer=Chuck Foster | |||
|date of source=200X | |||
|accessdate=17 July 2024 | |||
|archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20080108080227/https://www.doctorwholocations.net/locations/brandonestate | |||
|archivedate=8 January 2008 | |||
}}</ref> and that Kennington is situated on the border of {{w|London Borough of Lambeth}} and London Borough of Southwark. The stairwell<ref>[[TCH 48]]{{which}}</ref> and other parts of the estate<ref name="TCH 49">[[TCH 49]]{{which}}</ref> were also doubled by locations in Cardiff. | |||
[[File:Slitheen Craft Southwark.jpeg|thumb|right|The [[Slitheen craft (Aliens of London)|Slitheen craft]] flies past the Powell Estate, towards [[Tower Bridge]], in | [[File:Slitheen Craft Southwark.jpeg|thumb|right|The [[Slitheen craft (Aliens of London)|Slitheen craft]] flies past the Powell Estate, towards [[Tower Bridge]], in {{cs|Aliens of London (TV story)}}. This shot, among others, geographically means that the Powell Estate is in a 1:1 place to the Brandon Estate.]] | ||
* First, the establishing shots of the camera zooming from space onto Rose's alarm clock at 48 Bucknall House after the opening titles in the first episode of [[Series 1 (Doctor Who)|series one]], | * First, the establishing shots of the camera zooming from space onto Rose's alarm clock at 48 Bucknall House after the opening titles in the first episode of [[Series 1 (Doctor Who 2005)|series one]], {{cs|Rose (TV story)}} shows the geography of Kennington, including the Brandon Estate, [[the Oval]] and Kennington Park. | ||
* Second, the shots of the [[Slitheen craft (Aliens of London)|Slitheen craft]] in the fourth episode of series one, | * Second, the shots of the [[Slitheen craft (Aliens of London)|Slitheen craft]] in the fourth episode of series one, {{cs|Aliens of London (TV story)}}, depicts the flight-path following the real-world geography of London; it is seen that the craft flies over the Powell Estate, in the direction of [[Tower Bridge]] with [[the Gherkin]] towards the top-left. Other Southwark landmarks, such as [[London City Hall]] and [[HMS Belfast]], are also seen. | ||
* Third, in the fifth episode of series one, ''[[World War Three (TV story)|World War Three]]'', a poster for the [[Brandon Youth Centre]] is seen, which in the real world is located at 19 [[Maddock Way]], within the immediate proximity of the estate.<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20230722200821/https://www.onehubsouthwark.co.uk/youth-centres/brandon-youth-centre Brandon Youth Centre at onehubsouthwark.co.uk via the Wayback Machine]</ref> | * Third, in the fifth episode of series one, ''[[World War Three (TV story)|World War Three]]'', a poster for the [[Brandon Youth Centre]] is seen, which in the real world is located at 19 [[Maddock Way]], within the immediate proximity of the estate.<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20230722200821/https://www.onehubsouthwark.co.uk/youth-centres/brandon-youth-centre Brandon Youth Centre at onehubsouthwark.co.uk via the Wayback Machine]</ref> | ||
* Fourth, many other businesses along Maddock Way are seen in various episodes, from [[Maddock Cleaners]] in ''[[World War Three (TV story)|World War Three]]'', [[Maddock Way Surgery]] in ''[[The Christmas Invasion (TV story)|The Christmas Invasion]]'', and [[Maddock Way Chemist]] in ''[[The End of Time (TV story)|The End of Time]]''. | * Fourth, many other businesses along Maddock Way are seen in various episodes, from [[Maddock Cleaners]] in ''[[World War Three (TV story)|World War Three]]'', [[Maddock Way Surgery]] in ''[[The Christmas Invasion (TV story)|The Christmas Invasion]]'', and [[Maddock Way Chemist]] in ''[[The End of Time (TV story)|The End of Time]]''. | ||
* Fifth, while never explicitly stated on screen, scenes located at [[Walterley Street]] in the eighth episode of series one, ''[[Father's Day (TV story)|Father's Day]]'', there is a street sign that names the street as being part of the "London Borough of Southwark". In that episode, Walterley is implied to be a short walk from [[Jordan Road]] and the Powell Estate. The scenes on each of these roads were filmed in Cardiff,<ref name="TCH 49"/> more than a hundred miles from either the boroughs of Southwark or Lambeth. | * Fifth, while never explicitly stated on screen, scenes located at [[Walterley Street]] in the eighth episode of series one, ''[[Father's Day (TV story)|Father's Day]]'', there is a street sign that names the street as being part of the "London Borough of Southwark". In that episode, Walterley is implied to be a short walk from [[Jordan Road]] and the Powell Estate. The scenes on each of these roads were filmed in Cardiff,<ref name="TCH 49"/> more than a hundred miles from either the boroughs of Southwark or Lambeth. | ||
