User:NateBumber/Sandbox/3: Difference between revisions
NateBumber (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
NateBumber (talk | contribs) No edit summary |
||
Line 198: | Line 198: | ||
=== ''[[Time Fracture (stage play)|Time Fracture]]'' === | === ''[[Time Fracture (stage play)|Time Fracture]]'' === | ||
* ''[[Time Fracture Show Companion]]'', ''[[UNIT Field Log]]'', ''[[This is Sergeant Robert Dudley. (webcast)|This is Sergeant Robert Dudley.]]'', et al. | * ''[[Time Fracture Show Companion]]'', ''[[UNIT Field Log]]'', ''[[This is Sergeant Robert Dudley. (webcast)|This is Sergeant Robert Dudley.]]'', et al. | ||
== Realities == | |||
When it comes to continuity, tone, and worldview, the ''Doctor Who'' universe's many spin-offs and sub-series have usually been more concerned with themselves than each other. Within a series such as ''[[The Monthly Adventures]]'', one can expect to find more references to previous audios and the Classic show than, for instance, the [[Virgin Decalogs]] or [[Doctor Who annual]]s. As a result, each series presents a relatively self-contained chunk of [[the Doctor's reality]]. Sometimes these pieces have ebbed and flowed into each other through shared characters or references; other times, they have gone out of their way to paint each other as separate timelines or universes. | |||
While acknowleding that most sources suggest these all to be the same reality, it's helpful to cover the self-consistent chunks separately, to highlight the ways in which they stand on their own. [[User:TheChampionOfTime|TheChampionOfTime]] has paved the way for this aptly with the creation of pages like [[Virgin reality]].<ref>To emphasize the fact that these are ''not'' necessarily separate realities, perhaps it would be better to use subpages such as [[The Doctor's reality/Virgin reality]] etc.</ref> To help myself keep this straight in my mind, this table matches the "reality" pages with the approximate stories and series they cover. | |||
{| {{prettytable}} | |||
! Page || Series | |||
|- | |||
|[[The Doctor's reality (The Not-So-Sinister Sponge)]] | |||
|[[Doctor Who annual]]s seen through the lens of ''[[Short Trips and Side Steps]]''. | |||
|- | |||
|[[2-D universe]] | |||
|''[[Doctor Who Magazine]]'' comics | |||
|- | |||
|[[Virgin reality]] | |||
|[[Virgin Books]] ''[[Virgin New Adventures|New Adventures]]'', ''[[Virgin Missing Adventures|Missing Adventures]]'', and ''[[Virgin Decalogs|Decalogs]]'' | |||
|- | |||
|[[Braxiatel Collection's revised timeline]] | |||
|''[[Bernice Summerfield (series)|Bernice Summerfield]]'' | |||
|- | |||
|[[Barusa's universe]] | |||
|[[Leekley Bible]] | |||
|- | |||
|[[Infinity Doctor's reality]] | |||
|''[[The Infinity Doctors (novel)|The Infinity Doctors]]'' | |||
|- | |||
|[[The Doctor's reality (The Eight Doctors)]] | |||
|[[BBC Books]] ''[[Eighth Doctor Adventures (prose series)|Eighth Doctor Adventures]]''; perhaps the ''[[BBC Past Doctor Adventures|Past Doctor Adventures]]'' as well | |||
|- | |||
|[[War in Heaven]] | |||
|''[[Faction Paradox (series)|Faction Paradox]]''? | |||
|- | |||
|[[Post-War universe]] | |||
|''Eighth Doctor Adventures'' beginning with ''[[The Burning (novel)|The Burning]]'' | |||
|- | |||
|[[Council of Eight's universe]] | |||
|Following the [[multiverse collapse (Time Zero)|multiverse collapse]] | |||
|- | |||
|[[Positive-time universe]] | |||
|[[Big Finish]]'s ''[[The Monthly Adventures|Monthly Adventures]]'' and so on | |||
|- | |||
|[[Unbound Universe]] | |||
|''[[Sympathy for the Devil (audio story)|Sympathy for the Devil]]'' and so on | |||
|- | |||
|[[Parallel universe (Full Fathom Five)]] | |||
|''[[Full Fathom Five (audio story)|Full Fathom Five]]'' | |||
|- | |||
|[[2040 timeline (The Nuclear Option)]] | |||
|''[[Short Trips: 2040]]'' | |||
