The Doctor Falls (TV story)

The Doctor Falls
Doctor:	Twelfth Doctor
Companion(s):	Bill, Nardole
Featuring:	Missy, the Saxon Master, Heather, First Doctor
Main enemy:	Cybermen
Main setting:	Mondasian colony ship: Floor 1056 and Floor 0507
Key crew
Writer:	Steven Moffat
Director:	Rachel Talalay
Producer:	Peter Bennett
Release details
Story number:	275b
Premiere broadcast:	1 July 2017
Premiere network:	BBC One
Format:	1x60 minute episode
Doctor Who television stories
← Previous	World Enough and Time

The Doctor Falls was the twelfth and final episode of the tenth series of Doctor Who produced by BBC Wales. It saw the departures of both Bill Potts and Nardole, and the apparent end of the Master's life.

Expanding on the Twelfth Doctor's regeneration teased in the previous episode, it saw him mortally wounded in battle against the Cybermen. The regeneration would be postponed, however, as the Doctor refused to change, displaying how he hates having to be different people when he grows accustomed to being in an incarnation for a long period of time, mirroring the Tenth Doctor's attitude towards the process.

The episode also shows the events leading to the Saxon Master's regeneration into Missy, with the male Master being mortally wounded by his female successor, and he in turn seemingly killing her, this being an example of why, unlike the Doctor who has teamed up with his past and future incarnations, the Master very rarely works with any of his past or future incarnations as he would eventually double-cross himself. With the mystery of how the Master had regenerated into Missy now being shown, this would mark the last appearance of John Simm as the Harold Saxon incarnation of the Master.

The story featured several connections to the 1966 serial The Tenth Planet, including a story featuring humans from Mondas and featured appearances by the Cybermen from said planet.

More surprisingly, the episode featured the unexpected return of the First Doctor, now portrayed by David Bradley (who had previously portrayed William Hartnell in the docudrama An Adventure in Space and Time). This marks the first time since The Five Doctors that the adult First Doctor had been portrayed outside of archive footage, with the First Doctor as a child appearing in the Series 8 episode Listen, and the second time since The Tenth Planet where the First Doctor was in a regular episode of the show, even though it was a short appearance.

Synopsis

As he struggles to resist regenerating, the Twelfth Doctor prepares to make a last stand against the ever growing army of Cybermen. However, with Bill still a Cyberman, and Missy gradually turning to her old ways as the Saxon Master reminds of her of who she used to be, can the Doctor convince his old friend to finally be good before he falls?

Plot

The episode opens to a group of farmers on Floor 0507 facing against the prototypes from Floor 1056, shooting them down by night to then restrain on wooden crosses by day. A school child is out in the field one morning when a shuttlepod blasts through the ground. From the rubble, a Cyberman walks out carrying an unconscious Doctor.

Sometime earlier, the Doctor awakes on top of the hospital, soon recalling how he was subdued by Missy and the Master. The Doctor, now restrained in a wheelchair, watches the two incarnations of the Master taunt him on the many deaths the Doctor has had and wanting to find out new ways to kill him. The Master and Missy dance and flirt with each other and gloat of their plan of the Cybermen converting all the humans on the ship. However the Master is stunned to find that the Cybermen are heading towards the building that they are perched on. The Doctor explains that when he was knocked down by Missy, he altered the signal of the Cybermen so they would convert two-hearted beings as well, hence why they are now focusing on the Time Lord's presence. The Masters panic, Missy frantically using her sonic umbrella to lock a metal door to hold back advancing Cybermen while the Master uses his laser screwdriver to destroy advancing Cybermen. The Doctor brags that he is the only one who is has able to stop so many Cybermen at once. Realising this, a conflicted Missy knocks the Master out and frees the Doctor from his restraints. The Doctor starts wondering which side she is on to which she admits her indecisiveness as she is confused and her other half is unconscious.

Nardole, who had commandeered a shuttlecraft, lands near the roof to help escape, but the Doctor is grabbed and electrified by a Cyberman before he boards. Bill, in her cyber form, intervenes, destroying the Cyberman with a blaster based on her head. Missy and the Master try to convince Nardole to abandon the Doctor, but Bill prevents the shuttle from leaving, grabbing the ladders until they rescue him.