The televised stories that featured the Powell Estate seemed to imply that the estate was virtually identical to the Brandon Estate, from geographic location to appearance, perhaps suggesting that the only difference between the real world and the DWU was the ''name'' of the estate. Although technically, in the real world, | The televised stories that featured the Powell Estate seemed to imply that the estate was virtually identical to the Brandon Estate, from geographic location to appearance, perhaps suggesting that the only difference between the real world and the DWU was the ''name'' of the estate. Although technically, in the real world, Maddock Way is not technically part of the Brandon Estate, despite being located right next to the base of the towers; many of the businesses that operate along Maddocks Way are include "Brandon" in their names, such as the [[Brandon Library]], and many other businesses include "Maddock" in their names. | ||
A less explicit and consistent placement appears in ''[[The Christmas Invasion (TV story)|The Christmas Invasion]]''. The 2005 [[Christmas Special]]'s pre-titles sequence reuses the zooming shot from ''Rose'' (this time ending in Jackie's living room area). When the [[Fire Trap|Sycorax spaceship]] covers London, it clearly covers much of the skies of the Powell Estate from below, yet from above it passes over [[Hyde Park]], [[Green Park]], [[St James's Park]], [[Regent's Park]], and by extension [[London Zoo]] and [[Buckingham Palace]]. All of these locations are notably north of the [[River Thames]], while Southwark and Lambeth are south of it. The firing of the [[Jathaa sunglider laser]]s seen from [[Bloxham Road]] implies at least one of the lasers is in the vicinity of the real-world Brandon Estate, as one of the lasers seen from above begins its ascent close to the {{w|SIS Building}} and {{w|Vauxhall Bridge}}, about a mile from the estate. Despite dialogue placing Bloxham Road around the corner from the Powell Estate, filming took place in [[Brentford]] in the London Borough of Hounslow,<ref name="bloxham">[[TCH 51]]</ref> about 11 miles from the Brandon Estate and on the north side of the Thames. | |||
Additionally, while the scene where the Doctor and Rose talk after neutralising the Auton arm in [[TV]]: {{cs|Rose (TV story)}} was filmed at [[Lydstep Crescent]] in [[Cardiff]] (which has only three towers),<ref>{{cite web | |||
|url=http://www.doctorwholocations.net/locations/lydstepflats | |||
|title=Lydstep Crescent, Gabalfa, Cardiff | |||
|website name=Doctor Who: The Locations Guide | |||
|writer=Chuck Foster | |||
|date of source=200X | |||
|accessdate=17 July 2024 | |||
|archiveurl=https://web.archive.org/web/20080108083634/http://www.doctorwholocations.net/locations/lydstepflats | |||
|archivedate=8 January 2008 | |||
}}</ref> the buildings are cleverly shown to imitate the towers at the Brandon Estate — with the usage of a shot that gives the illusion there are at least five towers, as well as footage of the Brandon Estate spliced into the end of the scene, it is clear that the Cardiff location is being manipulated to resemble the Brandon Estate — this is also evident from an establishing shot earlier in the episode showing the latter estate. A minor contradiction is present however, as it instead shows Rose's flat being in one of the towers, not Bucknall House. | |||
Some spin-off media — such as the short story ''[[ | Some spin-off media — such as the short story ''[[Rose Tyler (short story)|Rose Tyler]]'' explicitly stating that the Powell Estate is located in Kennington and the novel ''[[Winner Takes All (novel)|Winner Takes All]]'' also showing similarities to the real Brandon Estate, including having [[Library, Powell Estate|a library]], a [[youth club, Powell Estate|youth club]], and its implied proximity to London itself — aligns with the televised geography, however most other spin-off media contradicts this. | ||