|- | |||
|[[Post-Time War universe]] | |||
|''Doctor Who'' [[series 1 (Doctor Who)|series 1]]–[[series 4 (Doctor Who)|4]]; ''[[The Sarah Jane Adventures]]''; ''[[Torchwood (series)|Torchwood]]'' | |||
|- | |||
|[[Cracked universe (The Eleventh Hour)]] | |||
|''Doctor Who'' [[series 5 (Doctor Who)|series 5]] | |||
|- | |||
|[[Rebooted universe (The Big Bang)]] | |||
|''[[The Big Bang (TV story)|The Big Bang]]'' onwards | |||
|- | |||
|[[Lethbridge-Stewart's universe (The Forgotten Son)]] | |||
|''[[Lethbridge-Stewart (series)|Lethbridge-Stewart]]'' | |||
|} | |||
== Footnotes == | |||
{{reflist}} |
Revision as of 19:34, 13 July 2022
Novelisation character names
This is a list of pages that could be renamed under the policy change I suggested in Thread:231243. By no means is it complete!
- Abigail (The Crimson Horror) to Abigail Blench
- Abigail's friend (The Crimson Horror) to Sissy Roper
- Barclay (The Tenth Planet) to Tom Barclay
- Bates (Attack of the Cybermen) to Eregous Bates
- Bruce (Doctor Who) to Bruce Gerhardt
- Captain (The Rescue) to Smith (The Rescue)
- Caretaker (Scream of the Shalka) to Mitch Stannard
- Cashier (Warriors of Kudlak) to Pam (Warriors of Kudlak)
- Chamberlain (The Twin Dilemma) to Slarn (The Twin Dilemma)
- Clark (The Sea Devils) to Alan Clark
- Collins (Pyramids of Mars) to Josiah Collins
- Co-pilot (The Horns of Nimon) to Sardor
- Crewmember (Resurrection of the Daleks) to Baz Seaton
- Curly (The Enemy of the World) to Tibor
- Curtis (Doctor Who) to Shelly Curtis
- Detective-Inspector (The Daleks' Master Plan) to Windsor (The Daleks' Master Plan)
- Digby (Black Orchid) to Raymond Digby
- Edmund (The Crimson Horror) to Edmund Thursday
- Effie (The Crimson Horror) to Effie Thursday
- Female art lover (City of Death) to Elena (City of Death)
- First policeman (The Daleks' Master Plan) to Welland
- Forester (Planet of Giants) to Mark Forester
- Fortune teller (Snakedance) to Zara (Snakedance)
- Gareth (Doctor Who) to Gareth Fitzpatrick
- Heath (The Sontaran Experiment) to Warra
- Interviewer (The Daleks' Master Plan) to Jim Grant
- Jim (The Dæmons) to Josh Wilkins
- Joe (Scream of the Shalka) to Joe Latham
- Lavel to Françoise Lavel
- Louvre guide to Henriette (City of Death)
- Mackenzie (Ghost Light) to Alfred Mackenzie
- Male art lover (City of Death) to Harrison Mandel
- Matron (Mawdryn Undead) to Cassidy
- Miranda (Doctor Who) to Miranda Gerhardt
- Mitchell (The Sea Devils) to Tony Mitchell (The Sea Devils)
- Morok commander to Ogrek
- Morok guard 2 to Pluton
- Munro (Terror of the Zygons) to Jock Munro
- One (The Ark) to One XVII
- Parisian artist to Bourget
- Perkins (Fury from the Deep) to Ronald Perkins
- Pete (Doctor Who) to Pete Callahan
- Pilot (The Horns of Nimon) to Sekkoth
- Policeman 1 (Logopolis) to Donald Seagrave
- Presidential bodyguard (The Invasion of Time) to Varn
- Price (Fury from the Deep) to David Price
- Registrar (The Wedding of Sarah Jane Smith) to Sandra Cho
- Roberts (Doctor Who and the Silurians) to George Roberts
- Second policeman (The Daleks' Master Plan) to Blessed
- Sergeant (The Highlanders) to Klegg
- Shrinking Guardian to Niash
- Simmons (Dalek) to Danny Simmons
- Station sergeant to Ellis (The Daleks' Master Plan)
- Steward (Slipback) to Velsper
- The Squire (The Visitation) to John (The Visitation)
- Ted (Doctor Who) to Ted Kriechel
- Teresa (The Talons of Weng-Chiang) to Teresa Hart
- Thursday (The Crimson Horror) to Jonas Thursday
The above grouping only includes characters whose names are currently not unique on the wiki. Characters whose names were already unique are listed below; the issue of whether the longer titles should be used regardless as "future-proofing" is probably best decided case-by-case, as described in the policy about "When not to disambiguate".