They escape to a higher floor on the ship, where time moves slower. They find themselves on a solar farm, where some of the humans and a large number of children protect themselves from the early Cybermen prototypes from Operation Exodus. They spend two weeks there while the Doctor recovers from his injuries. Bill awakes, in the barn, unsure why the villagers are scared on her. When given a mirror by a child, she becomes horrified to discover she was converted into a Cyberman. The girl goes to run but bumps into the Doctor who thanks her for being kind to Bill, offering her a jelly baby as she leaves. The Doctor has somewhat recovered from his injuries, though he still ha a scar from where he was hit by the Master.

Trying to console Bill, she gradually realises that though she thinks she is human, she is still a Mondasian Cyberman in appearance, created by a perception filter, according to the Doctor. She grows angry, the Doctor backing away as Bill accidentally triggers the blaster on her head, igniting the door on the barn, causing an explosion. Nardole, who has been preparing the town for the oncoming Cybermen, passively tells the farmers not to worry.

Bill sheds a tear when she realises the humans are frightened of her, and the Doctor wipes it away, noting it unusual. The Master tells the Doctor that he and Missy have been working on something, and pauses briefly to mock Bill, chastising the Doctor for still referring to her as a female and taunts how he hated the time he had to spend with Bill as "Razor". He stops because Bill claims he is not upsetting her, though she cries beneath her mask when he leaves. The Doctor finds it odd she is still able to shed tears. While traversing after the Master, the Doctor struggles to walk, limping heavily. He briefly stumbles against a tree, regeneration energy attempting to trickle from his hand. Wanting to not worry Bill, he draws up a stick and carries onwards but Bill is still distraught that the Doctor can't fix her current condition, the Doctor remarking there is still hope as she is strangely able to cry.

They soon reach the middle of a forest where Missy has discovered a camouflaged lift in the nearby forest, which she suggests they can escape to the bridge, using her sonic umbrella to call it. However, the Doctor declares that there will no doubt be a Cyberman in the lift waiting to find their floor, as the lift was taken to the bottom by them previously. Understanding this, Bill orders them to stand aside, the Doctor convincing the two Masters to do so. The three Time Lords prepare behind Bill, drawing their respective devices. As guessed, the lift brings up an advanced Cyberman from the lower floor, Bill speedily firing on it with her cyber blaster, the Master following likewise with his laser screwdriver as the Doctor and Missy use their sonic devices to slow its advance with a barrier. After several seconds, they disable it.

The Doctor warns that (through the Cybernet) they will now have much more time to plan, given they now know what floor they reside on, so they must prepare for a battle. While Nardole discovers that the floor below this one has many fuel pipes that he can detonate as weaponry against the Cybermen, the Doctor finds a conduit to another solar on a higher floor that can be used to evacuate the children, knowing this is a fight they will likely lose. The Master and Missy decide to leave and plan to find the Master's TARDIS at the lowest floor. The Doctor runs after the two Masters, pleading for them to be by his side to help, as doing so would just be kind. The Master ridicules the idea, saying that he didn't listen to a word the Doctor said. However Missy was somewhat moved by the Doctor's speech. However she sides with her predecessor.

At the lift, Missy tricks the Master into dancing with her and fatally stabs him, forcing his next regeneration. She announces she will return to help the Doctor, but when she turns her back, he fires his laser screwdriver at full blast, also fatally wounding her and disabling her regeneration. The Master comments that it is the perfect ending, with them both shooting themselves in the back. They both laugh as they die; the Master descends in the lift as Missy seemingly dies from the blast.

