The Doctor's death: Difference between revisions

From Tardis Wiki, the free Doctor Who reference
Tag: 2017 source edit
m (Upholding T:APOS)
 
(64 intermediate revisions by 18 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Update|This article needs to be updated to include details about the doctor's death in the newly-valid [[Death Comes to Time (webcast)]] in a section similar to [[#Parallel World (Turn Left)]]}}
{{first pic|OneLastTrip.jpg|The [[Eleventh Doctor]] enters [[the TARDIS]], he thinks, for the [[#Lake Silencio|last time]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[Closing Time (TV story)|Closing Time]]'')}}
{{first pic|OneLastTrip.jpg|The [[Eleventh Doctor]] enters [[the TARDIS]], he thinks, for the [[#Lake Silencio|last time]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[Closing Time (TV story)|Closing Time]]'')}}
{{Doctor more}}
{{Doctor more}}
{{big toc}}
{{big toc}}
Much like [[The Doctor's early life|their origin]], '''[[the Doctor]]'s [[death]]''' was a matter of conflicting accounts and [[alternate timeline]]s. ([[PROSE]]: ''[[Alien Bodies (novel)|Alien Bodies]]'', [[TV]]: ''[[The Impossible Astronaut (TV story)|The Impossible Astronaut]]'', ''[[The Name of the Doctor (TV story)|The Name of the Doctor]]'')
Much like [[The Doctor's early life|their origin]], '''[[the Doctor]]'s [[death]]''' was a matter of conflicting accounts and [[alternate timeline]]s. ([[PROSE]]: ''[[Alien Bodies (novel)|Alien Bodies]]'', [[TV]]: ''[[The Impossible Astronaut (TV story)|The Impossible Astronaut]]'', ''[[The Name of the Doctor (TV story)|The Name of the Doctor]]'') By some accounts, this occurred to [[the Doctor's final incarnation]] in most Doctors' relative future. ([[PROSE]]: ''[[Alien Bodies (novel)|Alien Bodies]]'')


==The Doctor's mortality==
== The Doctor's mortality ==
Through their ability to [[regenerate]], the Doctor was able to "cheat death" on numerous occasions. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Tenth Planet (TV story)|The Tenth Planet]]'', ''[[The Parting of the Ways (TV story)|The Parting of the Ways]]'') However, the [[Tenth Doctor]] noted that he could be killed without allowing for regeneration. ([[TV]]: ''[[The End of Time (TV story)|The End of Time]]'') As such, the Doctor was not truly [[immortal]], which the [[Fifth Doctor]] deemed impossible even for a [[Time Lord]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Five Doctors (TV story)|The Five Doctors]]'') Even allowing for regeneration, the Tenth Doctor regarded the change it entailed as a form of death. ([[TV]]: ''[[The End of Time (TV story)|The End of Time]]'')
Through their ability to [[regenerate]], the Doctor was able to "cheat death" on numerous occasions. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Tenth Planet (TV story)|The Tenth Planet]]'', ''[[The Parting of the Ways (TV story)|The Parting of the Ways]]'') However, the [[Tenth Doctor]] noted that he could be killed without allowing for regeneration. ([[TV]]: ''[[The End of Time (TV story)|The End of Time]]'') As such, the Doctor was not truly [[immortal]], which the [[Fifth Doctor]] deemed impossible even for a [[Time Lord]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Five Doctors (TV story)|The Five Doctors]]'') Even allowing for regeneration, the Tenth Doctor regarded the change it entailed as a form of death. ([[TV]]: ''[[The End of Time (TV story)|The End of Time]]'')


==Impact on the universe==
Visiting the [[Garden of Fond Memories]] on [[Necros]], the [[Sixth Doctor]] was shocked to find a [[statue]] made in his [[likeness]], which he took as evidence that he would die without regenerating. He noted to [[Peri Brown]] that, being a [[time travel]]ler, it was possible for them both to travel to a point after they had died. Peri, however, believed that the statue was a "[[joke]]" and a "[[gag]]", that someone was "having [him] on". To their shock, the statue fell on top of the Doctor, apparently crushing him, only for the Doctor to push aside the statue, finding that it was not genuine [[stone]] rather "an elaborate theatrical effect." The Doctor later determined that [[Davros]], who had masqueraded as the [[Great Healer]] of [[Necros]], was responsible for the statue; he complimented Davros on its "very good likeness" but added that "[he] really shouldn't have bothered." ([[TV]]: ''[[Revelation of the Daleks (TV story)|Revelation of the Daleks]]'')
{{simplequote|I never thought precognisance of my own death would be so disturbing.|[[Sixth Doctor]]|Revelation of the Daleks (TV story)}}
 
[[The Valeyard]] was introduced to the Sixth Doctor by {{Ainley}} as "an amalgamation of the darker sides of [his] nature, somewhere between [his] twelfth and final incarnation." ([[TV]]: ''[[The Ultimate Foe (TV story)|The Ultimate Foe]]'') In a story related by the Valeyard, the [[Hermit (Trial of the Valeyard)|thirteenth and final incarnation]] of the Doctor supposedly composed a [[The Doctor's Black Scrolls|set of scrolls]] which detailed his work to bypass the limit of twelve regenerations and that the Valeyard himself was created as a [[Time Tot]] on a mud planet orbiting [[Etarho]] as a result of the Doctor's experiments. The Valeyard's claim, however, was doubted by the Sixth Doctor. Indeed, the Doctor found what appeared to be his final incarnation on Etarho to have been the Valeyard masquerading as him. The Doctor later reflected that "[[the Matrix]] awaits us each and every Time Lord." ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Trial of the Valeyard (audio story)|Trial of the Valeyard]]'')
 
Following [[War Doctor|their forgotten ninth incarnation]] and an incident which saw the [[Tenth Doctor]] regenerate but keep the same [[face]], the [[incarnation]] who identified as the [[Eleventh Doctor]] emerged as the product of the Doctor's twelfth regeneration, the last of their original [[life cycle]], and so believed himself to be "the last Doctor" until the Time Lords enabled him to regenerate again. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Time of the Doctor (TV story)|The Time of the Doctor]]'', [[AUDIO]]: ''[[Regeneration Impossible (audio story)|Regeneration Impossible]]'') The [[Twelfth Doctor]], ([[TV]]: ''[[Kill the Moon (TV story)|Kill the Moon]]'') [[the Master]] ([[TV]]: ''[[The Doctor Falls (TV story)|The Doctor Falls]]'') and even [[Rassilon]] himself were uncertain as to how many regenerations the Doctor now possessed. ([[TV]]: ''[[Hell Bent (TV story)|Hell Bent]]'')
 
When the [[Thirteenth Doctor]] visited [[Daughter of Mine]] to free her from the [[mirror]] in which she was imprisoned, Daughter of Mine mentioned a [[The Doctor (Battlefield)|redheaded Doctor]] who "thought he was the last", which the present Doctor did not recognise. ([[WC]]: ''[[The Shadow in the Mirror (webcast)|The Shadow in the Mirror]]'') [[Time (mythology)|Time]] told the Doctor that she would not outrun her. Claiming that the Doctor's time was heading to its end, Time warned:
{{simplequote|Nothing is forever. No regeneration, no life.|Time.|The Vanquishers (TV story)}}<!--
-->
 
When the [[Eleventh Doctor]]'s [[timeline]] became distorted, [[the Curator]] was seen as one of his future incarnations, at the end of his lifespan opposite the [[First Doctor]]. ([[COMIC]]: ''[[The Then and the Now (comic story)|The Then and the Now]]'') However, the [[Thirteenth Doctor]] would make a [[Timeless Child|discovery]] which indicated that the First Doctor himself had followed [[The Doctor's early life|earlier lives]] that were struck from [[the Doctor's memories]]. ([[TV]]: {{cs|The Timeless Children (TV story)}})
 
== The Doctor on death ==
After [[the TARDIS]] became "stalled in the equivalent of a galactic lay-by", the [[Sixth Doctor]] had a worried thought of [[Peri Brown]] growing old and dying in the TARDIS, while he would "go on regenerating until all [his] lives [were] spent". ([[TV]]: ''[[Vengeance on Varos (TV story)|Vengeance on Varos]]'')
 
The [[War Doctor]], upon being warned by [[the Moment]] that there would be [[consequence]]s should he use her to destroy the [[Time Lord]]s and the [[Dalek]]s, told her that he had no [[desire]] to [[survival|survive]] the [[Time War]], to which she responded that the consequence would be that he would live. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Day of the Doctor (TV story)|The Day of the Doctor]]'')
 
Whilst facing the [[Gelth]] with [[Rose Tyler]], the [[Ninth Doctor]], recalling things he had seen and experienced, was openly disturbed at the prospect of dying "in a [[dungeon]] in [[Cardiff]]". ([[TV]]: ''[[The Unquiet Dead (TV story)|The Unquiet Dead]]'') Later, he accepted his death at the hands of the [[Dalek Emperor in the Last Great Time War|Dalek Emperor]]'s [[Daleks of human origin]], only to be saved by Rose as the [[Bad Wolf (entity)|Bad Wolf]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Parting of the Ways (TV story)|The Parting of the Ways]]'')
 
== Impact on the universe ==
Due to their impact on [[The Doctor's universe|the universe]], having "touched so many [[life|lives]]" and "saved so many [[people]]", the prospect of the Doctor's death would affect a great many people. Indeed, from an [[River Song's World|alternate reality]] in which [[River Song]] refused to kill the Doctor, [[news]] that the Doctor was dying led millions, all across [[time]] and [[space]], to offer their [[help]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Wedding of River Song (TV story)|The Wedding of River Song]]'') At the same time, [[Vislor Turlough]], [[companion]] to the [[Fifth Doctor]], noted that the Doctor had many [[enemy|enemies]] who would [[delight]] in his death, an observation which [[Kamelion]] concurred with. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Caves of Androzani (TV story)|The Caves of Androzani]]'') However, even {{Ainley}} once remarked that "a [[cosmos]] without the Doctor scarcely bears thinking about." ([[TV]]: ''[[The Five Doctors (TV story)|The Five Doctors]]'') Multiple occasions in which the Doctor was killed prematurely resulted in [[star]]s burning out across the universe. ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[The Furies (audio story)|The Furies]]'', [[TV]]: ''[[Turn Left (TV story)|Turn Left]]'', ''[[The Name of the Doctor (TV story)|The Name of the Doctor]]'')
Due to their impact on [[The Doctor's universe|the universe]], having "touched so many [[life|lives]]" and "saved so many [[people]]", the prospect of the Doctor's death would affect a great many people. Indeed, from an [[River Song's World|alternate reality]] in which [[River Song]] refused to kill the Doctor, [[news]] that the Doctor was dying led millions, all across [[time]] and [[space]], to offer their [[help]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Wedding of River Song (TV story)|The Wedding of River Song]]'') At the same time, [[Vislor Turlough]], [[companion]] to the [[Fifth Doctor]], noted that the Doctor had many [[enemy|enemies]] who would [[delight]] in his death, an observation which [[Kamelion]] concurred with. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Caves of Androzani (TV story)|The Caves of Androzani]]'') However, even {{Ainley}} once remarked that "a [[cosmos]] without the Doctor scarcely bears thinking about." ([[TV]]: ''[[The Five Doctors (TV story)|The Five Doctors]]'') Multiple occasions in which the Doctor was killed prematurely resulted in [[star]]s burning out across the universe. ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[The Furies (audio story)|The Furies]]'', [[TV]]: ''[[Turn Left (TV story)|Turn Left]]'', ''[[The Name of the Doctor (TV story)|The Name of the Doctor]]'')