- Abbott to Tom Abbott
- Carney to Mick Carney
- Fedorin to Nicholas Fedorin
- Griffiths to Charles Griffiths
- Katz to Katz Makrif
- Ollis to Mary Hollis
- Ridgeway to Robin Ridgeway
- Robbins to Thomas Robbins
- Salinger to Jim Salinger
- Swift to Roger Swift
- Van Lutyens to Pieter Van Lutyens
- Wagg to Joseph Wagg
- Wheeler to Angela Wheeler
- Wigner to Robert Wigner
- Zaroff to Hermann Zaroff
It's worth noting that there are already a ton of pages which use names from novelisations. An incomplete sample: Archie Sylvest; August Lilt; Cairn; Cass Fermazzi; Cedric (The King's Demons); Colin Redmayne; Derek Johnson; ECCO; Edith Randall; Fariah Neguib; Frank Harris; Fyodor Nikolai Kerensky; George Morris; Heidi Scarlioni; Jason Overton; Jebal; Joanna; Joshua Jobel; Justin Vogel; Lancelot Takis; Lee Lin; Mary Smith; Megara One; Megara Two; Odessa Smith; Owen Bywater; Owen Watson; Palmer; Ram Vermas; Robert Lines; Sakkib; Simon Metcalf; Smith; Sylvia Gribbins; Tasambeker Brown; Theodore Benik; Vincent Russell; Vorn; and Wilkins. Let them serve as not only demonstrations of the practicality of novelisation names being used more generally but also prompts for us to reconsider the current policy which forbids their existence!
Thinly-veiled characters
Doctors
- Cosmic Hobo (Second Doctor etc)
- El Jefe (Hartnell Doctor)
- Dr Oho (Cushing Doctor)
- Ninth Doctor 4 (The Tomorrow Windows) (Shalka Doctor)
- Grandfather Halfling (Relic Doctor)
- Lethean Campaign assassin (Relic Doctor)
- "Dr. Smith"
- The Evil Renegade
- Doctor Moon (45th Doctor)
- Old man (42nd Doctor)
- Paul Bowman (Eighth Doctor)
- War veteran (Now or Thereabouts) (Eighth Doctor)
- Drunk man (Now or Thereabouts) (Shalka Doctor)
- Singing man (Now or Thereabouts) (Ninth Doctor)
- Rivera Manuscript renegade (Relic Doctor?)
- Shift (Head of State) (The Other?)
- The Gestalt (?!?)