An initial wave of Cybermen arrive, but using Nardole's tricks with the explosives, they are able to make the humans appear more powerful, forcing the Cybermen to retreat and develop a new plan, giving the humans more time. Against Nardole's protests, the Doctor downloads the plans for the floor into his sonic screwdriver and sends him to help evacuate the children, intending to stay alone to fight the Cybermen. Nardole resists, the pair arguing over who really should die, the Doctor eventually convincing him helping the children will be his penance for his crimes he committed before meeting him. Bill also insists on staying with the Doctor despite Nardole trying to tell her otherwise. With all the humans evacuated, the Doctor ignites all the pipes below the floor, engulfing it all in a wave of destruction. All the Cybermen are killed, but the Doctor is severally wounded. Bill, still as a Cyberman, comes to mourn over the Doctor's body, but suddenly she finds herself out of the Cyberman suit, seemingly human, thanks to Heather (from The Pilot) who found her by her tear and restored her to be like she is now. They take to the Doctor's body to the TARDIS, and Heather, as the Pilot, directs the TARDIS to a new location, while offering Bill to live out a different life, and Bill accepts. Before leaving, Bill sheds a tear on the Doctor, but does not wipe it away, saying "Where there's tears, there's hope."

The TARDIS lands in an icy planet. The Doctor wakes up and starts regenerating. He tries fighting it off, in his confusion he starts recalling the last words of some of his previous incarnations. He also hallucinates several of his past companions. He controls the regeneration, angrily stating that he does not want to change again, hating the fact he becomes someone else. He steps outside into the snow and yet again his regeneration starts. The Doctor screams no and stops the regeneration by shoving his fists into the snow, again stating he will not change. Suddenly in the distance he hears a voice mocking his words. The stranger asks for the Doctor's identity. The stranger states that while the Doctor may be a Doctor, he "is the Doctor, the original you may say". Much to the Doctor's shock and surprise the stranger is revealed to be his own first incarnation.

Cast

• The Doctor - Peter Capaldi
• Bill - Pearl Mackie
• Nardole - Matt Lucas
• Missy - Michelle Gomez
• The Saxon Master - John Simm
• Hazran - Samantha Spiro
• Alit - Briana Shann
• Gazron - Rosie Boore
• Rexhill - Simon Coombs
• Heather - Stephanie Hyam
• Voice of the Cybermen - Nicholas Briggs

and

• The Doctor - David Bradley

Crew

Executive Producers   Steven Moffat and Brian Minchin

Written by Steven Moffat	Produced by Peter Bennett	Directed by Rachel Talalay	Director of Photography Ashley Rowe	Production Designer Michael Pickwoad	Visual Effects Milk BBC Wales VFX
Make-up Designer Barbara Southcott	Casting Director Andy Pryor CDG	Music Murray Gold	Costume Designer Hayley Nebauer	Edited by Will Oswald	Special Effects Real SFX
Original theme music by Ron Grainer  •  Titles by BBC Wales Graphics  •  With thanks to the BBC National Orchestra of Wales  Music conducted & orchestrated by Alastair King  •  Music score assistant - Jack Sugden   •  Music mixed by Jake Jackson  •  Music recorded by Gerry O'Riordan  Cybermen created by Kit Pedler and Gerry Davis