The [[Twelfth Doctor]] himself, after spending some time resisting regenerating even it if meant his final death, ultimately conceded to [[the TARDIS]] that the "silly old universe" still needed saving and that "[they'd] get it all wrong without [them]." ([[TV]]: ''[[Twice Upon a Time (TV story)|Twice Upon a Time]]'')
Two companions of the [[Twelfth Doctor]], [[Bill Potts]] and [[Nardole]], came to believe it was the Doctor's actions that ensured good always triumphed over evil in the universe, meaning that the Doctor's possible death would have dire effects for the cosmos. ([[TV]]: ''[[Twice Upon a Time (TV story)|Twice Upon a Time]]'') Indeed, the [[Fourth Doctor]] knew that humanity was able to defeat the [[Dalek]]s on many occasions in part because of he and his other selves continued their interventions. ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Energy of the Daleks (audio story)|Energy of the Daleks]]'') The Twelfth Doctor acknowledged the danger of his [[first incarnation]] choosing to die before doing the things that he was "supposed to do" and, after spending some time resisting regenerating even it if meant his final death, ultimately conceded to [[the TARDIS]] that the "silly old universe" still needed saving and that "[they'd] get it all wrong without me." ([[TV]]: ''[[Twice Upon a Time (TV story)|Twice Upon a Time]]'')
 
In a possible future stemming from the [[Eighth Doctor]]'s life, ([[PROSE]]: ''[[The Tomorrow Windows (novel)|The Tomorrow Windows]]'') what appeared to be the final death of [[Twelfth Doctor (The Curse of Fatal Death)|an alternate Twelfth Doctor]] led [[the Master (The Curse of Fatal Death)|the Master]] and a [[Dalek spaceship (The Curse of Fatal Death)|ship]]ful of [[Dalek]]s, who were saved when the Doctor stopped their [[Zectronic Beam Controller]] from imploding, to openly renounce their [[evil]] ways. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Curse of Fatal Death (TV story)|The Curse of Fatal Death]]'')


In a dissenting account of the Doctor's lives following the [[Eighth Doctor]], what appeared to be the final death of the [[Twelfth Doctor (The Curse of Fatal Death)|Twelfth Doctor]] led [[the Master (The Curse of Fatal Death)|the Master]] and a [[Dalek spaceship (The Curse of Fatal Death)|ship]]ful of [[Dalek]]s, who were saved when the Doctor stopped their [[Zectronic Beam Controller]] from imploding, to openly renounce their [[evil]] ways. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Curse of Fatal Death (TV story)|The Curse of Fatal Death]]'')
==Impact on the TARDIS==
{{first pic|GiganTARDIS.jpg|In an alternate timeline, the Doctor's dying TARDIS served as his tomb. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Name of the Doctor (TV story)|The Name of the Doctor]]'')}}
Anticipating his death in [[Battle of the Game Station|battle]] against the [[Dalek]]s, the [[Ninth Doctor]] expected that [[the TARDIS]] would ultimately die without him, deeming that preferable to falling into Dalek hands. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Parting of the Ways (TV story)|The Parting of the Ways]]'') After the [[Tenth Doctor (Turn Left)|Tenth Doctor]] died in [[parallel world (Turn Left)|a parallel world]], [[Rose Tyler]] believed that the TARDIS was dying. ([[TV]]: ''[[Turn Left (TV story)|Turn Left]]'') Experiencing a [[Alternate timeline (The Name of the Doctor)|potential future]] in which he died on [[Trenzalore]], the [[Eleventh Doctor]] observed the future TARDIS's [[size leak]] to be a sign that it was dying. The Doctor identified that the TARDIS was now his [[tomb]], now containing [[The Doctor's time stream|his time stream]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Name of the Doctor (TV story)|The Name of the Doctor]]'')


== Impact on companions ==
== Impact on companions ==
=== Denial and regret ===
=== Denial and regret ===
[[Sarah Jane Smith]] tearfully urged the dying [[Third Doctor]] not to die. ([[TV]]: ''[[Planet of the Spiders (TV story)|Planet of the Spiders]]'') Later on, [[Rose Tyler]] tried to assert that the [[Tenth Doctor]] ''couldn't'' die, since she'd only just found him. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Stolen Earth (TV story)|The Stolen Earth]]'') Having been made aware of the [[prophecy]] which foretold the end of the Tenth Doctor, [[Wilfred Mott]] tearfully pleaded with the Doctor not to let himself die. ([[TV]]: ''[[The End of Time (TV story)|The End of Time]]'')
[[Bernice Summerfield]], who had previously travelled with the [[Seventh Doctor]], told the [[Eighth Doctor]] that, while he may change, he would never die. ([[PROSE]]: ''[[The Dying Days (novel)|The Dying Days]]'')
After the [[Twelfth Doctor]]'s [[#Close encounters|apparent death]], [[Bill Potts]] told him she'd never believe he was really dead, because "one day everyone's just going to need [him] too much." She brought him into [[the TARDIS]], as "the only place he'd rest in peace", if he could do that anywhere. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Doctor Falls (TV story)|The Doctor Falls]]'')
After the [[Twelfth Doctor]]'s [[#Close encounters|apparent death]], [[Bill Potts]] told him she'd never believe he was really dead, because "one day everyone's just going to need [him] too much." She brought him into [[the TARDIS]], as "the only place he'd rest in peace", if he could do that anywhere. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Doctor Falls (TV story)|The Doctor Falls]]'')


Line 28: Line 57:
== Death and regeneration ==
== Death and regeneration ==
=== Close encounters ===
=== Close encounters ===
[[File:FiveRegenerates.jpg|thumb|left|"[[Adric|Don't die, Doctor. The universe needs you.]]" ([[TV]]: ''[[The Caves of Androzani (TV story)|The Caves of Androzani]]'')]]
[[File:FiveRegenerates.jpg|thumb|left|The [[Fifth Doctor]] regenerates. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Caves of Androzani (TV story)|The Caves of Androzani]]'')]]
Before [[regenerating]], the [[Fifth Doctor]] said it seemed "different this time", and worried that he might actually die from the [[spectrox toxaemia]]. However, visions of his [[companion]]s urged him to go on. {{Ainley|c}}'s assertion that he must die stirred the Doctor to finally regenerate. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Caves of Androzani (TV story)|The Caves of Androzani]]'')
Before [[regenerating]], the [[Fifth Doctor]] said it seemed "different this time", and worried that he might actually die from the [[spectrox toxaemia]]. However, visions of his [[companion]]s urged him to go on. {{Ainley|c}}'s assertion that he must die stirred the Doctor to finally regenerate. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Caves of Androzani (TV story)|The Caves of Androzani]]'')


Similarly, the [[Twelfth Doctor]]'s delayed regeneration on board a [[Mondasian colony ship]] caused [[Bill Potts]] to believe he died. Bill and [[Heather (The Pilot)|Heather]] brought him into [[the TARDIS]], and the Twelfth Doctor had visions of past companions saying his name. On hearing {{Gomez}}'s voice, he awoke and began the process, ([[TV]]: ''[[The Doctor Falls (TV story)|The Doctor Falls]]'') though it took an encounter with the [[First Doctor]] to convince him to finally allow himself to change. ([[TV]]: ''[[Twice Upon a Time (TV story)|Twice Upon a Time]]'')
According to one account, a [[Twelfth Doctor (The Curse of Fatal Death)|Twelfth Doctor]] believed that exposure to a [[zectronic beam]] had destroyed his ability to regenerate, anticipating his final death. However, in a feat which [[the Master (The Curse of Fatal Death)|the Master]] deemed to be impossible, he nevertheless regenerated into the [[Thirteenth Doctor (The Curse of Fatal Death)|Thirteenth Doctor]], with [[Emma (The Curse of Fatal Death)|Emma]] supposing that "maybe even the universe can't bear to be without the Doctor." ([[TV]]: ''[[The Curse of Fatal Death (TV story)|The Curse of Fatal Death]]'')
 
=== Complete death ===
{{video|Seventh Doctor Regenerates - Sylvester McCoy to Paul McGann - Doctor Who The Movie - BBC|thumb|Inside the [[morgue]], the [[Eighth Doctor]] finally takes his first [[breath]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[Doctor Who (TV story)|Doctor Who]]'')}}
The [[Eighth Doctor]] was nearly unique amongst his other [[incarnation]]s in that he was technically dead both when he regenerated from the [[Seventh Doctor]] and when he regenerated into [[The Doctor's ninth incarnation|his successor]]. Following a non-fatal shooting, the Seventh Doctor was taken to a [[San Francisco]] [[hospital]], where subsequent exploratory [[surgery]] by [[Grace Holloway]] with a [[camera]] accidentally clogged a [[vein]]; the [[anaesthetic]] he had been given delayed regeneration for several [[hour]]s and almost destroyed the process. ([[TV]]: ''[[Doctor Who (TV story)|Doctor Who]]'') The Eighth Doctor himself died aboard [[Cass Fermazzi's gunship]] when it crash-landed on [[Karn]], but was resurrected for four [[minute]]s by the [[Sisterhood of Karn]], enabling him to regenerate into the [[War Doctor]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Night of the Doctor (TV story)|The Night of the Doctor]]'')
 
After beginning to regenerate on a [[Mondasian colony ship]], the [[Twelfth Doctor]] declared that he didn't want to go on, telling his would-be successor to "let go" and interrupting the regenerative process by triggering a huge [[explosion]], killing himself in the process. [[Bill Potts]] found his body, and, with [[Heather (The Pilot)|Heather]]'s help, brought him back to [[the TARDIS]], believing it to be "the only place he'd rest in peace, if there's any place he'd do that". However, before saying her final goodbyes, Bill (now made of [[sentient oil]] like Heather), left him one of her [[tear]]s, stating that "where there's tears, there's hope". After Bill and Heather left, the tear reignited a small burst of regeneration energy; awakening, the Twelfth Doctor had visions of past companions saying his name, and on hearing [[Missy]]'s voice, he awoke and began regenerating in earnest again. He halted it again through sheer willpower, ([[TV]]: ''[[The Doctor Falls (TV story)|The Doctor Falls]]'') entering a [[state of grace]] during which he was restored to full health but had a short window of time in which to decide whether to let himself die as he was, or let himself regenerate completely into a [[Thirteenth Doctor|new Doctor]]. After an encounter with the [[First Doctor]] and the [[Testimony Foundation]]'s "ghosts" of his last few [[companion]]s, as well as input from the TARDIS herself, he finally allowed himself to regenerate. ([[TV]]: ''[[Twice Upon a Time (TV story)|Twice Upon a Time]]'')