Masters
- Magister1971
- The Magistrate (currently merged with the War King, but they should really be separate)
- Man with the Rosette
- Mestizer
- Pavo
- Stream (The Hollows of Time)
- The War King
Other DWU characters
- Ashlyn (Clara splinter)
- Auteur (Astrolabus)
- Ceol (Kelsey Hooper)
- Companion (The Blue Angel) (Cedric (Search Out Space))
- The Imperator (Morbius I)
- John Scanlon (First Monk)
- Lolita (The Master's first TARDIS)
- Mademoiselle Machine (Ace)
- The Minister (Minister of Chance + Minister of War)
- Man with a bent nose (Minister of Chance)
- Maria (Now or Thereabouts) (Maria Jackson)
- The Mistress (The Choice) (Romana II)
- Nari (The Rani)
- Noble-woman (Donna Noble)
- Quandry (Cleavis)
- V. M. McCrimmon (Victoria Waterfield)
- Weapon (The Eyeless) (The Moment)
- Agent (Is anyone receiving these transmissions?) (Zoria)
Non-DWU characters
- Tara in Verdigris (Tara King)
- Claudia in Father Time (Claudia Marwood)
- Joseph Craator (Judge Dredd)
- The Professor (Doctor Omega)
- Cococyte (Doctor Omega)
Gerry Anderson universe
- Main article: Talk: The Indestructible Man (novel)#Parallels
Blake's 7
- Kaston Iago (Kerr Avon)
- Butcher of Zircaster (Travis)
Alien
- Life-spore (Xenomorph (kind of))
- Narcissus (Nostromo)
- James Watt (Kane)
- Jennifer Alistoun (Ellen Ripley)
Valid references to invalid stories
"The Pilot Episode"
- Unnatural History, Escape Velocity, and Deadline mention the Doctor's possible origin in the 49th century
Dr. Who and the Daleks
Too many to name, including
- Iris mentions or revisits the Cushing version of the adventure, specifically, in Bafflement and Devotion and From Wildthyme with Love
A Fix with Sontarans
- Fixing a Hole is a sequel
Search Out Space
- The Blue Angel references Cedric as the Doctor's companion
- Storm in a Tikka is a prequel
Dimensions in Time
- First Frontier mentions it as a "nightmare"
- Storm in a Tikka is a sequel
The Skivers (1995)
- The Gallifrey Chronicles mentions Jemima-Katy as one of the Doctor's companions
Death Comes to Time
- Relative Dementias and The Tomorrow Windows mention Anima Persis
- Trading Futures references the Canisian invasion
- The Gallifrey Chronicles mentions Tannis and features the Minister of Chance
- The Three Paths mentions Mount Plutarch
- Celestial Intervention references the Lune Forest
Scream of the Shalka
- Childhood Living features the Slarvians from The Feast of the Stone
- Whatever Happened to Iris Wildthyme? repeats the Shalka Doctor's joke about the Slarvians
- A Brief History of Time Lords references the android Master
whoisdoctorwho.co.uk
- The Christmas Invasion mentions the Doctor's meeting with Arthur Dent, which was first reported on the website
Attack of the Graske
- Opera of Doom! references the ABBA concert
- Monster File: Christmas references the changelings
- Whatever Happened to Sarah Jane? references "the Graske activity on Earth a few years ago"
- Journey's End and SJAF 1 reference Griffoth
The Twelfth Doctor Interactive Story
- Big Bang Generation mentions Time Squids and Crinis
Time Fracture
Realities
When it comes to continuity, tone, and worldview, the Doctor Who universe's many spin-offs and sub-series have usually been more concerned with themselves than each other. Within a series such as The Monthly Adventures, one can expect to find more references to previous audios and the Classic show than, for instance, the Virgin Decalogs or Doctor Who annuals. As a result, each series presents a relatively self-contained chunk of the Doctor's reality. Sometimes these pieces have ebbed and flowed into each other through shared characters or references; other times, they have gone out of their way to paint each other as separate timelines or universes.
While acknowleding that most sources suggest these all to be the same reality, it's helpful to cover the self-consistent chunks separately, to highlight the ways in which they stand on their own. TheChampionOfTime has paved the way for this aptly with the creation of pages like Virgin reality.[1] To help myself keep this straight in my mind, this table matches the "reality" pages with the approximate stories and series they cover.
Footnotes
- ↑ To emphasize the fact that these are not necessarily separate realities, perhaps it would be better to use subpages such as The Doctor's reality/Virgin reality etc.