In the comic story ''[[Silver Scream (comic story)|Silver Scream]]'', it is stated that the Powell Estate is located in [[Peckham]]. This is reiterated in the novel ''[[Downtime: Child of the New World (novel)|Downtime: Child of the New World]]'' and the audio drama ''[[Ghosts (DWR audio story)|Ghosts]]''. While the Peckham locations ''is'' within the London Borough of Southwark, it adds around three extra miles and around a 60° angle on the shot of the Powell Estate to Tower Bridge, meaning that several shots in ''Aliens of London'' couldn't be possible. No in-universe explanation for this discrepancy has been given {{as of|April 2022}}. | In the comic story ''[[Silver Scream (comic story)|Silver Scream]]'', it is stated that the Powell Estate is located in [[Peckham]]. This is reiterated in the novel ''[[Downtime: Child of the New World (novel)|Downtime: Child of the New World]]'' and the audio drama ''[[Ghosts (DWR audio story)|Ghosts]]''. While the Peckham locations ''is'' within the London Borough of Southwark, it adds around three extra miles and around a 60° angle on the shot of the Powell Estate to Tower Bridge, meaning that several shots in ''Aliens of London'' couldn't be possible. No in-universe explanation for this discrepancy has been given {{as of|April 2022}}. | ||
Further complicating matters, [[Doctor Who website|the BBC's webpage on ''Doctor Who'']] from 2005 states that Rose is from SE15, which is Peckham's postcode,<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20050323031920/http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/ ''Doctor Who'' on bbc.co.uk via the Wayback Machine]</ref> whereas the postcodes for Kennington are SE11 and SE17. Furthermore, the twelfth episode of [[Series 2 (Doctor Who)|series two]], ''[[Army of Ghosts (TV story)|Army of Ghosts]]'', (a story filmed partially on the Brandon Estate and partially in Cardiff) and the short story ''[[Meet Rose (short story)|Meet Rose]]'' give "SE15 7GO" as her postcode, and the aforementioned Walterley Street sign in ''Father's Day'' is also marked as SE15. | Further complicating matters, [[Doctor Who website|the BBC's webpage on ''Doctor Who'']] from 2005 states that Rose is from SE15, which is Peckham's postcode,<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20050323031920/http://www.bbc.co.uk/doctorwho/ ''Doctor Who'' on bbc.co.uk via the Wayback Machine]</ref> whereas the postcodes for Kennington are SE11 and SE17. Furthermore, the twelfth episode of [[Series 2 (Doctor Who 2005)|series two]], ''[[Army of Ghosts (TV story)|Army of Ghosts]]'', (a story filmed partially on the Brandon Estate and partially in Cardiff) and the short story ''[[Meet Rose (short story)|Meet Rose]]'' give "SE15 7GO" as her postcode, and the aforementioned Walterley Street sign in ''Father's Day'' is also marked as SE15. | ||
Furthermore, given that the scenes for the Powell Estate were filmed across four different locations, each varying in terms of size and shape,<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20230620180319/https://twitter.com/set_dw/status/1620089579100606465 @set_dw on Twitter]</ref> confuses the appearance of the surrounding area somewhat too. | Furthermore, given that the scenes for the Powell Estate were filmed across four different locations, each varying in terms of size and shape,<ref>[https://web.archive.org/web/20230620180319/https://twitter.com/set_dw/status/1620089579100606465 @set_dw on Twitter]</ref> and a fifth location on the nominally adjacent Bloxham Road was somewhere entirely different to the other four,<ref name="bloxham"/> this confuses the appearance of the surrounding area somewhat too. | ||
== Footnotes == | == Footnotes == | ||
| Line 86: | Line 133: | ||
[[Category:Locations visited by the Ninth Doctor]] | [[Category:Locations visited by the Ninth Doctor]] | ||
[[Category:Locations visited by the Tenth Doctor]] | [[Category:Locations visited by the Tenth Doctor]] | ||
[[Category:Locations visited by Jack Harkness]] | |||
[[Category:Locations from the real world]] | |||
[[it:Powell Estate]] | [[it:Powell Estate]] | ||
Latest revision as of 01:44, 7 September 2024
The Powell Estate was a council estate in the London Borough of Southwark where Rose and Jackie Tyler and Mickey Smith lived.
Both the Ninth and Tenth Doctors visited the estate frequently throughout their time travelling with Rose Tyler, typically materialising the TARDIS on Maddock Way. As Rose's entire world was opened up in ways she could never have imagined upon meeting the Doctor, she found domestic life at the estate to be impossible to go back to. The Doctor would go on to form friendships with some of the other residents, in particular Mickey, whom he initially derided and mocked.