According to another account, a [[Twelfth Doctor (The Curse of Fatal Death)|Twelfth Doctor]] believed that exposure to a [[zectronic beam]] had destroyed his ability to regenerate, anticipating his final death. However, in a feat which [[the Master (The Curse of Fatal Death)|the Master]] deemed to be impossible, he nevertheless regenerated into the [[Thirteenth Doctor (The Curse of Fatal Death)|Thirteenth Doctor]], with [[Emma (The Curse of Fatal Death)|Emma]] supposing that "maybe even the universe can't bear to be without the Doctor." ([[TV]]: ''[[The Curse of Fatal Death (TV story)|The Curse of Fatal Death]]'')
== Myths ==
[[We Killed the Doctor Dead!|"We Killed the Doctor Dead!"]] was a [[song]] sung by the [[Scorchie]] [[Mr Grizzfizzle]], with [[Cool Cat]] and the [[Magic Mice]] doing backup. Through this song they informed [[Jo Grant]] that they killed the [[Third Doctor]]. The song was reprised when the Scorchies discovered that the Doctor was not dead. ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[The Scorchies (audio story)|The Scorchies]]'')


=== Complete death ===
== Ubankan ship ==
[[File:Seventh Doctor Regenerates - Sylvester McCoy to Paul McGann - Doctor Who The Movie - BBC|thumb|Inside the [[morgue]], the [[Eighth Doctor]] finally takes his first [[breath]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[Doctor Who (TV story)|Doctor Who]]'')]]
According to one account, at some point between his flight from Gallifrey and his first confrontation with [[Omega]], the Doctor was fated to die in the void of space near a [[Ubankan ship]], trying and failing to reach his TARDIS before he asphyxiated. Because he wished for the Doctor to be available at a later point to the [[White Guardian]] as a pawn in the quest for the [[Key to Time]], [[God (mythology)|God]] allowed him to miraculously survive, sending him a bubble of air. ([[PROSE]]: ''[[Power to the People (short story)|Power to the People]]'')
The [[Eighth Doctor]] was unique amongst his other [[incarnation]]s in that he was technically dead both when he regenerated from the [[Seventh Doctor]] and when he regenerated into [[The Doctor's ninth incarnation|his successor incarnation]]. Following a non-fatal shooting, the Seventh Doctor was taken to a [[San Francisco]] [[hospital]], where subsequent exploratory [[surgery]] by [[Grace Holloway]] with a [[camera]] accidentally clogged a [[vein]]; the [[anaesthetic]] he had been given delayed regeneration for several [[hour]]s and almost destroyed the process. ([[TV]]: ''[[Doctor Who (TV story)|Doctor Who]]'') The Eighth Doctor himself died aboard [[Cass Fermazzi's gunship]] when it crash-landed on [[Karn]], but was resurrected for four [[minute]]s by the [[Sisterhood of Karn]], enabling him to regenerate into the [[War Doctor]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Night of the Doctor (TV story)|The Night of the Doctor]]'')


== War in Heaven ==
== War in Heaven ==
Line 47: Line 82:
== Lake Silencio ==
== Lake Silencio ==
{{first pic|Death of the Doctor.jpg|The [[Eleventh Doctor]] was seemingly killed at [[Lake Silencio]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Impossible Astronaut (TV story)|The Impossible Astronaut]]'')}}
{{first pic|Death of the Doctor.jpg|The [[Eleventh Doctor]] was seemingly killed at [[Lake Silencio]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Impossible Astronaut (TV story)|The Impossible Astronaut]]'')}}
It was a matter of historical record that the [[Eleventh Doctor]] was [[kill]]ed at [[Lake Silencio]], [[Utah]] on the [[planet]] [[Earth]] at 5:02 PM on [[22 April]] [[2011]] at the hands of [[River Song]], [[born]] Melody Pond. Knowing this, the [[crew]] of the ''[[Teselecta]]'', a [[ship]] of the [[Justice Department]] which operated to inflict "[[hell]]" on unpunished [[criminal]]s, deviated from their mission to punish [[Adolf Hitler]] when they discovered River. It was through this encounter that a younger version of the Eleventh Doctor became aware of his recorded death. ([[TV]]: ''[[Let's Kill Hitler (TV story)|Let's Kill Hitler]]'')
Even on pre-[[Time War]] [[Gallifrey]], ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Songs of Love (audio story)|Songs of Love]]'') it was a matter of historical record that the [[Eleventh Doctor]] was [[kill]]ed at [[Lake Silencio]], [[Utah]] on the [[planet]] [[Earth]] at 5:02 PM on [[22 April]] [[2011]] at the hands of [[River Song]], [[born]] Melody Pond. Knowing this, the [[crew]] of the ''[[Teselecta]]'', a [[ship]] of the [[Justice Department]] which operated to inflict "[[hell]]" on unpunished [[criminal]]s, deviated from their mission to punish [[Adolf Hitler]] when they discovered River. It was through this encounter that a younger version of the Eleventh Doctor became aware of his recorded death. ([[TV]]: ''[[Let's Kill Hitler (TV story)|Let's Kill Hitler]]'')


Though at first the Doctor was willing to accept his coming death, ([[TV]]: ''[[Closing Time (TV story)|Closing Time]]'') he later found a way around this [[fixed point in time]] by asking the ''Teselecta'' crew for help. To preserve [[history]], the ''Teselecta'' took on the form of the Eleventh Doctor, taking his place in the events to follow. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Wedding of River Song (TV story)|The Wedding of River Song]]'') River Song was procured by the [[Kovarian Chapter]] of [[the Silence]], and placed in a [[space suit]] beneath Lake Silencio, ([[TV]]: ''[[Closing Time (TV story)|Closing Time]]'') where she would be made to shoot the Doctor, causing a brief [[regeneration]] before cutting this short with her second blast. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Impossible Astronaut (TV story)|The Impossible Astronaut]]'')
Though at first the Doctor was willing to accept his coming death, ([[TV]]: ''[[Closing Time (TV story)|Closing Time]]'') he later found a way around this [[fixed point in time]] by asking the ''Teselecta'' crew for help. To preserve [[history]], the ''Teselecta'' took on the form of the Eleventh Doctor, taking his place in the events to follow. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Wedding of River Song (TV story)|The Wedding of River Song]]'') River Song was procured by the [[Kovarian Chapter]] of [[the Silence]], and placed in a [[space suit]] beneath Lake Silencio, ([[TV]]: ''[[Closing Time (TV story)|Closing Time]]'') where she would be made to shoot the Doctor, causing a brief [[regeneration]] before cutting this short with her second blast. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Impossible Astronaut (TV story)|The Impossible Astronaut]]'')


=== River Song's World ===
=== River Song's World ===
In a new [[timeline]], River Song refused to play her part, creating an unstable [[River Song's World|alternate reality]] in which all of [[Earth]]'s [[history]] took place at once. On discovering that the Eleventh Doctor was safe on board the ''Teselecta'', however, during her [[wedding]] with the Doctor, River initiated contact with him again, allowing time to continue, as it had before. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Wedding of River Song (TV story)|The Wedding of River Song]]'') Afterwards, [[River Song]] was imprisoned at the [[Stormcage Containment Facility]], on charges of [[murder]], ([[TV]]: ''[[Flesh and Stone (TV story)|Flesh and Stone]]'') for having "killed" the Doctor. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Wedding of River Song (TV story)|The Wedding of River Song]]'') She went on many adventures with the Doctor during her [[prisoner|imprisonment]], ([[HOMEVID]]: ''[[First Night (home video)|First Night]]'', ''[[Last Night (home video)|Last Night]]'') and became known for escaping, ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[The Bekdel Test (audio story)|The Bekdel Test]]'') though she always returned in the end, to serve her [[sentence]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[A Good Man Goes to War (TV story)|A Good Man Goes to War]]'') During an adventure with a younger Doctor, River [[spoiler|refused]] to reveal the name of the man she'd killed. ([[TV]]: ''[[Flesh and Stone (TV story)|Flesh and Stone]]'')
In a new [[timeline]], River Song refused to play her part, creating an unstable [[River Song's World|alternate reality]] in which all of [[Earth]]'s [[history]] took place at once. On discovering that the Eleventh Doctor was safe on board the ''Teselecta'', however, during her [[wedding]] with the Doctor, River initiated contact with him again, allowing time to continue, as it had before. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Wedding of River Song (TV story)|The Wedding of River Song]]'') Afterwards, [[River Song]] was imprisoned at the [[Stormcage Containment Facility]], on charges of [[murder]], ([[TV]]: ''[[Flesh and Stone (TV story)|Flesh and Stone]]'') for having "killed" the Doctor. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Wedding of River Song (TV story)|The Wedding of River Song]]'') She went on many adventures with the Doctor during her [[prisoner|imprisonment]], ([[HOMEVID]]: ''[[First Night (home video)|First Night]]'', ''[[Last Night (home video)|Last Night]]'') and became known for escaping, ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[The Bekdel Test (audio story)|The Bekdel Test]]'') though she always returned in the end, to serve her [[sentence]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[A Good Man Goes to War (TV story)|A Good Man Goes to War]]'') [[Missy]] was among those who believed the Doctor to be dead, and so claimed herself to be the last living Time Lord in the universe before she met River and learnt that the Doctor had survived, ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[The Bekdel Test (audio story)|The Bekdel Test]]'') coming to realise that he was responsible for [[Fall of Gallifrey|saving her]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[Death in Heaven (TV story)|Death in Heaven]]'') During an adventure with a younger Doctor, River [[spoiler|refused]] to reveal the name of the man she'd killed. ([[TV]]: ''[[Flesh and Stone (TV story)|Flesh and Stone]]'')


River Song was later released, since it seemed the man she killed had never existed, when the Eleventh Doctor expunged [[the Doctor's name|his name]] from all records. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Angels Take Manhattan (TV story)|The Angels Take Manhattan]]'')
River Song was later released, since it seemed the man she killed had never existed, when the Eleventh Doctor expunged any details about himself from all records. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Angels Take Manhattan (TV story)|The Angels Take Manhattan]]'')


== Trenzalore ==
== Trenzalore ==
Line 61: Line 96:


[[File:Trenzalore Alternate Timeline.jpg|thumb|The Doctor arrives on Trenzalore. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Name of the Doctor (TV story)|The Name of the Doctor]]'')]]
[[File:Trenzalore Alternate Timeline.jpg|thumb|The Doctor arrives on Trenzalore. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Name of the Doctor (TV story)|The Name of the Doctor]]'')]]
In a confrontation with the Doctor and [[Clara Oswald]], the [[Great Intelligence]] entered [[the Doctor's time stream]] in the Doctor's tomb, which he used to attack his entire [[timeline]], turning all his [[victory|victories]] into [[defeat]]s. As a result, the Doctor was, as [[Vastra]] put it, "dying all at once", including as the [[Fifth Doctor]] on [[Androzani]] and as the Eleventh Doctor in the [[Dalek Asylum]]. These deaths were averted when Clara herself entered the time stream, splintering herself into [[Clara Oswald's splinters|echoes]] who saved the Doctor, across [[The Doctor#Incarnations|all known incarnations]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Name of the Doctor (TV story)|The Name of the Doctor]]'')
In a confrontation with the Doctor and [[Clara Oswald]], the [[Great Intelligence]] entered [[the Doctor's time stream]] in the Doctor's tomb, which he used to attack his entire [[timeline]], turning all his [[victory|victories]] into [[defeat]]s. As a result, the Doctor was, as [[Vastra]] put it, "dying all at once", including as the [[Fifth Doctor]] on [[Androzani]] and as the Eleventh Doctor in the [[Dalek Asylum]]. These deaths were averted when Clara herself entered the time stream, splintering herself into [[Clara Oswald splinter|echoes]] who saved the Doctor, across [[The Doctor#Incarnations|all known incarnations]]. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Name of the Doctor (TV story)|The Name of the Doctor]]'')