General production staff Head of Production - Gordon Ronald Production Executive - Tracie Simpson Line Producer - Steffan Morris Production Manager - Adam Knopf Location Manager - Iwan Roberts Unit Manager - Beccy Jones Production Co-ordinator - Sandra Cosfeld Assistant Production Co-ordinator - Nicola Chance Production Assistants - Virginia Bonet, Paige Woodward, Jamie Shaw Unit Drivers - Paul Watkins, Jolyon Davey Unit Medic - Glyn Evans Business Affairs Executive - Carol Griggs Production Accountant - Simon Wheeler Assistant Accountant - Matthew Fisher Script department Script Editor - Nick Lambon Script Executive - Lindsey Alford Assistant Script Editor - Emma Genders Camera and lighting department 1st Assistant Director - Dan Mumford 2nd Assistant Director - James DeHaviland 3rd Assistant Director - Christopher J Thomas Assistant Directors - Rhun Llewleyn, Lauren Pate, Kieran Hayhow Script Supervisor - Nicki Coles Camera Operator - Mark McQuoid Focus Pullers - Jonathan Vidgen, Elhein De Wet Grip - John Robinson Assistant Grip - Sean Cronin Camera Assistants - Gethin Williams, Drew Marsden, Chris Jacobi, Dan Patounas Gaffers - Mark Hutchings, Andy Gardiner Best Boy - Gawain Nash Electricians - Gareth Sheldon, Bob Milton, Sion Davies, Andrew Williams	Art department Supervising Art Director - Dafydd Shurmer Art Director - Tim Overson Art Department Accountant - Bethan Griffiths Production Buyer - Jen Saguaro Set Decorator - Adrian Anscombe Prop Buyers - Jo Pearce, Charlotte Lailey de Ville Storyboard Artist - Mike Collins Concept Artist - Sam Lamont Graphic Artist - Christina Tom Standby Props - Matt Ireland, Jonathan Barclay Standby Carpenter - Paul Jones Prop Hands - Nigel Magni, Faith Summers, Tom Leaman Standby Art Director - Nick Murray Rigging - Shadow Scaffolding Standby Rigger - Colin Toms Head Scenic Artist - Clive Clark Painters - John Nelms, Steve Nelms, Paul Murray, Tara McCourt Storeman - Matt Watts Prop Master - Paul Smith Props Chargehand - Scott Howe Props Driver - Gareth Fox Construction Manager - Terry Horle Construction Chargehand - Dean Tucker Construction Driver - Jonathan Tylke Construction Labourer - Jason Tylke Practical Electricians - Callum Alexander, Austin Curtis Graphics Assistant - Jack Bowes Draughtsperson - Matt Sanders Carpenters - Tim Burke, Keith Richads, Matt Ferry, Campbell Frazer, Chris Daniels, Joe Painter, George Rees, Dan Berrow, Tom Berrow Title Concept - Billy Hanshaw Costume department Costume Supervisor - Gayle Woodsend Assistant Costume Designer - Elizabeth Richards Costume Assistants - Rebecca Cunningham, Leila Headon, Jenny Tindle	Make-up and prosthetics Make-up Supervisor - James Spinks Make-up Artists - Megan Bowes, Lolly Goodship, Derek Lloyd, Cathy Davies Movement Stunt Co-ordinators - Crispin Layfield, Derek Lea Stunt Performers - Troy Kenchington, Andrew Burford, Freddie Mason Choreographer - Ailsa Berk Casting Casting Associate - Ri McDaid-Wren Casting Assistant - Louis Constantine General post-production staff Post-production Supervisor - Samantha Price Post-production Co-ordinator - Hannah Jones Assistant Editor - David Davies On-line Editors - Geraint Pari Huws, Christine Kelly Special and visual effects VFX Editor - Dan Rawlings Special Creature Effects & Prosthetics - Millennium FX Colourist - Gareth Spensley Model Makers - Alan Hardy, Jamie Thomas Sound Sound Recordist - Deian Llŷr Humphreys Dubbing Mixer - Mark Ferda Sound Maintenance Engineers - Tam Shoring, Christopher Goding Dialogue Editor - Darran Clement ADR Editor - Matthew Cox Sound Effects Editor - Harry Barnes Foley Editor - Simon Clement Foley Artist - Julie Ankerson

Not every person who worked on this adventure was credited. The absence of a credit for a position doesn't necessarily mean the job wasn't required. The information above is based solely on observations of the actual end credits of the episodes as broadcast, and does not relay information from IMDB or other sources.

References

Vehicles

• Nardole pilots a shuttle labelled SL-16.

Music

• The song heard when Missy and the Master are dancing on the rooftop is "Midnight, the Stars and You" by Al Bowlly.