Geography[[edit] | [edit source]]
Although the Powell Estate was located in the London Borough of Southwark, (TV: Father's Day [+]Loading...["Father's Day (TV story)"]) in South East London, (PROSE: Doctor Who: The Encyclopedia [+]Loading...["Doctor Who: The Encyclopedia (reference book)"]) its exact location varied between accounts.
Kennington[[edit] | [edit source]]
According to many accounts, the Powell Estate was located in Kennington.
This was evident from various landmarks being visible from the roof of Bucknall House, from several distinctive council estates to the London Eye and the Gherkin, (TV: Aliens of London [+]Loading...["Aliens of London (TV story)"], etc.) as well as its relative proximity to the Oval and the Thames, (TV: Rose [+]Loading...["Rose (TV story)"]) with UNIT personnel indeed confirming its Kennington location. (PROSE: Rose Tyler [+]Loading...["Rose Tyler (short story)"])
Peckham[[edit] | [edit source]]
According to other accounts, the Powell Estate was located in Peckham.
This was asserted by many accounts, (COMIC: Silver Scream [+]Loading...["Silver Scream (comic story)"], PROSE: Downtime: Child of the New World [+]Loading...["Downtime: Child of the New World (novel)"], AUDIO: Ghosts [+]Loading...["Ghosts (Redacted audio story)"]) with one account specifying North Peckham. (PROSE: The Time Traveller's Almanac [+]Loading...{"chaptname":"Everything Changes","page":"71","chaptnum":"3","1":"The Time Traveller's Almanac (reference book)"}) Its nearest station was Peckham Rye. (AUDIO: Ghosts [+]Loading...["Ghosts (Redacted audio story)"])
Layout[[edit] | [edit source]]
The layout of the Powell Estate was mostly consistent between accounts, although not without its own contradictions.
Generally, the Powell Estate was shown to be accessible from a road; turning on to Maddock Way, there was one block of flats to the left before a building filled with shops, which ended before another building containing the library and youth centre. On the right, a longer building, also filled with shops, ran the length of Maddock Way. On the other side laid a car park. At the end of Maddock Way laid Bucknall House, a squat block of flats which ran parallel to the road Maddock Way was accessible from. Beyond Bucknall House laid six tall towers, arranged approximately in a u-shape. (TV: Rose [+]Loading...["Rose (TV story)"], Aliens of London [+]Loading...["Aliens of London (TV story)"], The Christmas Invasion [+]Loading...["The Christmas Invasion (TV story)"], The End of Time (part two) [+]Loading...{"part":"Two","1":"The End of Time (TV story)"}, COMIC: Revolving Doors [+]Loading...["Revolving Doors (comic story)"], etc.)
The shops on the left included Mart Ltd and Maddock Way Chemist, (TV: The Christmas Invasion [+]Loading...["The Christmas Invasion (TV story)"], The End of Time (part two) [+]Loading...{"part":"Two","1":"The End of Time (TV story)"}) and the shops on the right included Consumers Food + Wine, (TV: Aliens of London [+]Loading...["Aliens of London (TV story)"]) Maddock Way Surgery, (TV: The Christmas Invasion [+]Loading...["The Christmas Invasion (TV story)"]) and Maddock Cleaners. (TV: World War Three [+]Loading...["World War Three (TV story)"]) Without any indication to its exact location, there was also a Chinese takeaway. (PROSE: Winner Takes All [+]Loading...{"page":"13","chaptnum":"1","1":"Winner Takes All (novel)"})
According to one account, however, the Powell Estate had merely two towers of sixteen floors, unofficially called Enoch and Powell, with six flats per storey. The towers rose above a squat quadrant with shops, such as a newsagents, Dev the bookie's and Chicken Shack & Rack. (PROSE: Rose [+]Loading...["Rose (novelisation)"])
Furthermore, where individuals such as Mickey Smith lived was also subject to contradiction.