=== New timeline ===
=== New timeline ===
Line 67: Line 102:


== Alternate realities ==
== Alternate realities ==
When [[the TARDIS]] crashed on [[Tick-Tock World]], the [[First Doctor]], along with [[Ian Chesterton]] and [[Barbara Wright]], were devoured by the [[Xesto]], creatures that consumed time and all possible futures. He then woke up in a dream-like dimension, encountering other alternative outcomes of how he could have been devoured. A woman helped him to make contact with [[Susan Foreman|Susan]], as the state of "death" on the planet meant someone would be disposed outside time itself. As he was fading away, he realised the woman was an older version of his granddaughter, and he persuaded the younger Susan to touch her older self. Their violation of the [[Blinovitch Limitation Effect]] caused an explosion which allowed the older Susan to avert the original crash, by having her original self to suggest her grandfather to shut down the defence systems of the ship. ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Tick-Tock World (audio story)|Tick-Tock World]]'')
In an [[Silurian Earth|alternate timeline]] created by {{Champion}} using the [[Chronovore]] [[Artemis (No Future)|Artemis]], ([[PROSE]]: ''[[No Future (novel)|No Future]]'') the [[Third Doctor (Silurian Earth)|Third Doctor]] was killed by [[Morka]] during his confrontation with the [[Silurian]]s, resulting in humanity being decimated as the Silurians attempted to return Earth to its original state. ([[PROSE]]: ''[[Blood Heat (novel)|Blood Heat]]'')
In an [[Silurian Earth|alternate timeline]] created by {{Champion}} using the [[Chronovore]] [[Artemis (No Future)|Artemis]], ([[PROSE]]: ''[[No Future (novel)|No Future]]'') the [[Third Doctor (Silurian Earth)|Third Doctor]] was killed by [[Morka]] during his confrontation with the [[Silurian]]s, resulting in humanity being decimated as the Silurians attempted to return Earth to its original state. ([[PROSE]]: ''[[Blood Heat (novel)|Blood Heat]]'')


As the [[Lord of the Manor]], a future version of the [[Fifth Doctor]] who had lived somewhere between 100,000 and a million years, ruling over [[Stockbridge]], the Doctor finally died when the original Doctor collapsed the [[time bubble]] in which the town had been contained. ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[The Eternal Summer (audio story)|The Eternal Summer]]'')
As the [[Lord of the Manor]], a future version of the [[Fifth Doctor]] who had lived somewhere between 100,000 and a million years, ruling over [[Stockbridge]], the Doctor finally died when the original Doctor collapsed the [[time bubble]] in which the town had been contained. ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[The Eternal Summer (audio story)|The Eternal Summer]]'')
In a timeline where a [[Dalek]] invasion of Earth in [[1903]] was thwarted by the [[Sixth Doctor]] and [[Evelyn Smythe]], the [[British government]] trapped the Doctor in the [[Tower of London]] along with the two surviving Daleks to keep him as a symbol of their victory, cutting off his legs in order to keep him trapped. Driven insane over the years, the Doctor sometimes spoke to hallucinations of Evelyn after she died of old age, not even fully aware when a younger Evelyn came to see him in the Tower. He was eventually exterminated by the [[Dalek (Jubilee)|last surviving Dalek]] when it came to ask him for orders as it didn't know what else to do with itself. ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Jubilee (audio story)|Jubilee]]'')


When [[Rose Tyler]] changed history by saving the life of her [[father]], [[Pete Tyler]], [[Reaper]]s appeared and consumed the [[Ninth Doctor]] as he tried to protect his [[human]] company. Exclaiming that the Doctor was dead, Rose blamed herself. However, Pete gave his life to stop the Reapers by stepping in front of the [[car]] that killed him, resulting in the return of the Doctor along with everyone else the Reapers had consumed. ([[TV]]: ''[[Father's Day (TV story)|Father's Day]]'')
When [[Rose Tyler]] changed history by saving the life of her [[father]], [[Pete Tyler]], [[Reaper]]s appeared and consumed the [[Ninth Doctor]] as he tried to protect his [[human]] company. Exclaiming that the Doctor was dead, Rose blamed herself. However, Pete gave his life to stop the Reapers by stepping in front of the [[car]] that killed him, resulting in the return of the Doctor along with everyone else the Reapers had consumed. ([[TV]]: ''[[Father's Day (TV story)|Father's Day]]'')


=== Donna's World ===
In an aborted timeline, {{Simm}} claimed he had killed the [[Thirteenth Doctor]] by throwing her into the heart of a [[star]], after she escaped from being shackled in its orbit. ([[AUDIO]]:''[[Masterful (audio story)| Masterful]]'')
 
In the final [[minute]]s of [[31 December]] [[2021]], the Doctor was exterminated by [[Dalek Executioner]]s. Due to a temporary [[time loop]] created by the TARDIS, she was exterminated and brought back multiple times before managing to survive and destroy the Daleks. ([[TV]]: ''[[Eve of the Daleks (TV story)|Eve of the Daleks]]'')
 
=== Parallel World (''Turn Left'') ===
[[File:The Doctor is dead.jpg|thumb|Without Donna Noble, the Doctor's confrontation with the Racnoss ended in his death. ([[TV]]: ''[[Turn Left (TV story)|Turn Left]]'')]]
[[File:The Doctor is dead.jpg|thumb|Without Donna Noble, the Doctor's confrontation with the Racnoss ended in his death. ([[TV]]: ''[[Turn Left (TV story)|Turn Left]]'')]]
[[Donna's World]] was a parallel universe created when a [[fortune teller (Turn Left)|fortune teller]] fitted a [[Time Beetle]] of the [[Trickster's Brigade]] to [[Donna Noble]], [[companion]] of the [[Tenth Doctor]], changing her past so that on one day she turned right rather than left. The ensuing chain of events meant that she never met the Doctor and so was not there to stop him when he drowned the [[Racnoss]], resulting in him dying with them before he could regenerate, his body being retrieved by [[UNIT]] along with [[the TARDIS]]. In the following years, the Earth was devastated by [[alien invasion]]s which the Doctor would have stopped. Allies of the Doctor, both those he had met and those he would have met, opposed these incursions in his stead but most of them were killed. Eventually, the [[star]]s themselves began to go out, a result of the [[reality bomb]]. [[Rose Tyler]], a former companion who returned from [[Pete's World]], came to Donna and saw that she was sent back in time using what remained of the TARDIS, which she believed to be dying. Donna herself gave her life so that her past self would be forced to turn left, thus correcting history. ([[TV]]: ''[[Turn Left (TV story)|Turn Left]]'')
[[parallel world (Turn Left)|A parallel world]] was created when a [[fortune teller (Turn Left)|fortune teller]] fitted a [[Time Beetle]] of the [[Trickster's Brigade]] to [[Donna Noble]], [[companion]] of the [[Tenth Doctor]], changing her past so that on one day she turned right rather than left. The ensuing chain of events meant that she never met the Doctor and so was not there to stop him when he drowned the [[Racnoss]], resulting in him dying with them before he could regenerate, his body being retrieved by [[UNIT]] along with [[the TARDIS]]. In the following years, the Earth was devastated by [[alien invasion]]s which the Doctor would have stopped. Allies of the Doctor, both those he had met and those he would have met, opposed these incursions in his stead but most of them were killed. Eventually, the [[star]]s themselves began to go out, a result of the [[reality bomb]]. [[Rose Tyler]], a former companion who returned from [[Pete's World]], came to Donna and saw that she was sent back in time using what remained of the TARDIS, which she believed to be dying. Donna herself gave her life so that her past self would be forced to turn left, thus correcting history. ([[TV]]: ''[[Turn Left (TV story)|Turn Left]]'')


=== Other universes and dimensions ===
=== Other universes and dimensions ===
[[File:Raxacoricofallapatorian in Four Doctors.jpg|thumb|The death of the "Time Lord Victorious". ([[COMIC]]: ''[[Four Doctors (comic story)|Four Doctors]]'')]]
In one [[parallel universe (Full Fathom Five)|parallel universe]], [[Ruth Mills]] knew about [[the Doctor (Full Fathom Five)|the Doctor]]'s [[life cycle|regeneration limit]]. She forced him to regenerate into a [[New Doctor (Full Fathom Five)|new incarnation]], then killed him too, musing about how many times she'd have to do this before the Doctor was dead. ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Full Fathom Five (audio story)|Full Fathom Five]]'')
In one [[parallel universe (Full Fathom Five)|parallel universe]], [[Ruth Mills]] knew about [[the Doctor (Full Fathom Five)|the Doctor]]'s [[life cycle|regeneration limit]]. She forced him to regenerate into a [[New Doctor (Full Fathom Five)|new incarnation]], then killed him too, musing about how many times she'd have to do this before the Doctor was dead. ([[AUDIO]]: ''[[Full Fathom Five (audio story)|Full Fathom Five]]'')


==Duplicates==
In [[alternate timelines (Four Doctors)|a timeline]] created by a [[continuity bomb]] where the [[Tenth Doctor]] embraced the title of "[[Time Lord Victorious]]" and became a mad [[tyrant]] who ruled over time and space, a [[Raxacoricofallapatorian (Four Doctors)|Raxacoricofallapatorian]] shot him dead without regeneration. ([[COMIC]]: ''[[Four Doctors (comic story)|Four Doctors]]'')
 
== Duplicates ==
The [[Eleventh Doctor]]'s [[Eleventh Doctor (Ganger)|Ganger]] sacrificed himself and [[Miranda Cleaves (Ganger)|Ganger Miranda]] to stop [[Jennifer Lucas (Ganger)|Ganger Jennifer]], setting the [[the Doctor's sonic screwdriver|sonic screwdriver]] to a frequency that would cause the Flesh to collapse, in full knowledge that this would destroy him too so that the others would be encouraged to negotiate better conditions for the Gangers. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Almost People (TV story)|The Almost People]]'')
The [[Eleventh Doctor]]'s [[Eleventh Doctor (Ganger)|Ganger]] sacrificed himself and [[Miranda Cleaves (Ganger)|Ganger Miranda]] to stop [[Jennifer Lucas (Ganger)|Ganger Jennifer]], setting the [[the Doctor's sonic screwdriver|sonic screwdriver]] to a frequency that would cause the Flesh to collapse, in full knowledge that this would destroy him too so that the others would be encouraged to negotiate better conditions for the Gangers. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Almost People (TV story)|The Almost People]]'')