Story notes

• This marks David Bradley's first appearance as the First Doctor in a DWU television story. Bradley previously portrayed a fictionalised version of William Hartnell, the original actor to portray the First Doctor, in the non-DWU docudrama An Adventure in Space and Time, in which Bradley reenacted scenes from several First Doctor serials.
• The Doctor's mention of Marinus as a planet on which the Cybermen originated (COMIC: The World Shapers) is another rare instance of the TV series directly referencing non-televised material.
• This episode wraps up the stories of several recurring characters;
  • Bill and Heather begin their own travels through time and space, Bill leaving the Doctor behind in the TARDIS.
  • Nardole stays behind on the Mondasian ship to help Hazran and her children escape the Cybermen.
  • The Saxon Master is forced to regenerate by Missy after she stabs him. Both agree that he then regenerates into Missy, in his own TARDIS, and he forgets the whole adventure.
  • Missy is killed by her previous incarnation, left unable to regenerate. In their own words, they were stabbed in the back by themselves.

Ratings

• 3.75m (UK overnight figures)

Filming locations

to be added

Production errors

If you'd like to talk about narrative problems with this story — like plot holes and things that seem to contradict other stories — please go to this episode's discontinuity discussion.

to be added

Continuity

• The Doctor recalls last seeing Missy's predecessor heading to Gallifrey, deducing that the Time Lords cured his "little condition" before kicking him out. (TV: The End of Time)
• The Master gloats over his dominion to a wheelchair bound Doctor just as he did with the aged Tenth Doctor during the Year That Never Was, (TV: Last of the Time Lords) and to a restrained Doctor upon the rise of the Master Race. (TV: The End of Time)
• The Doctor notes the Cybermen have risen naturally from Mondas (AUDIO: Spare Parts, TV: The Tenth Planet) Telos, (PROSE: Doctor Who and the Cybermen) Earth, (TV: Rise of the Cybermen / The Age of Steel) Planet 14 (TV: The Invasion) and Marinus. (COMIC: The World Shapers)
• The Doctor recounts his various victories over the Cybermen: on Telos where he sealed them into their ice tombs, (TV: The Tomb of the Cybermen) Voga, (TV: Revenge of the Cybermen), Canary Wharf (TV: Army of Ghosts / Doomsday) and Planet 14. (COMIC: The World Shapers, TV: The Invasion) He states: "Every single time, you lose, even on the Moon". (TV: The Moonbase).
• The Doctor reminds Bill how she remembered the truth during the reign of the Monks. (TV: The Lie of the Land)
• The Doctor reiterates his dislike of guns, (TV: The Sontaran Stratagem, The Doctor's Daughter, The Impossible Astronaut, The Curse of the Black Spot) despite having used them several times. (TV: Day of the Daleks, The Invasion of Time, Hell Bent)
• Nardole reminds Bill that he is still allowed to "kick [her] arse". (TV: Extremis)
• Nardole mentions how he used to be a black market dealer before meeting the Doctor, (TV: The Husbands of River Song) and further indicates he is a cyborg. (TV: Oxygen, The Eaters of Light, World Enough and Time)
• Missy is able to provide the Master with a dematerialisation circuit by telling him to always carry a spare, similar to how the Tenth Doctor told the Fifth Doctor how he could stop the TARDIS exploding. (TV: Time Crash)
• Missy telling her previous incarnation she loved being him also mirrors a sentiment of the Tenth Doctor, as he expressed such to his fifth incarnation. (TV: Time Crash)
• The Doctor reiterates River's words that Nardole once spoke to him from her diary. (TV: Extremis)
• Bill is reunited with Heather in the form of sentient oil. (TV: The Pilot)
• Missy uses her sonic umbrella. (TV: World Enough and Time)
• The Master asks the Doctor if he has ever burned to death. Although the Doctor hasn't, the Master has. (TV: Planet of Fire) Missy says that she knows the Doctor has literally fallen to his death as the Fourth Doctor regenerated as a result of falling off the Pharos Project's radio telescope. (TV: Logopolis) The Master asks if the Doctor has ever drowned, which he did while fighting the Racnoss in an alternate timeline. (TV: Turn Left).
• The Master uses a modified laser screwdriver. (TV: Last of the Time Lords)
• The Master reveals to Bill that he was Mr. Razor and that he hated the 10 years they spent together on floor 1056. (TV: World Enough and Time)