Mickey Smith's flat[[edit] | [edit source]]
- Main article: Mickey Smith's flat
Mickey was shown to live in the tower nearest the road, in flat 90. (TV: Rose [+]Loading...["Rose (TV story)"], Aliens of London [+]Loading...["Aliens of London (TV story)"], World War Three [+]Loading...["World War Three (TV story)"], etc.) However, another account claimed Mickey lived in 90 Bucknall House, the same block of flats as Rose. (PROSE: Doctor Who: The Encyclopedia [+]Loading...{"name":"\"encyclopedia\"","page":"281","ed":"2011 reprint","1":"Doctor Who: The Encyclopedia (reference book)"}) According to a third account, Mickey lived in 10 Bucknall House. (PROSE: "Mickey Data" [+]Part of Mickey, Loading...{"name":"\"data\"","page":"6","namedpart":"Mickey Data","1":"Mickey (reference book)"}) According to to a fourth, in which there were only two towers, Mickey lived in 90 Powell Tower. (PROSE: Rose [+]Loading...["Rose (novelisation)"])
Residents[[edit] | [edit source]]
Between 2005 and 2006, its residents included Rose and Jackie Tyler, Mickey Smith, (TV: Rose) Arianna, Jolene, Gemma, (AUDIO: Retail Therapy) Trisha Delaney, Rosita, Yasmin, Henry, Frank, Doris, Bill, Maxine, Mrs Boufakis, (AUDIO: Wednesdays For Beginners) Mrs McGregor, Mrs Pye, Darren, (PROSE: Winner Takes All) Sandra, Jason and Tina. (TV: The Christmas Invasion) In an ultimately-undone timeline, Ruby Sunday moved in in 2029 and remained there until at least 2046. (PROSE: 73 Yards [+]Loading...{"page":"98, 103, 146-147","1":"73 Yards (novelisation)"})
History[[edit] | [edit source]]
This section is stubby and some of the information would be better served to be duplicated and/or moved to Maddock Way, which is specifically the area of shops at the base of the towers. Also some parts aren't in chronological order.
In 1879, Queen Victoria knighted future resident Rose Tyler as "Dame Rose of the Powell Estate" before exiling her from the British Empire. (TV: Tooth and Claw [+]Loading...["Tooth and Claw (TV story)"])
The Powell Estate was built in 1973. By this account, in which there were only two towers, they were unofficially called Enoch and Powell under the mistaken belief that Enoch Powell MP had christened the estate when in actuality it was named after the developer's wife's mother, Mary Jane Powell, who had died in 1951. (PROSE: Rose [+]Loading...["Rose (novelisation)"])
.jpg)
While trying to siphon off of the Tenth Doctor's emotional pain, the Reach deposited him at the Powell Estate shortly before its opening. (COMIC: Revolving Doors [+]Loading...["Revolving Doors (comic story)"])
On several occasions during the 1990s, Captain Jack Harkness, who travelled with the Ninth Doctor and Rose Tyler for some time, visited the Powell Estate to watch Rose grow up, but did not approach her to avoid disrupting her timeline. (TV: Utopia [+]Loading...["Utopia (TV story)"])
The Ninth Doctor visited the Powell Estate in 1998 after buying Rose a red bicycle for Christmas. (PROSE: The Red Bicycle [+]Loading...["The Red Bicycle (short story)"])
In September 2004, Len Cawl and Sid Adarsh stashed the kidnapped teenagers, Gordon Lethbridge-Stewart and Conall Wilson, in a flat in Bucknall House, and talked about a woman who lived below them called Jacks, who had a gobby teenage daughter. (PROSE: Downtime: Child of the New World [+]Loading...["Downtime: Child of the New World (novel)"])
Jackie Tyler first moved into 48 Bucknall House (TV: Love & Monsters [+]Loading...["Love & Monsters (TV story)"]) at the Powell Estate in the late 1980s with her husband Pete. It was there that their daughter Rose grew up. (TV: Father's Day [+]Loading...["Father's Day (TV story)"], Doomsday [+]Loading...["Doomsday (TV story)"]) River Song briefly moved into number 23 in 2007. (AUDIO: R&J [+]Loading...["R&J (audio story)"])
The Tenth Doctor, just before regenerating, made a final visit to the Powell Estate on 1 January 2005. He observed Rose and Jackie, months before he first met them in their timeline. He also exchanged a few words with Rose before staggering back to the TARDIS, parked nearby, to regenerate. (TV: The End of Time [+]Loading...["The End of Time (TV story)"])
Powell Estate Motors was a business located around the Powell Estate by 2007. (TV: Love & Monsters [+]Loading...["Love & Monsters (TV story)"])
The Powell Estate became the site of considerable excitement from the years 2005 to 2007 after Rose Tyler encountered the Ninth Doctor.