== Behind the scenes ==
== Behind the scenes ==
=== Meta-narrative ===
=== Meta-narrative ===
Many commentators have pointed out that [[regeneration]] was introduced to recast [[William Hartnell]] because if the Doctor ever died, "the show would end."<ref>{{cite web|url=https://edwardianadventurer.wordpress.com/tag/eleventh-doctor/|title=50th Anniversary Blues|author=King, S.W.|date of source=4 May 2013|website name=The Edwardian Adventurer|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref><ref>A.B., Digital Spy Forum. ''Twelfth Night: Adventures in Time and Space with Peter Capaldi''. Edited by Andrew O'Day.</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Fridge/DoctorWhoMeta|title=Fridge / Doctor Who – Meta|author=Several authors|website name=TV Tropes|accessdate=12 January 2022<!--If anything changes, I've made an archive here: https://web.archive.org/web/20220113044819/https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Fridge/DoctorWhoMeta-->}}</ref> This was what [[Steven Moffat]] has called "a clever way to solve a staffing problem"<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.undertheradarmag.com/interviews/steven_moffat_interview_072008/|title=Doctor Who's New Showrunner Remains Tightlipped|author=Redfern, Mark|date of source=1 July 2008|website name=Under The Radar Magazine|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref>. This narrative technique is what has allowed the character of [[the Doctor]] to survive through {{age|1963|11|23}} years of [[television]] history, shaking up the core dynamic of the series each time a [[List of actors to have played the Doctor|new lead actor]] is cast, rather than ending when the core cast has left, as many other series do.
Many commentators have pointed out that [[regeneration]] was introduced to recast [[William Hartnell]] because if the Doctor ever died, "the show would end."<ref>{{cite web|url=https://edwardianadventurer.wordpress.com/tag/eleventh-doctor/|title=50th Anniversary Blues|author=King, S.W.|date of source=4 May 2013|website name=The Edwardian Adventurer|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref><ref>A.B., Digital Spy Forum. ''Twelfth Night: Adventures in Time and Space with Peter Capaldi''. Edited by Andrew O'Day.</ref><ref>{{cite web|url=https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Fridge/DoctorWhoMeta|title=Fridge / Doctor Who – Meta|author=Several authors|website name=TV Tropes|accessdate=12 January 2022<!--If anything changes, I've made an archive here: https://web.archive.org/web/20220113044819/https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Fridge/DoctorWhoMeta-->}}</ref> This was what [[Steven Moffat]] has called "a clever way to solve a staffing problem"<ref>{{cite web|url=http://www.undertheradarmag.com/interviews/steven_moffat_interview_072008/|title=Doctor Who's New Showrunner Remains Tightlipped|author=Redfern, Mark|date of source=1 July 2008|website name=Under The Radar Magazine|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref>. This narrative technique is what has allowed the character of [[the Doctor]] to survive through {{age|1963|11|23}} years of [[television]] history, shaking up the core dynamic of the series each time a [[List of Doctor Who cast members|new lead actor]] is cast, rather than ending when the core cast has left, as many other series do.


However, this same problem has caused problems for {{w|suspension of disbelief}}. For example, [[TV]]: ''[[The Impossible Astronaut (TV story)|The Impossible Astronaut]]'' sets up the expectation that the [[Eleventh Doctor]] will die in the [[The Wedding of River Song (TV story)|series finale]]. Though this left fans speculating about how the Doctor will evade death ''this'' time — with theories ranging from "[[Eleventh Doctor (Ganger)|the Doctor used his Ganger]]"<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.denofgeek.com/tv/doctor-who-series-6-the-loose-threads-still-to-resolve-2/|title=Doctor Who series 6: the loose threads still to resolve|author=Brew, Simon|date of source=6 June 2011|website name=Den of Geek|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref> to "the Doctor we've been following ''is'' the [[Ganger]]"<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.cbr.com/doctor-who-season-6-5-things-to-remember-about-the-story-so-far/|title=Doctor Who Season 6: 5 Things To Remember About The Story So Far|author=McMillan, Graeme|date of source=27 August 2011|website name=CBR|date of source=12 January 2022}}</ref> — the weight of the Doctor's true, final end would act on no one, because, to anyone engaging with the material, the Doctor's death could only spell one thing: the end of the programme.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://reprog.wordpress.com/2011/04/29/a-spoileriffic-doctor-who-question/|author=Several authors|title=Responses to "A spoileriffic Doctor Who question"|date of source=29 April 2011|website name=The Reinvigorated Programmer|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref>
However, this same problem has caused problems for {{w|suspension of disbelief}}. For example, [[TV]]: ''[[The Impossible Astronaut (TV story)|The Impossible Astronaut]]'' sets up the expectation that the [[Eleventh Doctor]] will die in the [[The Wedding of River Song (TV story)|series finale]]. Though this left fans speculating about how the Doctor will evade death ''this'' time — with theories ranging from "[[Eleventh Doctor (Ganger)|the Doctor used his Ganger]]"<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.denofgeek.com/tv/doctor-who-series-6-the-loose-threads-still-to-resolve-2/|title=Doctor Who series 6: the loose threads still to resolve|author=Brew, Simon|date of source=6 June 2011|website name=Den of Geek|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref> to "the Doctor we've been following ''is'' the [[Ganger]]"<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.cbr.com/doctor-who-season-6-5-things-to-remember-about-the-story-so-far/|title=Doctor Who Season 6: 5 Things To Remember About The Story So Far|author=McMillan, Graeme|date of source=27 August 2011|website name=CBR|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref> — the weight of the Doctor's true, final end would act on no one, because, to anyone engaging with the material, the Doctor's death could only spell one thing: the end of the programme.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://reprog.wordpress.com/2011/04/29/a-spoileriffic-doctor-who-question/|author=Several authors|title=Responses to "A spoileriffic Doctor Who question"|date of source=29 April 2011|website name=The Reinvigorated Programmer|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref>


=== Sensationalism ===
=== Sensationalism ===
[[File:ROTD greeneyestalk.jpg|thumb|''[[Remembrance of the Daleks (TV story)|Remembrance of the Daleks]]'' ended its first episode with the [[Seventh Doctor]] at the mercy of a [[Dalek]].]]
The Doctor's death was teased by the title of the fifth episode of ''[[The Chase (TV story)|The Chase]]'', "The Death of Doctor Who", which ultimately referred to the destruction of the [[First Doctor]]'s [[Robot Doctor|robotic duplicate]]. Years later, the [[Eleventh Doctor]] made his appearance in ''[[The Sarah Jane Adventures]]'' story ''[[Death of the Doctor (TV story)|Death of the Doctor]]'', which featured his staged funeral.
The Doctor's death was teased by the title of the fifth episode of ''[[The Chase (TV story)|The Chase]]'', "The Death of Doctor Who", which ultimately referred to the destruction of the [[First Doctor]]'s [[Robot Doctor|robotic duplicate]]. Years later, the [[Eleventh Doctor]] made his appearance in ''[[The Sarah Jane Adventures]]'' story ''[[Death of the Doctor (TV story)|Death of the Doctor]]'', which featured his staged funeral.
Numerous [[cliffhanger]]s have shown the Doctor to be on the brink of death or even seemingly killed, only for them to escape. For instance, the first episode of ''[[Revelation of the Daleks (TV story)|Revelation of the Daleks]]'' has the [[Sixth Doctor]] apparently crushed by a [[memorial]] [[statue]] made in his likeness, only for the next episode to open with him pushing aside the fake statue. ''[[Aliens of London (TV story)|Aliens of London]]'' ends with the [[Ninth Doctor]] among those  who are subjected to a fatal [[electric]] shock by the [[Slitheen]], then ''[[World War Three (TV story)|World War Three]]'' opens with the Doctor surviving due to his [[Gallifreyan physiology|non-human physiology]]. Controversially, the "Next Time" trailer for ''World War Three'' revealed the Doctor's survival immediately following ''Aliens of London's'' cliffhanger; later trailers would be placed following the closing credits. This trend is even poked fun at in-universe in ''[[Hell Bent (TV story)|Hell Bent]]'', where the [[Twelfth Doctor]] interrupts his own [[story]] at a point where he has supposedly been shot by [[Rassilon (Hell Bent)|Rassilon]]'s [[firing squad]], to which [[Clara Oswald]] remarks "you like a cliffhanger, don't you."


=== Regeneration limit ===
=== Regeneration limit ===
The 1976 serial [[TV]]: ''[[The Deadly Assassin (TV story)|The Deadly Assassin]]'' set a challenge in establishing that [[Time Lord]] have a [[regeneration]] limit of 13 incarnations. [[The Valeyard]] would later be introduced in [[TV]]: ''[[The Mysterious Planet (TV story)|The Mysterious Planet]]'' as a manifestation of the Doctor from "between his twelfth and final incarnations." Some readers have determined, as a result, that the [[The Doctor (Alien Bodies)|final Doctor]] seen in [[PROSE]]: ''[[Alien Bodies (novel)|Alien Bodies]]'' would be the [[Thirteenth Doctor]], having used up his incarnations by the time of [[War in Heaven|the War]].<ref>{{cite web|url=https://mysite.science.uottawa.ca/rsmith43/cloister/goth.htm|author=Wilson, Anthony|website name=The Cloister Library|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref>
[[File:RegenEnergyTOTD.jpg|thumb|"Regeneration number thirteen" indefinitely expanded the lifespan of the Doctor and the series. ([[TV]]: ''[[The Time of the Doctor (TV story)|The Time of the Doctor]]'')]]
The 1976 serial [[TV]]: ''[[The Deadly Assassin (TV story)|The Deadly Assassin]]'' set a challenge in establishing that [[Time Lord]]s have a twelve [[regeneration]] limit, consisting of thirteen incarnations. [[The Valeyard]] would later be introduced in [[TV]]: ''[[The Mysterious Planet (TV story)|The Mysterious Planet]]'' as a manifestation of the Doctor from "between his twelfth and final incarnations." Some readers have determined, as a result, that the [[The Doctor (Alien Bodies)|final Doctor]] seen in [[PROSE]]: ''[[Alien Bodies (novel)|Alien Bodies]]'' would be the [[Thirteenth Doctor]], having used up all twelve regenerations by the time of [[War in Heaven|the War]].<ref>{{cite web|url=https://mysite.science.uottawa.ca/rsmith43/cloister/goth.htm|title=Goth Opera|author=Wilson, Anthony|website name=The Cloister Library|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref>
 
The unproduced 1980s play ''[[The Inheritors of Time (stage play)|The Inheritors of Time]]'', written with the continuity guidance of [[Terrance Dicks]], was set after the Doctor's death at the end of his thirteenth life so as to not contradict television continuity. The Doctor's corpse (having been kept around by the Time Lords in case of an emergency) would have been resurrected using a sliver of regeneration energy leftover from ''[[The War Games (TV story)|The War Games]]'', creating a new Fourteenth Doctor. ([[DWM 341]])