• The Master (seemingly) once again refuses to listen to the Doctor. (TV: Last of the Time Lords) However, Missy does, in the end, turn back to join him, as she has progressively had a change of heart. (TV: Extremis onwards)
• The Doctor has a brief recall of some of his past companions from his ninth incarnation onwards, just before his body attempts to regenerate. The Fourth and Fifth Doctor similarly had this occur to him. Likewise, the last face he sees is the Master's. (TV: The Caves of Androzani, Logopolis)
  • He recalls Rose Tyler from Bad Wolf, Martha Jones from Daleks in Manhattan, Donna Noble from Partners in Crime, Jack Harkness from Utopia, Vastra from The Name of the Doctor, Jenny Flint from The Crimson Horror, Sarah Jane Smith from The Stolen Earth, Amy Pond from The Impossible Astronaut, River Song from The Pandorica Opens, and even Clara Oswald from Last Christmas.
• When waking up after his pre-regeneration flashbacks, the Doctor says "Sontarans! Perverting the course of human history!". They were the first words of the Fourth Doctor after regenerating. (TV: Robot). He said the same statement after he woke up in the TARDIS during TV: Listen.
• As he begins regenerating, the Doctor says "I don't want to go", the exact same words his tenth incarnation said before regenerating. (TV: The End of Time) He also reiterates the last lines of his eleventh incarnation, (TV: The Time of the Doctor) as well as the final words the Tenth Doctor stated before his aborted regeneration. (TV: The Stolen Earth)
• The Doctor resists regenerating. He has previously done this when nearing the end of his fifth (TV: The Caves of Androzani) and tenth incarnations. (TV: The End of Time)
• The Doctor offers people jelly babies. (TV: The Three Doctors, Robot, et al.)
• The Master refers to the Doctor as "Doc". The Doctor's first incarnation had previously taken umbrage at being addressed like that (TV: The Time Meddler, The Five Doctors), as did his sixth (TV: The Twin Dilemma, The Ultimate Foe) and tenth. (TV: Dreamland)
• It was revealed Heather gave her tears to track Bill, explaining how Bill was still able to cry despite being a Cyberman. (TV: World Enough and Time)
  • The cyber-converted Yvonne Hartman, who had managed to retain her free will after conversion, also displayed the ability to cry; however, she cried oil rather than actual tears like Bill. (TV: Doomsday)
• The Doctor meets his first incarnation. He has met this version of himself on numerous previous occasions. (TV: The Three Doctors, The Five Doctors, The Day of the Doctor)
• The Doctor and Bill both recite the line "while there's tears, there's hope" at different points in the story. A similar line, "while there's life, there's hope," served as the final words of the Third Doctor in TV: Planet of the Spiders, while trying to console a crying Sarah Jane Smith.
• As the Doctor leaves the TARDIS the cloister bell is heard ringing.
• The Twelfth Doctor, and later the First Doctor, describe themselves as "the Doctor, the original you might say." The First Doctor previously said this exact phrase in TV: The Five Doctors, the first and only other televised story to feature the First Doctor portrayed by an actor other than William Hartnell.
• Missy severely injures one of her previous incarnations. The Master previously did this to himself in AUDIO: The Two Masters.
• Bill was strong enough to survive the cyber-conversion process while retaining her humanity, largely in part due to the strong attachment she had to her deceased mother. (TV: The Pilot et al.)
  • Yvonne Hartman and Mercy Hartigan were also able to retain their consciousness following their conversions. (TV: Doomsday, The Next Doctor)
  • The Doctor had previously encountered a version of Clara Oswald who had been strong enough to survive a Dalek conversion process and retain her humanity, she too had few memories of the conversion and believed she was still human. (TV: Asylum of the Daleks)
  • Craig Owens had previously been able to resist a Cyber-conversion due to his strong love for his son overpowering a damaged cyber-ship's conversion equipment. (TV: Closing Time)
• The Master being stranded by a malfunction, or by his TARDIS otherwise being unavailable to him, was a feature of several past stories, especially TV: The Claws of Axos and AUDIO: Sympathy for the Devil.

Home video releases

DVD releases

to be added

Blu-ray releases

to be added

Digital releases

to be added

External links

• Official The Doctor Falls page on the Doctor Who website