Mickey Smith was believed to have murdered his girlfriend, Rose Tyler, when she disappeared, due to leaving to travel with the Ninth Doctor and returning home a year later than she intended. As a result, he was shunned by the Powell Estate, especially when Rose's mother, Jackie Tyler, continuously spread rumours of his guilt. Two weeks after Rose's return on 6 March 2006, (TV: Aliens of London [+]Loading...["Aliens of London (TV story)"]) the people around the estate began being more helpful to Mickey, now that they knew he wasn't a murderer, (PROSE: Essay Competition [+]Loading...["Essay Competition (short story)"]) although the youths of the estate still theorised he was. (PROSE: Winner Takes All [+]Loading...{"page":"189","chaptnum":"16","1":"Winner Takes All (novel)"})
The Powell Estate was one of many sites in London and around the world which were invaded by Cybermen from the alternate reality known as "Pete's World" before the Tenth Doctor expelled the invaders into the Void. (TV: Army of Ghosts [+]Loading...["Army of Ghosts (TV story)"]/Doomsday [+]Loading...["Doomsday (TV story)"]) As a result of these events, Rose and Jackie were stranded on Pete's World, effectively abandoning their home in the Powell Estate. (TV: Doomsday [+]Loading...["Doomsday (TV story)"]) Sometime during these events, Suzy Monroe went to the Powell Estate to film the Cybermen, who looked like ghosts. It was broadcasted live on Ghostwatch. After she had filmed several Cybermen Suzy left to have a look at some other viewers' sightings and was attacked by a Cyberman. (GAME: Ghostwatch [+]Loading...["Ghostwatch (video game)"])
The Tenth Doctor claimed he had picked up his accent from the Powell Estate, when talking to Archie Maplin in 1929. He found common ground with Maplin by noting that the estate was in Peckham, Maplin's home. (COMIC: Silver Scream [+]Loading...["Silver Scream (comic story)"])
Cleo Proctor grew up at the Powell Estate. (AUDIO: Interrogation [+]Loading...["Interrogation (audio story)"])
In an ultimately-undone timeline, Ruby Sunday moved in to a small apartment on the Powell Estate in 2029, and remained there until at least 2046; she had watched the streetlights, cars and office blocks around the Estate change over the years. She could see Unit Tower, which later became The Unit, from her window. (PROSE: 73 Yards [+]Loading...{"page":"98, 103, 145-147","1":"73 Yards (novelisation)"})
Behind the scenes[[edit] | [edit source]]
In-universe location[[edit] | [edit source]]
First and foremost, it should be clarified that the scenes for the Powell Estate block of flats were, primarily, filmed at the Brandon Estate in Kennington,[1] and that Kennington is situated on the border of London Borough of Lambeth and London Borough of Southwark. The stairwell[2] and other parts of the estate[3] were also doubled by locations in Cardiff.
- First, the establishing shots of the camera zooming from space onto Rose's alarm clock at 48 Bucknall House after the opening titles in the first episode of series one, Rose [+]Loading...["Rose (TV story)"] shows the geography of Kennington, including the Brandon Estate, the Oval and Kennington Park.
- Second, the shots of the Slitheen craft in the fourth episode of series one, Aliens of London [+]Loading...["Aliens of London (TV story)"], depicts the flight-path following the real-world geography of London; it is seen that the craft flies over the Powell Estate, in the direction of Tower Bridge with the Gherkin towards the top-left. Other Southwark landmarks, such as London City Hall and HMS Belfast, are also seen.
- Third, in the fifth episode of series one, World War Three, a poster for the Brandon Youth Centre is seen, which in the real world is located at 19 Maddock Way, within the immediate proximity of the estate.[4]
- Fourth, many other businesses along Maddock Way are seen in various episodes, from Maddock Cleaners in World War Three, Maddock Way Surgery in The Christmas Invasion, and Maddock Way Chemist in The End of Time.
- Fifth, while never explicitly stated on screen, scenes located at Walterley Street in the eighth episode of series one, Father's Day, there is a street sign that names the street as being part of the "London Borough of Southwark". In that episode, Walterley is implied to be a short walk from Jordan Road and the Powell Estate. The scenes on each of these roads were filmed in Cardiff,[3] more than a hundred miles from either the boroughs of Southwark or Lambeth.