Eventually, Steven Moffat decided to write his way out of the regeneration limit by having the Time Lords grant the Doctor a new [[life cycle|regeneration cycle]] in [[TV]]: ''[[The Time of the Doctor (TV story)|The Time of the Doctor]]'', in order to allow the franchise to continue without breaking [[continuity]] with earlier ''Doctor Who'' serials, which he respected.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.digitalspy.com/tv/doctor-who-50th-anniversary/a533505/doctor-who-steven-moffat-on-regeneration-limit/|title='Doctor Who': Steven Moffat on regeneration limit|author=Rigby, Sam|date of source=24 November 2013|website name=Digital Spy|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref>
Eventually, Steven Moffat decided to write his way out of the regeneration limit by having the Time Lords grant the Doctor a new [[life cycle|regeneration cycle]] in [[TV]]: ''[[The Time of the Doctor (TV story)|The Time of the Doctor]]'', in order to allow the franchise to continue without breaking [[narrative continuity]] with earlier ''Doctor Who'' serials, which he respected.<ref>{{cite web|url=https://www.digitalspy.com/tv/doctor-who-50th-anniversary/a533505/doctor-who-steven-moffat-on-regeneration-limit/|title='Doctor Who': Steven Moffat on regeneration limit|author=Rigby, Sam|date of source=24 November 2013|website name=Digital Spy|accessdate=12 January 2022}}</ref>


=== Death Comes to Time ===
=== An alternate ending ===
''[[Death Comes to Time (webcast)|Death Comes to Time]]'', produced years following the [[Doctor Who (TV story)|introduction]] of [[Paul McGann]]'s [[Eighth Doctor]] but before plans were announced to revive the series, was an attempt to create a story that would act as the series finale for ''Doctor Who'' altogether. This ending would dovetail into a spin-off that would be the spiritual successor to ''Doctor Who'', called ''The Minister of Chance''. The would-be finale depicts [[Seventh Doctor]], as ever portrayed by [[Sylvester McCoy]], making a final sacrifice, and an implied downfall of the Time Lord society prior to the events of the story, as the few Time Lords seen in the story are stated to be the last alive. The Doctor's [[companion]], [[Ace (Death Comes to Time)|Ace]], also ends up on her own, solemnly telling [[The Brigadier (Death Comes to Time)|the Brigadier]] about the Doctor's demise. However, because the Doctor's body is never found, his final fate is unclear.
[[File:Death comes to time 01.jpg|thumb|The Doctor's final adventure?]]
''[[Death Comes to Time (webcast)|Death Comes to Time]]'', produced in the years following the [[Doctor Who (TV story)|introduction]] of [[Paul McGann]]'s [[Eighth Doctor]] but before plans were announced to revive the series, was an attempt to create a story that would act as the series finale for ''Doctor Who'' altogether. This ending would dovetail into a spin-off that would be the spiritual successor to ''Doctor Who'', called ''The Minister of Chance''. The would-be finale depicts the [[Seventh Doctor]], as ever portrayed by [[Sylvester McCoy]], making a final sacrifice, and an implied downfall of the Time Lord society prior to the events of the story, as the few Time Lords seen in the story are stated to be the last alive. The Doctor's [[companion]], [[Ace (Death Comes to Time)|Ace]], also ends up on her own, solemnly telling [[The Brigadier (Death Comes to Time)|the Brigadier]] about the Doctor's demise. However, because the Doctor's body is never found, his final fate is unclear. Freedman explained that his plans for the ''Doctor Who'' reboot which would have followed on from ''Death Comes to Time'' would have been to carry on with a different main character picking up the Doctor's legacy, but that eventually, the Doctor would have been revealed to have survived, possibly even as [[Paul McGann]]'s [[Eighth Doctor]], though with the full circumstances of his survival regeneration left ambiguous and presumably not matching the events depicted in [[Doctor Who (TV story)|the 1996 TV movie]].  


''Death Comes to Time'' would be referred to in several valid sources including, ironically, the [[BBC Eighth Doctor Adventures]]. Furthermore, ''[[Zagreus (audio story)|Zagreus]]'' implies that the story takes place in an [[alternate reality]] which is glimpsed by the Eighth Doctor.
''Death Comes to Time'' would be referred to in several valid sources including, ironically, the [[BBC Eighth Doctor Adventures]]. Furthermore, ''[[Zagreus (audio story)|Zagreus]]'' implies that the story takes place in an [[alternate reality]] which is glimpsed by the Eighth Doctor.
=== Video game mechanics ===
In video games such as ''[[The Adventure Games]]'', the Doctor is susceptible to being killed by enemies such as the [[Dalek]]s and the [[Cybermen]], at which point the game resets to an earlier point.


=== Non-narrative sources ===
=== Non-narrative sources ===
Line 107: Line 163:
== Footnotes ==
== Footnotes ==
{{reflist}}
{{reflist}}
{{TitleSort}}
{{TitleSort}}


[[Category:The Doctor]]
[[Category:The Doctor]]
[[Category:Death and mortality]]
[[Category:Death and mortality]]

Latest revision as of 18:14, 3 November 2024

This article needs to be updated.

This article needs to be updated to include details about the doctor's death in the newly-valid Death Comes to Time (webcast) in a section similar to #Parallel World (Turn Left)

These omissions are so great that the article's factual accuracy has been compromised. Check out the discussion page and revision history for further clues about what needs to be updated in this article.

The Eleventh Doctor enters the TARDIS, he thinks, for the last time. (TV: Closing Time)

Much like their origin, the Doctor's death was a matter of conflicting accounts and alternate timelines. (PROSE: Alien Bodies, TV: The Impossible Astronaut, The Name of the Doctor) By some accounts, this occurred to the Doctor's final incarnation in most Doctors' relative future. (PROSE: Alien Bodies)

The Doctor's mortality[[edit] | [edit source]]

Through their ability to regenerate, the Doctor was able to "cheat death" on numerous occasions. (TV: The Tenth Planet, The Parting of the Ways) However, the Tenth Doctor noted that he could be killed without allowing for regeneration. (TV: The End of Time) As such, the Doctor was not truly immortal, which the Fifth Doctor deemed impossible even for a Time Lord. (TV: The Five Doctors) Even allowing for regeneration, the Tenth Doctor regarded the change it entailed as a form of death. (TV: The End of Time)

Visiting the Garden of Fond Memories on Necros, the Sixth Doctor was shocked to find a statue made in his likeness, which he took as evidence that he would die without regenerating. He noted to Peri Brown that, being a time traveller, it was possible for them both to travel to a point after they had died. Peri, however, believed that the statue was a "joke" and a "gag", that someone was "having [him] on". To their shock, the statue fell on top of the Doctor, apparently crushing him, only for the Doctor to push aside the statue, finding that it was not genuine stone rather "an elaborate theatrical effect." The Doctor later determined that Davros, who had masqueraded as the Great Healer of Necros, was responsible for the statue; he complimented Davros on its "very good likeness" but added that "[he] really shouldn't have bothered." (TV: Revelation of the Daleks)

"I never thought precognisance of my own death would be so disturbing."Sixth Doctor [src]

The Valeyard was introduced to the Sixth Doctor by the Tremas Master as "an amalgamation of the darker sides of [his] nature, somewhere between [his] twelfth and final incarnation." (TV: The Ultimate Foe) In a story related by the Valeyard, the thirteenth and final incarnation of the Doctor supposedly composed a set of scrolls which detailed his work to bypass the limit of twelve regenerations and that the Valeyard himself was created as a Time Tot on a mud planet orbiting Etarho as a result of the Doctor's experiments. The Valeyard's claim, however, was doubted by the Sixth Doctor. Indeed, the Doctor found what appeared to be his final incarnation on Etarho to have been the Valeyard masquerading as him. The Doctor later reflected that "the Matrix awaits us each and every Time Lord." (AUDIO: Trial of the Valeyard)

Following their forgotten ninth incarnation and an incident which saw the Tenth Doctor regenerate but keep the same face, the incarnation who identified as the Eleventh Doctor emerged as the product of the Doctor's twelfth regeneration, the last of their original life cycle, and so believed himself to be "the last Doctor" until the Time Lords enabled him to regenerate again. (TV: The Time of the Doctor, AUDIO: Regeneration Impossible) The Twelfth Doctor, (TV: Kill the Moon) the Master (TV: The Doctor Falls) and even Rassilon himself were uncertain as to how many regenerations the Doctor now possessed. (TV: Hell Bent)

When the Thirteenth Doctor visited Daughter of Mine to free her from the mirror in which she was imprisoned, Daughter of Mine mentioned a redheaded Doctor who "thought he was the last", which the present Doctor did not recognise. (WC: The Shadow in the Mirror) Time told the Doctor that she would not outrun her. Claiming that the Doctor's time was heading to its end, Time warned:

"Nothing is forever. No regeneration, no life."Time. [src]

When the Eleventh Doctor's timeline became distorted, the Curator was seen as one of his future incarnations, at the end of his lifespan opposite the First Doctor. (COMIC: The Then and the Now) However, the Thirteenth Doctor would make a discovery which indicated that the First Doctor himself had followed earlier lives that were struck from the Doctor's memories. (TV: The Timeless Children [+]Loading...["The Timeless Children (TV story)"])

The Doctor on death[[edit] | [edit source]]

After the TARDIS became "stalled in the equivalent of a galactic lay-by", the Sixth Doctor had a worried thought of Peri Brown growing old and dying in the TARDIS, while he would "go on regenerating until all [his] lives [were] spent". (TV: Vengeance on Varos)

The War Doctor, upon being warned by the Moment that there would be consequences should he use her to destroy the Time Lords and the Daleks, told her that he had no desire to survive the Time War, to which she responded that the consequence would be that he would live. (TV: The Day of the Doctor)

Whilst facing the Gelth with Rose Tyler, the Ninth Doctor, recalling things he had seen and experienced, was openly disturbed at the prospect of dying "in a dungeon in Cardiff". (TV: The Unquiet Dead) Later, he accepted his death at the hands of the Dalek Emperor's Daleks of human origin, only to be saved by Rose as the Bad Wolf. (TV: The Parting of the Ways)

Impact on the universe[[edit] | [edit source]]

Due to their impact on the universe, having "touched so many lives" and "saved so many people", the prospect of the Doctor's death would affect a great many people. Indeed, from an alternate reality in which River Song refused to kill the Doctor, news that the Doctor was dying led millions, all across time and space, to offer their help. (TV: The Wedding of River Song) At the same time, Vislor Turlough, companion to the Fifth Doctor, noted that the Doctor had many enemies who would delight in his death, an observation which Kamelion concurred with. (TV: The Caves of Androzani) However, even the Tremas Master once remarked that "a cosmos without the Doctor scarcely bears thinking about." (TV: The Five Doctors) Multiple occasions in which the Doctor was killed prematurely resulted in stars burning out across the universe. (AUDIO: The Furies, TV: Turn Left, The Name of the Doctor)

Two companions of the Twelfth Doctor, Bill Potts and Nardole, came to believe it was the Doctor's actions that ensured good always triumphed over evil in the universe, meaning that the Doctor's possible death would have dire effects for the cosmos. (TV: Twice Upon a Time) Indeed, the Fourth Doctor knew that humanity was able to defeat the Daleks on many occasions in part because of he and his other selves continued their interventions. (AUDIO: Energy of the Daleks) The Twelfth Doctor acknowledged the danger of his first incarnation choosing to die before doing the things that he was "supposed to do" and, after spending some time resisting regenerating even it if meant his final death, ultimately conceded to the TARDIS that the "silly old universe" still needed saving and that "[they'd] get it all wrong without me." (TV: Twice Upon a Time)

In a possible future stemming from the Eighth Doctor's life, (PROSE: The Tomorrow Windows) what appeared to be the final death of an alternate Twelfth Doctor led the Master and a shipful of Daleks, who were saved when the Doctor stopped their Zectronic Beam Controller from imploding, to openly renounce their evil ways. (TV: The Curse of Fatal Death)

Impact on the TARDIS[[edit] | [edit source]]

In an alternate timeline, the Doctor's dying TARDIS served as his tomb. (TV: The Name of the Doctor)

Anticipating his death in battle against the Daleks, the Ninth Doctor expected that the TARDIS would ultimately die without him, deeming that preferable to falling into Dalek hands. (TV: The Parting of the Ways) After the Tenth Doctor died in a parallel world, Rose Tyler believed that the TARDIS was dying. (TV: Turn Left) Experiencing a potential future in which he died on Trenzalore, the Eleventh Doctor observed the future TARDIS's size leak to be a sign that it was dying. The Doctor identified that the TARDIS was now his tomb, now containing his time stream. (TV: The Name of the Doctor)

Impact on companions[[edit] | [edit source]]

Denial and regret[[edit] | [edit source]]

Sarah Jane Smith tearfully urged the dying Third Doctor not to die. (TV: Planet of the Spiders) Later on, Rose Tyler tried to assert that the Tenth Doctor couldn't die, since she'd only just found him. (TV: The Stolen Earth) Having been made aware of the prophecy which foretold the end of the Tenth Doctor, Wilfred Mott tearfully pleaded with the Doctor not to let himself die. (TV: The End of Time)

Bernice Summerfield, who had previously travelled with the Seventh Doctor, told the Eighth Doctor that, while he may change, he would never die. (PROSE: The Dying Days)

After the Twelfth Doctor's apparent death, Bill Potts told him she'd never believe he was really dead, because "one day everyone's just going to need [him] too much." She brought him into the TARDIS, as "the only place he'd rest in peace", if he could do that anywhere. (TV: The Doctor Falls)

After the Eleventh Doctor's supposed death at Lake Silencio, Amy Pond needed desperately to talk with him to understand what happened. When River Song visited, Amy solemnly noted she was still having adventures with a younger Doctor, running around with him, while for Amy, the Doctor was already dead. Amy was gleeful when she found out that he'd survived. (TV: The Wedding of River Song)

A feeling inside the heart[[edit] | [edit source]]

Before encountering the Tenth Doctor, Sarah Jane Smith believed that the Doctor had died, having left her for so long without returning. (TV: School Reunion) However, by another account, Sarah Jane always believed that when the Doctor died, she would know, because she would feel it. Jo Jones believed the same thing, having travelled with the Third Doctor:

"Even if he was as far away as Metebelis Three, [...] I'd feel it, you know, in my heart."Jo Jones [src]

When the Shansheeth brought news of the Doctor's supposed death, Sarah knew he was still alive, and proclaimed that she would find him. Rani Chandra thought of all the lives he'd touched on Earth, and was saddened that the whole world wasn't mourning. The Eleventh Doctor later reunited with Sarah Jane and Jo, putting these claims to rest. (TV: Death of the Doctor)

Death and regeneration[[edit] | [edit source]]

Close encounters[[edit] | [edit source]]

Before regenerating, the Fifth Doctor said it seemed "different this time", and worried that he might actually die from the spectrox toxaemia. However, visions of his companions urged him to go on. The Tremas Master's assertion that he must die stirred the Doctor to finally regenerate. (TV: The Caves of Androzani)

According to one account, a Twelfth Doctor believed that exposure to a zectronic beam had destroyed his ability to regenerate, anticipating his final death. However, in a feat which the Master deemed to be impossible, he nevertheless regenerated into the Thirteenth Doctor, with Emma supposing that "maybe even the universe can't bear to be without the Doctor." (TV: The Curse of Fatal Death)

Complete death[[edit] | [edit source]]

Inside the morgue, the Eighth Doctor finally takes his first breath. (TV: Doctor Who)

The Eighth Doctor was nearly unique amongst his other incarnations in that he was technically dead both when he regenerated from the Seventh Doctor and when he regenerated into his successor. Following a non-fatal shooting, the Seventh Doctor was taken to a San Francisco hospital, where subsequent exploratory surgery by Grace Holloway with a camera accidentally clogged a vein; the anaesthetic he had been given delayed regeneration for several hours and almost destroyed the process. (TV: Doctor Who) The Eighth Doctor himself died aboard Cass Fermazzi's gunship when it crash-landed on Karn, but was resurrected for four minutes by the Sisterhood of Karn, enabling him to regenerate into the War Doctor. (TV: The Night of the Doctor)

After beginning to regenerate on a Mondasian colony ship, the Twelfth Doctor declared that he didn't want to go on, telling his would-be successor to "let go" and interrupting the regenerative process by triggering a huge explosion, killing himself in the process. Bill Potts found his body, and, with Heather's help, brought him back to the TARDIS, believing it to be "the only place he'd rest in peace, if there's any place he'd do that". However, before saying her final goodbyes, Bill (now made of sentient oil like Heather), left him one of her tears, stating that "where there's tears, there's hope". After Bill and Heather left, the tear reignited a small burst of regeneration energy; awakening, the Twelfth Doctor had visions of past companions saying his name, and on hearing Missy's voice, he awoke and began regenerating in earnest again. He halted it again through sheer willpower, (TV: The Doctor Falls) entering a state of grace during which he was restored to full health but had a short window of time in which to decide whether to let himself die as he was, or let himself regenerate completely into a new Doctor. After an encounter with the First Doctor and the Testimony Foundation's "ghosts" of his last few companions, as well as input from the TARDIS herself, he finally allowed himself to regenerate. (TV: Twice Upon a Time)

Myths[[edit] | [edit source]]

"We Killed the Doctor Dead!" was a song sung by the Scorchie Mr Grizzfizzle, with Cool Cat and the Magic Mice doing backup. Through this song they informed Jo Grant that they killed the Third Doctor. The song was reprised when the Scorchies discovered that the Doctor was not dead. (AUDIO: The Scorchies)

Ubankan ship[[edit] | [edit source]]

According to one account, at some point between his flight from Gallifrey and his first confrontation with Omega, the Doctor was fated to die in the void of space near a Ubankan ship, trying and failing to reach his TARDIS before he asphyxiated. Because he wished for the Doctor to be available at a later point to the White Guardian as a pawn in the quest for the Key to Time, God allowed him to miraculously survive, sending him a bubble of air. (PROSE: Power to the People)

War in Heaven[[edit] | [edit source]]

By one account, the Doctor died during the War in Heaven. His body became known as "the Relic", which contained all the Doctor's knowledge. It was contained within a glowing metal box with two Greek letters on it, and was planted in a bunker beneath the ruins of Smithmanstown on Dronid, where it was found by the Corporation. (PROSE: Alien Bodies)

Bernice Summerfield tried and failed to locate the Doctor's remains, finding only empty graves. (PROSE: The Shape of the Hole) The Eighth Doctor later destroyed the Relic inside his TARDIS, having found it at an auction in the Unthinkable City. (PROSE: Alien Bodies)

Lake Silencio[[edit] | [edit source]]

Even on pre-Time War Gallifrey, (AUDIO: Songs of Love) it was a matter of historical record that the Eleventh Doctor was killed at Lake Silencio, Utah on the planet Earth at 5:02 PM on 22 April 2011 at the hands of River Song, born Melody Pond. Knowing this, the crew of the Teselecta, a ship of the Justice Department which operated to inflict "hell" on unpunished criminals, deviated from their mission to punish Adolf Hitler when they discovered River. It was through this encounter that a younger version of the Eleventh Doctor became aware of his recorded death. (TV: Let's Kill Hitler)

Though at first the Doctor was willing to accept his coming death, (TV: Closing Time) he later found a way around this fixed point in time by asking the Teselecta crew for help. To preserve history, the Teselecta took on the form of the Eleventh Doctor, taking his place in the events to follow. (TV: The Wedding of River Song) River Song was procured by the Kovarian Chapter of the Silence, and placed in a space suit beneath Lake Silencio, (TV: Closing Time) where she would be made to shoot the Doctor, causing a brief regeneration before cutting this short with her second blast. (TV: The Impossible Astronaut)

River Song's World[[edit] | [edit source]]

In a new timeline, River Song refused to play her part, creating an unstable alternate reality in which all of Earth's history took place at once. On discovering that the Eleventh Doctor was safe on board the Teselecta, however, during her wedding with the Doctor, River initiated contact with him again, allowing time to continue, as it had before. (TV: The Wedding of River Song) Afterwards, River Song was imprisoned at the Stormcage Containment Facility, on charges of murder, (TV: Flesh and Stone) for having "killed" the Doctor. (TV: The Wedding of River Song) She went on many adventures with the Doctor during her imprisonment, (HOMEVID: First Night, Last Night) and became known for escaping, (AUDIO: The Bekdel Test) though she always returned in the end, to serve her sentence. (TV: A Good Man Goes to War) Missy was among those who believed the Doctor to be dead, and so claimed herself to be the last living Time Lord in the universe before she met River and learnt that the Doctor had survived, (AUDIO: The Bekdel Test) coming to realise that he was responsible for saving her. (TV: Death in Heaven) During an adventure with a younger Doctor, River refused to reveal the name of the man she'd killed. (TV: Flesh and Stone)

River Song was later released, since it seemed the man she killed had never existed, when the Eleventh Doctor expunged any details about himself from all records. (TV: The Angels Take Manhattan)

Trenzalore[[edit] | [edit source]]

Original timeline[[edit] | [edit source]]

In one timeline, (TV: The Time of the Doctor) the Eleventh Doctor died on Trenzalore in a great battle. He was buried inside his TARDIS, which grew to an enormous size due to size leakage, acting as his tomb. As the Eleventh Doctor explained, the TARDIS was dying as well.