The televised stories that featured the Powell Estate seemed to imply that the estate was virtually identical to the Brandon Estate, from geographic location to appearance, perhaps suggesting that the only difference between the real world and the DWU was the name of the estate. Although technically, in the real world, Maddock Way is not technically part of the Brandon Estate, despite being located right next to the base of the towers; many of the businesses that operate along Maddocks Way are include "Brandon" in their names, such as the Brandon Library, and many other businesses include "Maddock" in their names.
A less explicit and consistent placement appears in The Christmas Invasion. The 2005 Christmas Special's pre-titles sequence reuses the zooming shot from Rose (this time ending in Jackie's living room area). When the Sycorax spaceship covers London, it clearly covers much of the skies of the Powell Estate from below, yet from above it passes over Hyde Park, Green Park, St James's Park, Regent's Park, and by extension London Zoo and Buckingham Palace. All of these locations are notably north of the River Thames, while Southwark and Lambeth are south of it. The firing of the Jathaa sunglider lasers seen from Bloxham Road implies at least one of the lasers is in the vicinity of the real-world Brandon Estate, as one of the lasers seen from above begins its ascent close to the SIS Building and Vauxhall Bridge, about a mile from the estate. Despite dialogue placing Bloxham Road around the corner from the Powell Estate, filming took place in Brentford in the London Borough of Hounslow,[5] about 11 miles from the Brandon Estate and on the north side of the Thames.
Additionally, while the scene where the Doctor and Rose talk after neutralising the Auton arm in TV: Rose [+]Loading...["Rose (TV story)"] was filmed at Lydstep Crescent in Cardiff (which has only three towers),[6] the buildings are cleverly shown to imitate the towers at the Brandon Estate — with the usage of a shot that gives the illusion there are at least five towers, as well as footage of the Brandon Estate spliced into the end of the scene, it is clear that the Cardiff location is being manipulated to resemble the Brandon Estate — this is also evident from an establishing shot earlier in the episode showing the latter estate. A minor contradiction is present however, as it instead shows Rose's flat being in one of the towers, not Bucknall House.
Some spin-off media — such as the short story Rose Tyler explicitly stating that the Powell Estate is located in Kennington and the novel Winner Takes All also showing similarities to the real Brandon Estate, including having a library, a youth club, and its implied proximity to London itself — aligns with the televised geography, however most other spin-off media contradicts this.
In the comic story Silver Scream, it is stated that the Powell Estate is located in Peckham. This is reiterated in the novel Downtime: Child of the New World and the audio drama Ghosts. While the Peckham locations is within the London Borough of Southwark, it adds around three extra miles and around a 60° angle on the shot of the Powell Estate to Tower Bridge, meaning that several shots in Aliens of London couldn't be possible. No in-universe explanation for this discrepancy has been given As of April 2022[update].
Further complicating matters, the BBC's webpage on Doctor Who from 2005 states that Rose is from SE15, which is Peckham's postcode,[7] whereas the postcodes for Kennington are SE11 and SE17. Furthermore, the twelfth episode of series two, Army of Ghosts, (a story filmed partially on the Brandon Estate and partially in Cardiff) and the short story Meet Rose give "SE15 7GO" as her postcode, and the aforementioned Walterley Street sign in Father's Day is also marked as SE15.
Furthermore, given that the scenes for the Powell Estate were filmed across four different locations, each varying in terms of size and shape,[8] and a fifth location on the nominally adjacent Bloxham Road was somewhere entirely different to the other four,[5] this confuses the appearance of the surrounding area somewhat too.
Footnotes[[edit] | [edit source]]
- ↑ Brandon Estate, Kennington, London. Doctor Who: The Locations Guide (200X). Archived from the original on 8 January 2008. Retrieved on 17 July 2024.
- ↑ TCH 48[which?]
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 TCH 49[which?]
- ↑ Brandon Youth Centre at onehubsouthwark.co.uk via the Wayback Machine
- ↑ 5.0 5.1 TCH 51
- ↑ Lydstep Crescent, Gabalfa, Cardiff. Doctor Who: The Locations Guide (200X). Archived from the original on 8 January 2008. Retrieved on 17 July 2024.
- ↑ Doctor Who on bbc.co.uk via the Wayback Machine
- ↑ @set_dw on Twitter
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