The Doctor arrives on Trenzalore. (TV: The Name of the Doctor)

In a confrontation with the Doctor and Clara Oswald, the Great Intelligence entered the Doctor's time stream in the Doctor's tomb, which he used to attack his entire timeline, turning all his victories into defeats. As a result, the Doctor was, as Vastra put it, "dying all at once", including as the Fifth Doctor on Androzani and as the Eleventh Doctor in the Dalek Asylum. These deaths were averted when Clara herself entered the time stream, splintering herself into echoes who saved the Doctor, across all known incarnations. (TV: The Name of the Doctor)

New timeline[[edit] | [edit source]]

Later on, Clara Oswald helped create a new timeline by convincing the Time Lords to grant the Doctor a new regeneration cycle, allowing him to regenerate on Trenzalore. Back in his TARDIS, the Eleventh Doctor regenerated into the Twelfth Doctor. (TV: The Time of the Doctor)

Alternate realities[[edit] | [edit source]]

When the TARDIS crashed on Tick-Tock World, the First Doctor, along with Ian Chesterton and Barbara Wright, were devoured by the Xesto, creatures that consumed time and all possible futures. He then woke up in a dream-like dimension, encountering other alternative outcomes of how he could have been devoured. A woman helped him to make contact with Susan, as the state of "death" on the planet meant someone would be disposed outside time itself. As he was fading away, he realised the woman was an older version of his granddaughter, and he persuaded the younger Susan to touch her older self. Their violation of the Blinovitch Limitation Effect caused an explosion which allowed the older Susan to avert the original crash, by having her original self to suggest her grandfather to shut down the defence systems of the ship. (AUDIO: Tick-Tock World)

In an alternate timeline created by Mortimus using the Chronovore Artemis, (PROSE: No Future) the Third Doctor was killed by Morka during his confrontation with the Silurians, resulting in humanity being decimated as the Silurians attempted to return Earth to its original state. (PROSE: Blood Heat)

As the Lord of the Manor, a future version of the Fifth Doctor who had lived somewhere between 100,000 and a million years, ruling over Stockbridge, the Doctor finally died when the original Doctor collapsed the time bubble in which the town had been contained. (AUDIO: The Eternal Summer)

In a timeline where a Dalek invasion of Earth in 1903 was thwarted by the Sixth Doctor and Evelyn Smythe, the British government trapped the Doctor in the Tower of London along with the two surviving Daleks to keep him as a symbol of their victory, cutting off his legs in order to keep him trapped. Driven insane over the years, the Doctor sometimes spoke to hallucinations of Evelyn after she died of old age, not even fully aware when a younger Evelyn came to see him in the Tower. He was eventually exterminated by the last surviving Dalek when it came to ask him for orders as it didn't know what else to do with itself. (AUDIO: Jubilee)

When Rose Tyler changed history by saving the life of her father, Pete Tyler, Reapers appeared and consumed the Ninth Doctor as he tried to protect his human company. Exclaiming that the Doctor was dead, Rose blamed herself. However, Pete gave his life to stop the Reapers by stepping in front of the car that killed him, resulting in the return of the Doctor along with everyone else the Reapers had consumed. (TV: Father's Day)

In an aborted timeline, the Saxon Master claimed he had killed the Thirteenth Doctor by throwing her into the heart of a star, after she escaped from being shackled in its orbit. (AUDIO: Masterful)

In the final minutes of 31 December 2021, the Doctor was exterminated by Dalek Executioners. Due to a temporary time loop created by the TARDIS, she was exterminated and brought back multiple times before managing to survive and destroy the Daleks. (TV: Eve of the Daleks)

Parallel World (Turn Left)[[edit] | [edit source]]

Without Donna Noble, the Doctor's confrontation with the Racnoss ended in his death. (TV: Turn Left)

A parallel world was created when a fortune teller fitted a Time Beetle of the Trickster's Brigade to Donna Noble, companion of the Tenth Doctor, changing her past so that on one day she turned right rather than left. The ensuing chain of events meant that she never met the Doctor and so was not there to stop him when he drowned the Racnoss, resulting in him dying with them before he could regenerate, his body being retrieved by UNIT along with the TARDIS. In the following years, the Earth was devastated by alien invasions which the Doctor would have stopped. Allies of the Doctor, both those he had met and those he would have met, opposed these incursions in his stead but most of them were killed. Eventually, the stars themselves began to go out, a result of the reality bomb. Rose Tyler, a former companion who returned from Pete's World, came to Donna and saw that she was sent back in time using what remained of the TARDIS, which she believed to be dying. Donna herself gave her life so that her past self would be forced to turn left, thus correcting history. (TV: Turn Left)

Other universes and dimensions[[edit] | [edit source]]

The death of the "Time Lord Victorious". (COMIC: Four Doctors)

In one parallel universe, Ruth Mills knew about the Doctor's regeneration limit. She forced him to regenerate into a new incarnation, then killed him too, musing about how many times she'd have to do this before the Doctor was dead. (AUDIO: Full Fathom Five)

In a timeline created by a continuity bomb where the Tenth Doctor embraced the title of "Time Lord Victorious" and became a mad tyrant who ruled over time and space, a Raxacoricofallapatorian shot him dead without regeneration. (COMIC: Four Doctors)

Duplicates[[edit] | [edit source]]

The Eleventh Doctor's Ganger sacrificed himself and Ganger Miranda to stop Ganger Jennifer, setting the sonic screwdriver to a frequency that would cause the Flesh to collapse, in full knowledge that this would destroy him too so that the others would be encouraged to negotiate better conditions for the Gangers. (TV: The Almost People)

Behind the scenes[[edit] | [edit source]]

Meta-narrative[[edit] | [edit source]]

Many commentators have pointed out that regeneration was introduced to recast William Hartnell because if the Doctor ever died, "the show would end."[1][2][3] This was what Steven Moffat has called "a clever way to solve a staffing problem"[4]. This narrative technique is what has allowed the character of the Doctor to survive through 60 years of television history, shaking up the core dynamic of the series each time a new lead actor is cast, rather than ending when the core cast has left, as many other series do.

However, this same problem has caused problems for suspension of disbelief. For example, TV: The Impossible Astronaut sets up the expectation that the Eleventh Doctor will die in the series finale. Though this left fans speculating about how the Doctor will evade death this time — with theories ranging from "the Doctor used his Ganger"[5] to "the Doctor we've been following is the Ganger"[6] — the weight of the Doctor's true, final end would act on no one, because, to anyone engaging with the material, the Doctor's death could only spell one thing: the end of the programme.[7]

Sensationalism[[edit] | [edit source]]

Remembrance of the Daleks ended its first episode with the Seventh Doctor at the mercy of a Dalek.

The Doctor's death was teased by the title of the fifth episode of The Chase, "The Death of Doctor Who", which ultimately referred to the destruction of the First Doctor's robotic duplicate. Years later, the Eleventh Doctor made his appearance in The Sarah Jane Adventures story Death of the Doctor, which featured his staged funeral.

Numerous cliffhangers have shown the Doctor to be on the brink of death or even seemingly killed, only for them to escape. For instance, the first episode of Revelation of the Daleks has the Sixth Doctor apparently crushed by a memorial statue made in his likeness, only for the next episode to open with him pushing aside the fake statue. Aliens of London ends with the Ninth Doctor among those who are subjected to a fatal electric shock by the Slitheen, then World War Three opens with the Doctor surviving due to his non-human physiology. Controversially, the "Next Time" trailer for World War Three revealed the Doctor's survival immediately following Aliens of London's cliffhanger; later trailers would be placed following the closing credits. This trend is even poked fun at in-universe in Hell Bent, where the Twelfth Doctor interrupts his own story at a point where he has supposedly been shot by Rassilon's firing squad, to which Clara Oswald remarks "you like a cliffhanger, don't you."

Regeneration limit[[edit] | [edit source]]

"Regeneration number thirteen" indefinitely expanded the lifespan of the Doctor and the series. (TV: The Time of the Doctor)

The 1976 serial TV: The Deadly Assassin set a challenge in establishing that Time Lords have a twelve regeneration limit, consisting of thirteen incarnations. The Valeyard would later be introduced in TV: The Mysterious Planet as a manifestation of the Doctor from "between his twelfth and final incarnations." Some readers have determined, as a result, that the final Doctor seen in PROSE: Alien Bodies would be the Thirteenth Doctor, having used up all twelve regenerations by the time of the War.[8]

The unproduced 1980s play The Inheritors of Time, written with the continuity guidance of Terrance Dicks, was set after the Doctor's death at the end of his thirteenth life so as to not contradict television continuity. The Doctor's corpse (having been kept around by the Time Lords in case of an emergency) would have been resurrected using a sliver of regeneration energy leftover from The War Games, creating a new Fourteenth Doctor. (DWM 341)

Eventually, Steven Moffat decided to write his way out of the regeneration limit by having the Time Lords grant the Doctor a new regeneration cycle in TV: The Time of the Doctor, in order to allow the franchise to continue without breaking narrative continuity with earlier Doctor Who serials, which he respected.[9]

An alternate ending[[edit] | [edit source]]

The Doctor's final adventure?

Death Comes to Time, produced in the years following the introduction of Paul McGann's Eighth Doctor but before plans were announced to revive the series, was an attempt to create a story that would act as the series finale for Doctor Who altogether. This ending would dovetail into a spin-off that would be the spiritual successor to Doctor Who, called The Minister of Chance. The would-be finale depicts the Seventh Doctor, as ever portrayed by Sylvester McCoy, making a final sacrifice, and an implied downfall of the Time Lord society prior to the events of the story, as the few Time Lords seen in the story are stated to be the last alive. The Doctor's companion, Ace, also ends up on her own, solemnly telling the Brigadier about the Doctor's demise. However, because the Doctor's body is never found, his final fate is unclear. Freedman explained that his plans for the Doctor Who reboot which would have followed on from Death Comes to Time would have been to carry on with a different main character picking up the Doctor's legacy, but that eventually, the Doctor would have been revealed to have survived, possibly even as Paul McGann's Eighth Doctor, though with the full circumstances of his survival regeneration left ambiguous and presumably not matching the events depicted in the 1996 TV movie.

Death Comes to Time would be referred to in several valid sources including, ironically, the BBC Eighth Doctor Adventures. Furthermore, Zagreus implies that the story takes place in an alternate reality which is glimpsed by the Eighth Doctor.

Video game mechanics[[edit] | [edit source]]

In video games such as The Adventure Games, the Doctor is susceptible to being killed by enemies such as the Daleks and the Cybermen, at which point the game resets to an earlier point.

Non-narrative sources[[edit] | [edit source]]

The final objective of the online video game NOTVALID: The Last Dalek was for the player-controlled Dalek to exterminate the Ninth Doctor and destroy the TARDIS.

Footnotes[[edit] | [edit source]]

  1. King, S.W. (4 May 2013). 50th Anniversary Blues. The Edwardian Adventurer. Retrieved on 12 January 2022.
  2. A.B., Digital Spy Forum. Twelfth Night: Adventures in Time and Space with Peter Capaldi. Edited by Andrew O'Day.
  3. Several authors. Fridge / Doctor Who – Meta. TV Tropes. Retrieved on 12 January 2022.
  4. Redfern, Mark (1 July 2008). Doctor Who's New Showrunner Remains Tightlipped. Under The Radar Magazine. Retrieved on 12 January 2022.
  5. Brew, Simon (6 June 2011). Doctor Who series 6: the loose threads still to resolve. Den of Geek. Retrieved on 12 January 2022.
  6. McMillan, Graeme (27 August 2011). Doctor Who Season 6: 5 Things To Remember About The Story So Far. CBR. Retrieved on 12 January 2022.
  7. Several authors (29 April 2011). Responses to "A spoileriffic Doctor Who question". The Reinvigorated Programmer. Retrieved on 12 January 2022.
  8. Wilson, Anthony. Goth Opera. The Cloister Library. Retrieved on 12 January 2022.
  9. Rigby, Sam (24 November 2013). 'Doctor Who': Steven Moffat on regeneration limit. Digital Spy. Retrieved on 12 January 2022.